mpostor
member
Joined: 04/09/03
Posts: 409
Loc: S.W. London
|
UPS recommendations
#987521 - 15/05/12 09:42 AM
|
|
|
Does anyone use a UPS to keep their FOH setup safe from accidental power outages? Can
anyone recommend a suitable device? I've got a Yamaha 01v96VCM with external pre-amps
and a CD player. Our lampy tripped the power at our last gig. It was only off for a
second, but it was enough to reset everything. I'd like to avoid that in the future (after
the gig we took the lampy outside and reset him with a mic stand; gave a new definition
for 'insert device'  ). Any suggestions of what to get or avoid would be appreciated. Thanks. Stu.
|
chris...
active member
Joined: 12/03/03
Posts: 4152
Loc: Glasgow
|
Re: UPS recommendations
[Re: mpostor]
#987538 - 15/05/12 10:34 AM
|
|
|
|
When you say "reset", does the 01V not boot and resume from where it was, once the power
returns ?
(I appreciate lots of other gear might not)
|
Hugh Robjohns
SOS Technical Editor
Joined: 25/07/03
Posts: 18368
Loc: Worcestershire
|
Re: UPS recommendations
[Re: mpostor]
#987549 - 15/05/12 11:03 AM
|
|
|
APC are amongst the industry leaders and I've always found their products to be very
cost-effective and reliable. http://www.apc.com/products/category.cfm?id=13You will
need to decide what power load, capacity, and run-time you require, and then find the
appropriate unit. The little Back-UPS models are quite popular amongst TV drama and Film
recordists. http://www.apcmedia.com/salestools/DFAH-8GLQK6_R0_EN.pdfhugh
-------------------- Technical Editor, Sound On Sound
|
mpostor
member
Joined: 04/09/03
Posts: 409
Loc: S.W. London
|
Re: UPS recommendations
[Re: chris...]
#987555 - 15/05/12 11:43 AM
|
|
|
Quote chris...:
When you say
"reset", does the 01V not boot and resume from where it was, once the power returns ?
(I appreciate lots of other gear might not)
Yes, the desk does resume where you left off, but only after a
lenghty reboot. There's also a spike sent down the audio lines when the pre-amps
start up as well. Done in the right sequence, as it is during setup, there's no
issues (PA is the last thing switched on). The momentary loss of power, followed by
restoration was enough to put a loud BANG through the PA. It was loud enough for someone
to come running in from another part of the building carrying a fire extinguisher. Yes, we've identified a failing in our working practices (the lampy), but we need to
look at how we can minimise problems when it happens again. I say 'when' because it would
be foolish to assume that it won't ever happen again, even if we are careful and we
prevent the lampy from touching anything.
Thanks for the APC info Hugh. I'll
look into them.
Cheers.
Stu.
|
chris...
active member
Joined: 12/03/03
Posts: 4152
Loc: Glasgow
|
Re: UPS recommendations
[Re: mpostor]
#987557 - 15/05/12 12:10 PM
|
|
|
|
Good luck!
|
seablade
Joined: 21/11/04
Posts: 3768
|
Re: UPS recommendations
[Re: mpostor]
#987566 - 15/05/12 12:50 PM
|
|
|
Quote mpostor:
Does anyone use a
UPS to keep their FOH setup safe from accidental power outages? Can anyone recommend
a suitable device? I've got a Yamaha 01v96VCM with external pre-amps and a CD
player. Our lampy tripped the power at our last gig. It was only off for a second,
but it was enough to reset everything. I'd like to avoid that in the future (after the gig
we took the lampy outside and reset him with a mic stand; gave a new definition for
'insert device' ).
Any suggestions of what to get or avoid would be appreciated.
Thanks.
Stu.
You need to make sure you have an 'online' UPS that is constantly powering the
equipment plugged into it from the battery. While not as common these days and 'offline'
UPS means that it will switch to the battery and sometimes this doesn't happen fast enough
to prevent problems in computer based equipment, thus why you may have had problems, or
else your battery is really shot if it really died in a fraction of a second(Assuming you
didn't have anything like a full amp rack on it).
And yes APC is considered
popular, to be honest they aren't really all that special in many ways. I am taking a
close look at the SurgeX offering in this area, who are very popular for their power
conditioning products to see how their new UPS system does.
Personally my
preference is to make sure the UPS is in a nice rolling rack, so I prefer not to mess with
the bricks Hugh posted for live sound. I can see why they would be popular for film
sound, but I prefer as much of my stuff to be rackmounted as possible.
Seablade
|
chris...
active member
Joined: 12/03/03
Posts: 4152
Loc: Glasgow
|
Re: UPS recommendations
[Re: seablade]
#987568 - 15/05/12 01:01 PM
|
|
|
Quote seablade:
'offline' UPS
means that it will switch to the battery and sometimes this doesn't happen fast enough to
prevent problems in computer based equipment, thus why you may have had problems,
That said, an offline UPS (designed
for computers) will hopefully be better than nothing (the current situation).
With an online UPS, would we expect a significantly greater chance off the UPS itself
failing (for whatever reason) hence taking down the show, while the raw mains feed
itself is perfectly fine ? With the offline UPS, at least the show is effectively
running off raw mains until something goes horribly wrong. Or am I being paranoid
?
