Main Forums >> Production - Mixing, Mastering, Gear & Techniques
        Print Thread

Pages: 1
Matt Houghton
SOS Reviews Editor


Joined: 08/08/07
Posts: 596
Ellie Goulding: 'Your Song'
      #903048 - 23/03/11 01:11 PM
Ellie Goulding’s tremendous vocal performance was more than enough to carry this song into the charts, but personally I can’t help being underwhelmed by the instrumental arrangement, which reminds me rather too much of something out of one of those ‘one man band’ arranger keyboards! I mean, come on — surely there’s more to life than eighth‑note piano chords? And I pity the poor, wasted cellist, whose only relief from uninspired chordal padding is the self‑conscious-sounding fill at 2:27. I’m not asking for jazz‑fusion here — the spotlight should undoubtedly remain on Ellie, after all — but those instrumental parts almost completely miss the opportunity to support or enhance the vocal line.

I’m not totally convinced by the sonics either, even though Goulding’s performance kicks arse and the vocal sound is pretty respectable too. The piano feels bass‑light, for a start, and the presence of a spurious sub‑50Hz environmental rumble at 1:08 suggests that this is down to recording choices, rather than filtering at mixdown. The cello sounds even more anaemic, as if it’s been miked too close to the instrument, and it doesn’t blend well with either the piano or vocal. Yes, I know, you could argue that this puts the project into the ‘authentically/endearingly rough‑hewn’ category, and that the overall lightweight mix tone deliberately serves to contrast with the rumbling LF of the climactic bass‑drum entry at 2:29 — but I just don’t buy it. For my money, Adele’s ‘Make You Feel My Love’ (which also recently enjoyed a return to the charts) works much better on all these counts — it’s got a more musical (though still reserved) arrangement, great‑sounding piano and string recordings, and some subtle low‑end support from an additional bass line. Mike Senior

For more critiques of commercial productions, browse The Mix Review Index

--------------------
SOS Reviews Editor

Edited by Jennifer Jones (25/07/11 10:23 AM)


Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator     Back to top
BenH
member


Joined: 15/08/03
Posts: 25
Loc: Caversham, UK
Re: Ellie Goulding: 'Your Song' new [Re: Matt Houghton]
      #903981 - 27/03/11 09:29 AM
I couldn't get on with the EG version of Your Song. I found EJ's original a bit cloying any way, and EG's glottal stops and general tweeness a bit irritating. But Mike's points on the arrangement and mix make a lot of sense, and are thought provoking. I wondered whether the piano had been intended as a component for a more elaborate arrangement - i.e. it wasn't originally intended to be as exposed as it is in this mix.

Great idea for a new column. Only problem is that I'll need to download the other two tracks, my daughter's Now That's What I Call Average collection not stretching to them...


Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator     Back to top
The Bunk



Joined: 29/12/07
Posts: 731
Loc: Surrey
Re: Ellie Goulding: 'Your Song' new [Re: Matt Houghton]
      #904061 - 27/03/11 03:52 PM
I was quite taken with EG's version at first - although maybe that was down to the warm glow I got from it being a John Lewis Xmas advert - but it soon wears off.
Can't really pass comment on the various EQ issues that arise as I'm no expert but I've been learning the original Elton John version on the piano and EGs version does miss out on some of the nicer features of the piano playing on the original. There's a couple of subtle chord variations (an F over a C descending to a C, and another F over an A rising to a Bb) which sound lovely when just played on their own.
My girlfriend also wanted to try singing it in the EG style, so I tried playing it in the eighth-note manner. It just doesn't work (although I am still a relative beginner so my touch may not be quite what's needed for it!) but there has to be something else going on to keep the song moving.


Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator     Back to top
shufflebeat



Joined: 09/12/07
Posts: 3222
Loc: Manchester, UK
Re: Ellie Goulding: 'Your Song' new [Re: The Bunk]
      #904097 - 27/03/11 06:50 PM
It reminded me of Sid Vicious doing "My Way". Worth hearing once but added nothing to the original.

I had high hopes for EG, the first time I heard "Starry Eyed" I told by music obsessed children to keep an eye on her as she was a distinctive voice with a refreshing energy to her performance. I bought the album, it had one other good song on it, "The Writer". Both went on the medicine box (iRiver H10). The CD hasn't left the case again.

