Lord Of Tea
Joined: 14/01/05
Posts: 36
|
Shielding guitar electronics
#1024497 - 16/12/12 03:21 AM
|
|
|
|
Just tried shielding a Strat copy (Aria STG) but it seems to make no difference. I put
baking foil around the pot and pickup cavity, the jack connector cavity and on the
underside of the scratch plate. I haven't tried putting foil arond the pick ups yet but
that's the next thing I'm intending to try.
Does anyone have any advice and or
previouse experience? Want to get this right on the Aria before I move on to my Fenders.
|
JM-1
Joined: 30/09/07
Posts: 604
|
Re: Shielding guitar electronics
[Re: Lord Of Tea]
#1024506 - 16/12/12 05:52 AM
|
|
|
Take a look at this: http://www.edgeguitarservices.co.uk/electric/rf_screening.htmIf it's for a guitar without antique value, you'd be far better off with a couple of
coats of conductive graphite paint than copper foil... Remember to paint on to
the surface of the body so as to make contact with the foil on the scratchplate. Also do
screen the cavity of the jack socket and the 'tunnel' that leads to it from the main
control cavity.
|
ef37a
Joined: 29/05/06
Posts: 5620
Loc: northampton uk
|
Re: Shielding guitar electronics
[Re: Lord Of Tea]
#1024532 - 16/12/12 12:00 PM
|
|
|
|
The efficacy of "electrostatic" screening of anything is dependant upon the conductivity
of the shield material. Copper will be better than graphite and Silver (used in RF kit)
would be better still (of the same coating thickness)but I doubt you would hear much
difference for an electric guitar.
The quotes are because screening the cavity
does not reduce "electromagnetic" pickup (might if you used "mu-metal"). I have a De Mazio
humbucker in a diecast box*. 100% heavy e'stat screening but it still hums if close enough
to a 50Hz traff.
*As a "proper" input load for amps. I had to fill the pot
with candle fat as well to mitigate microphony.
Dave.
|
Gary_W
Joined: 18/10/06
Posts: 376
|
Re: Shielding guitar electronics
[Re: Lord Of Tea]
#1024541 - 16/12/12 12:35 PM
|
|
|
The screening won't do anything if it is not connected to the screen of the guitar
cable. It's well worth investing a tenner in a multimeter. That way, you can
make sure that you have decent continuity to your pots in the first place. Once you've
established that, you can then use that 'know good earth'...... As long as your foil has
a firm mechanical connection to the earth you'll be fine  For a Strat, I like to take the hardware off the scratch plate and then apply a layer of
foil to the underside of it using spray on glue. Whilst it's drying, I put
foil inside the body cavity. I leave a tiny bit of foil overlapping in a few places so
that they are sticking out of the cavity. I also make sure the bridge is earthed - if it
isn't I sort that out. Ditto for any dodgy joints on the pots. In fact, I'll often
replace all the wiring - the standard of soldering often seems to be poor in cheaper
guitars. Once the scratchplate is dry I bolt the pots back on. Using my meter
I then ensure you have an earthed scratch plate. Then I bolt the scratch plate back in,
trapping the overlapping body cavity bits in there. Job done  . Obviously a Strat won't be as quiet as a properly screened humbucker equipped guitar but
doing the above turns a buzz monster into something far nicer.
|
Huge Longjohns
long-serving member
Joined: 10/04/03
Posts: 1356
Loc: Where the black rocks stand gu...
|
Re: Shielding guitar electronics
[Re: Lord Of Tea]
#1024674 - 17/12/12 10:52 AM
|
|
|
|
Yup, Gary is right. I use the self adhesive copper tape you can get on ebay for about £4
a roll. It's really easy to use, just line the scratchplate and all the cavities then
solder an earth wire from the foil to the back of the volume pot. It can make a huge
difference. Do it on a single coil guitar and it can turn really noisy into really
useable. Do it on a humbucker equipped guitar and you'll think your lead has fallen out
it's so eerily quiet!
-------------------- "Ignorance more frequently begets confidence than does knowledge" Charles Darwin.
|
Huge Longjohns
long-serving member
Joined: 10/04/03
Posts: 1356
Loc: Where the black rocks stand gu...
|
Re: Shielding guitar electronics
[Re: Lord Of Tea]
#1024675 - 17/12/12 10:56 AM
|
|
|
Copper tape Here's the stuff I use.
-------------------- "Ignorance more frequently begets confidence than does knowledge" Charles Darwin.
|
Lord Of Tea
Joined: 14/01/05
Posts: 36
|
Re: Shielding guitar electronics
[Re: JM-1]
#1024788 - 17/12/12 11:53 PM
|
|
|
|
I didn't shield the tunnel. Will get some conductive paint.
|
Lord Of Tea
Joined: 14/01/05
Posts: 36
|
Re: Shielding guitar electronics
[Re: Gary_W]
#1024790 - 17/12/12 11:57 PM
|
|
|
Quote Gary_W:
The screening won't
do anything if it is not connected to the screen of the guitar cable.
It's well
worth investing a tenner in a multimeter. That way, you can make sure that you have
decent continuity to your pots in the first place. Once you've established that, you can
then use that 'know good earth'...... As long as your foil has a firm mechanical
connection to the earth you'll be fine 
For a Strat, I like to take the hardware off the scratch plate and then apply a layer of
foil to the underside of it using spray on glue.
Whilst it's drying, I put
foil inside the body cavity. I leave a tiny bit of foil overlapping in a few places so
that they are sticking out of the cavity. I also make sure the bridge is earthed - if it
isn't I sort that out. Ditto for any dodgy joints on the pots. In fact, I'll often
replace all the wiring - the standard of soldering often seems to be poor in cheaper
guitars.