Edited by chris... (15/05/12 01:13 PM)
|
Hugh Robjohns
SOS Technical Editor
Joined: 25/07/03
Posts: 18368
Loc: Worcestershire
|
Re: UPS recommendations
[Re: seablade]
#987571 - 15/05/12 01:10 PM
|
|
|
Quote seablade:
You need to make
sure you have an 'online' UPS that is constantly powering the equipment plugged into it
from the battery.
I don't
believe this is the case -- at least not for this application. And online UPS are
fiendishly expensive.
I have used simple off-line UPS systems with a Yamaha
DM1000 digital console, and it manages to flip over to battery power quite fast enough to
prevent the Yamaha from being aware of a mains outage. I also use larger off-line systems
to back up my desktop computer and NAS etc, again without any glitches during power
outages.
Quote:
Personally my preference is to make sure the UPS is in a nice rolling rack, so I prefer
not to mess with the bricks Hugh posted for live sound. I can see why they would be
popular for film sound, but I prefer as much of my stuff to be rackmounted as possible.
If you're trying to protect a
large system then a rolling rack makes a lot of sense -- UPS batteries are heavy, and big
capacity systems get extremely heavy, and who deosn't like rack-mounted gear? 
The model I linked to above was simply a suggestion of a small, compact and affordable
solution that would provide the required protection for a small digital desk, and which I
know from trusted feedback does the job adequately for those on a budget.
Hugh
-------------------- Technical Editor, Sound On Sound
|
seablade
Joined: 21/11/04
Posts: 3768
|
Re: UPS recommendations
[Re: chris...]
#987592 - 15/05/12 02:51 PM
|
|
|
Quote chris...:
Quote seablade:
'offline' UPS
means that it will switch to the battery and sometimes this doesn't happen fast enough to
prevent problems in computer based equipment, thus why you may have had problems,
That said, an offline UPS (designed
for computers) will hopefully be better than nothing (the current situation).
With an online UPS, would we expect a significantly greater chance off the UPS itself
failing (for whatever reason) hence taking down the show, while the raw mains feed
itself is perfectly fine ? With the offline UPS, at least the show is effectively
running off raw mains until something goes horribly wrong. Or am I being paranoid
?
Ahh sorry I
misunderstood, I thought you HAD a UPS and had the issue, my fault.
I haven't
had one fail in such a way yet myself.
Seablade
|
seablade
Joined: 21/11/04
Posts: 3768
|
Re: UPS recommendations
[Re: Hugh Robjohns]
#987594 - 15/05/12 02:53 PM
|
|
|
Quote Hugh Robjohns:
I
don't believe this is the case -- at least not for this application. And online UPS are
fiendishly expensive.
I have used simple off-line UPS systems with a Yamaha
DM1000 digital console, and it manages to flip over to battery power quite fast enough to
prevent the Yamaha from being aware of a mains outage. I also use larger off-line systems
to back up my desktop computer and NAS etc, again without any glitches during power
outages.
Yes you CAN
use offline without issues on occasion, in my experience it really varies on the quality
of the UPS and how picky my power supply is.
Quote:
If you're trying to protect a large system
then a rolling rack makes a lot of sense -- UPS batteries are heavy, and big capacity
systems get extremely heavy, and who deosn't like rack-mounted gear? 
The model I linked to above was simply a suggestion of a small, compact and affordable
solution that would provide the required protection for a small digital desk, and which I
know from trusted feedback does the job adequately for those on a budget.
Hugh
Yea don't get me wrong, as I
mentioned above there are places those make sense. Just in sound reinforcement I find the
rackmount units a better fit. Then again decent rackmount units do cost money.
Seablade
Who does have a couple of those bricks in his house for the
record.
|
chris...
active member
Joined: 12/03/03
Posts: 4152
Loc: Glasgow
|
Re: UPS recommendations
[Re: seablade]
#987686 - 15/05/12 11:17 PM
|
|
|
Quote seablade:
I haven't had one
fail in such a way yet myself.
With an online UPS, the load is always running from the batteries, right? So if the
batteries give out (e.g due to being too old - you should have replaced them months ago),
can that cause loss of power, where the mains itself is fine ? Or does old batteries
simply mean the autonomy time is poor ? Or maybe the online UPS can quickly switch the
load onto raw mains if the batteries fail. Or something.
I worry that you
protect against one type of problem, only to become vulnerable to another.
|
seablade
Joined: 21/11/04
Posts: 3768
|
Re: UPS recommendations
[Re: chris...]
#987694 - 16/05/12 12:48 AM
|
|
|
Quote chris...:
So if the
batteries give out (e.g due to being too old - you should have replaced them months ago),
can that cause loss of power, where the mains itself is fine ? Or does old batteries
simply mean the autonomy time is poor ?
The latter. And typically long before that you get annoying
beeping to alert you to your battery needing to be replaced.
Seablade
|
Jamie Taylor
Joined: 13/04/10
Posts: 4
Loc: London, England
|
Re: UPS recommendations
[Re: mpostor]
#990314 - 30/05/12 01:22 AM
|
|
|
|
I second Hugh on APC UPS' we use lots of them on our show (Jersey Boys London) for FOH
computers, samplers and the entire comms rig. They will need maintaining long term (the
batteries do not last forever) and I have known them to fail on very rare occasions but
the company that supplies the kit supply many very big shows and find them the most
reliable option.
-------------------- I do not regret the things I've done but those I did not do.
|