When I heard "Your Song" I initially thought it was one of those Radio 1 live lounge sessions that pair artists with songs they are least likely to otherwise do. A great idea, BTW. With that in mind, I reasoned, the keys player could be forgiven for missing out some of the key chord changes which I now realised were an integral part of the movement of the dynamic and without which it sounded like a bad karaoke wedding.

The vocal is interesting insofar as it sounds like someone doing an impression of EG doing an EJ song but without those features that made EG stand out to me in the first place, originality and talent.

Would I have sold out in the same way for a lucrative advertising deal - bloody right, but let's not kid ourselves it's anything other than that.

--------------------
Dear Mr God,
We called but you were out - B Dylan Deliveries (Intntl)


Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator     Back to top
ian2



Joined: 09/10/04
Posts: 61
Loc: Oxfordshire, U.K.
Mix review review new [Re: shufflebeat]
      #904119 - 27/03/11 09:12 PM
Quote shufflebeat:

It reminded me of Sid Vicious doing "My Way". Worth hearing once but added nothing to the original.




shufflebeat, your mix review is a touch light on the mixing side of things. :-) But thank you for saying what I was thinking - I agree entirely with everything you've written!


Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator     Back to top
shufflebeat



Joined: 09/12/07
Posts: 3222
Loc: Manchester, UK
Re: Mix review review new [Re: ian2]
      #904136 - 28/03/11 12:33 AM
Quote ian2:

Quote shufflebeat:

It reminded me of Sid Vicious doing "My Way". Worth hearing once but added nothing to the original.




shufflebeat, your mix review is a touch light on the mixing side of things. :-) But thank you for saying what I was thinking - I agree entirely with everything you've written!




Fair point Ian. I've only heard the track on small DAB radio so haven't been in a position to study it in detail but don't think I've heard anything that couldn't have been done in a decent project studio.

I like the Mix Review concept, I see it as another angle on and a valid complement to the Classic Tracks feature. I think this track is an odd choice to start it on, though. I look forward to future editions where the hand of the mix engineer is more apparent.

--------------------
Dear Mr God,
We called but you were out - B Dylan Deliveries (Intntl)


Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator     Back to top
shufflebeat



Joined: 09/12/07
Posts: 3222
Loc: Manchester, UK
Re: Ellie Goulding: 'Your Song' new [Re: Matt Houghton]
      #904137 - 28/03/11 12:42 AM
BTW, am I losing the plot or did this thread change it's name?

--------------------
Dear Mr God,
We called but you were out - B Dylan Deliveries (Intntl)


Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator     Back to top
TheChorltonWheelie



Joined: 22/09/09
Posts: 1049
Re: Ellie Goulding: 'Your Song' new [Re: The Bunk]
      #904152 - 28/03/11 08:13 AM
Quote The Bunk:

I was quite taken with EG's version at first - although maybe that was down to the warm glow I got from it being a John Lewis Xmas advert - but it soon wears off.




It's truly, truly horrendous in every single respect: not only does she introduce her own melody, as Elton's clearly wasn't good enough for her, but the chord structure changed beyond all recognition as once again, Elton's original effort clearly didn't cut it.

As for her vocal/singing style, that's just plain awful.


Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator     Back to top
Mike Senior
SOS Mix Specialist


Joined: 08/08/03
Posts: 1393
Loc: Cambridge, UK
Re: Ellie Goulding: 'Your Song' new [Re: Matt Houghton]
      #904414 - 29/03/11 08:09 AM
I can see that this track has already sparked a fair bit of debate, which is great -- the purpose of the 'Mix Review' column is partly to get people talking more about commercial productions, so that we can all learn something! To answer shufflebeat's specific comment, though (namely that this track was an unusual choice to start the column on), I can see your point if you're looking at the column as being just about mixing. However, we've always wanted the column's reach to be wider than that, so that we can take in issues of writing, production and mastering, seeing as all of those can play important roles in the effectiveness of the final mix that's heard by the public at large. As such, I think the column is actually more an extension of 'Inside Track' or 'Mix Rescue' than it is of 'Classic Tracks'.