Once the scratchplate is dry I bolt the pots back on. Using my meter
I then ensure you have an earthed scratch plate. Then I bolt the scratch plate back in,
trapping the overlapping body cavity bits in there. Job done .
Obviously a Strat won't be as quiet as a properly screened humbucker equipped guitar but
doing the above turns a buzz monster into something far nicer.
I've checked the foil, pots, screws
and bridge with a multimeter and all seems to be earthed.But still the same hum.
|
zenguitar
active member
Joined: 05/12/02
Posts: 7593
Loc: Devon
|
Re: Shielding guitar electronics
[Re: Lord Of Tea]
#1024795 - 18/12/12 12:26 AM
|
|
|
Quote Lord Of Tea:
I've checked
the foil, pots, screws and bridge with a multimeter and all seems to be earthed.But still
the same hum.
I know exactly
what you mean. I used to spend hours methodically checking earths with a multimeter
without finding any problem. So as a last resort I would strip out all of the wiring loom,
clean all the pots and switches, use a nice solder pump, solder wick, and a file to clean
the surface of the contacts, I'd use some fine wet & dry paper to clean the jack socket,
and would then rewire from scratch with new hook-up cable.
And it always solved
the problem.
I have theories why it is the case, but can't be certain. However,
experience tells me that if I hear an obvious wiring problem it is a complete waste
of time trying to chase it down with a meter. OK, I've rewired a LOT of guitars,
but it always takes me less time to draw a schematic of the existing wiring, work out what
it is intended to do (and whether it will actually do that), remove the old loom, clean
up, and rewire properly.
Yeah, it's nice to know what was wrong, but it can be
a serious waste of time tracing it. Only worth doing on an instrument that would be
seriously devalued by rewiring from scratch.
Life is too short to waste on
tracing a hum that shouldn't be there. Just rip it all out and rewire from scratch.
Hook-up cable costs pennies.
Andy
-------------------- When the going gets weird, the Weird turn Pro.
|
Megacurve
Joined: 14/06/10
Posts: 13
Loc: Australia
|
Re: Shielding guitar electronics
[Re: Lord Of Tea]
#1024814 - 18/12/12 07:58 AM
|
|
|
I have a detailed article on shielding a strat, then changing to a bridge humbucker. http://www.artandtechnology.com.au/guitar/shielding-strat.htmlThis has a real short hum demo at the end showing that even with complete
shielding,single coils still hum. Even doing a really good shielding job
doesn't fix all the hum. The pickups stick out of the body and are great at picking up
hum. I use high gain, and the final fix for me was a DiMarzio single coil
format humbucker.
-------------------- Adrian Bruce
www.artandtechnology.com.au
|
Lord Of Tea
Joined: 14/01/05
Posts: 36
|
Re: Shielding guitar electronics
[Re: zenguitar]
#1025595 - 22/12/12 02:51 PM
|
|
|
Quote zenguitar:
Quote Lord Of Tea:
I've checked
the foil, pots, screws and bridge with a multimeter and all seems to be earthed.But still
the same hum.
I know exactly
what you mean. I used to spend hours methodically checking earths with a multimeter
without finding any problem. So as a last resort I would strip out all of the wiring loom,
clean all the pots and switches, use a nice solder pump, solder wick, and a file to clean
the surface of the contacts, I'd use some fine wet & dry paper to clean the jack
socket, and would then rewire from scratch with new hook-up cable.
And it
always solved the problem.
I have theories why it is the case, but can't be
certain. However, experience tells me that if I hear an obvious wiring problem it
is a complete waste of time trying to chase it down with a meter. OK, I've rewired a
LOT of guitars, but it always takes me less time to draw a schematic of the
existing wiring, work out what it is intended to do (and whether it will actually do
that), remove the old loom, clean up, and rewire properly.
Yeah, it's nice to
know what was wrong, but it can be a serious waste of time tracing it. Only worth doing on
an instrument that would be seriously devalued by rewiring from scratch.
Life
is too short to waste on tracing a hum that shouldn't be there. Just rip it all out and
rewire from scratch. Hook-up cable costs pennies.
Andy
Cheers Andy. I'll take your advice. I
have some shielded cable, is there any reason I shouldn't use that? Currently all the
looms are made up of unshielded single core.
|
zenguitar
active member
Joined: 05/12/02
Posts: 7593
Loc: Devon
|
Re: Shielding guitar electronics
[Re: Lord Of Tea]
#1025604 - 22/12/12 05:34 PM
|
|
|
Shielded cable can be very useful, especially for the link to the output socket. But it
does come with some caveats if you want to use it for all the hook-ups. And to be honest,
if the guitar is already screened there is little if any extra value to be had from using
screened cable. The main things to watch out for are ground loops, especially
on instruments where the pots and switches are mounted on a metal plate or a foil screened
scratchplate/cavity. The metal plate or foil screen will usually link the metal cases of
the pots and switches. So, whether you are using new pots and switches or re-using the
originals (after carefully cleaning the solder tags/bodies as I described), the best
approach is to fit them before making any connections and use your meter to check whether
or not the bodies of the parts have a continuity between them. If they do, your guitar is
well screened so just use normal hook-up wire and just use the screened cable for the
output. If most are connected, but one or two are not (maybe a tele with a pick
up selector on the top horn like a Les Paul, or a switch with a plastic body) use your
screened to connect to that part. But take care to avoid creating any ground loops when
you do. For example, a strat pick-up selector is connected to all three pots so if your
switch body needs a ground connection you only need to connect it to one of the pot bodies
using the screened cable. If you connect all 3 with screened cable you risk ground
loops. Hope that helps  Andy
-------------------- When the going gets weird, the Weird turn Pro.
|