On the whole I'm trying to choose tracks which feel like they've got something interesting to teach the listener, rather than just because they're great songs or chart smashes -- there's often a lot more to learn from tracks which aren't as successful, in fact! That said, I am going to be focusing primarily on the Top Ten in general, rather than the whole Top 40, simply because it's more likely that the reader will have access to those tracks. Still, this column will continue to evolve, I'm sure, so do keep the feedback comments coming so that we can make it as useful as possible to the largest number of readers.

I reviewed this song from Ellie Goulding's Album 'Bright Lights', my copy of which includes 'Your Song' as a bonus track. The credits in the CD sleeve are:

Music by Elton John.
Lyrics by Bernie Taupin.
Produced by Ben Lovett.
Engineered and Mixed by Matt Lawrence.
Mastered by Naweed at Whitfield Mastering

--------------------
Mixing Secrets for the Small Studio
A complete mixing method based around the techniques of the world's most famous producers.


Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator     Back to top
shufflebeat



Joined: 09/12/07
Posts: 3222
Loc: Manchester, UK
Re: Ellie Goulding: 'Your Song' new [Re: Matt Houghton]
      #904652 - 29/03/11 11:40 PM
Yeah, I realised afterwards it was Inside Track I meant but thought I'll keep my head down and hope nobody noticed. Some chance...

There was some talk at one stage about a series building a mix from downloadable files. It was explained how this might throw up some issues (maybe I'm imagining all this). The Mix Review promises to explore the process in the same way but from a different angle.

Looking forward to it.

--------------------
Dear Mr God,
We called but you were out - B Dylan Deliveries (Intntl)


Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator     Back to top
Thomas Elise



Joined: 12/10/09
Posts: 45
Re: Ellie Goulding: 'Your Song' new [Re: Matt Houghton]
      #906204 - 05/04/11 10:54 PM
Interesting. Produced by Ben Lovett? As in.... Mumford & Sons???


Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator     Back to top
TapeOpAl



Joined: 11/01/08
Posts: 19
Loc: London, UK
Re: Ellie Goulding: 'Your Song' new [Re: Thomas Elise]
      #906267 - 06/04/11 10:14 AM
While I often have my own thoughts on ideas and opinions shared in SoS (as everyone should with every publication) I was thrilled to find that Mike Senior in some way shared my disdain for this song.

Ellie Goulding has also done a similarly pedestrian cover of Roscoe by Midlake - a great song that she makes no great contribution to.


Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator     Back to top
Mike Senior
SOS Mix Specialist


Joined: 08/08/03
Posts: 1393
Loc: Cambridge, UK
Re: Ellie Goulding: 'Your Song' new [Re: Thomas Elise]
      #906363 - 06/04/11 03:03 PM
Quote Thomas Elise:

Interesting. Produced by Ben Lovett? As in.... Mumford & Sons???




I believe so.

--------------------
Mixing Secrets for the Small Studio
A complete mixing method based around the techniques of the world's most famous producers.


Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator     Back to top
Mike Senior
SOS Mix Specialist


Joined: 08/08/03
Posts: 1393
Loc: Cambridge, UK
Re: Ellie Goulding: 'Your Song' new [Re: TapeOpAl]
      #906365 - 06/04/11 03:04 PM
Quote TapeOpAl:

While I often have my own thoughts on ideas and opinions shared in SoS (as everyone should with every publication) I was thrilled to find that Mike Senior in some way shared my disdain for this song.




It's us against the world!

--------------------
Mixing Secrets for the Small Studio
A complete mixing method based around the techniques of the world's most famous producers.


Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator     Back to top
Sam Inglis
SOS Features Editor


Joined: 15/12/00
Posts: 1723
Re: Ellie Goulding: 'Your Song' new [Re: TapeOpAl]
      #907365 - 11/04/11 01:06 PM
Quote TapeOpAl:


Ellie Goulding has also done a similarly pedestrian cover of Roscoe by Midlake




aaargh! Say it ain't so.


Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator     Back to top
bazmitch



Joined: 14/04/11
Posts: 6
Re: Ellie Goulding: 'Your Song' new [Re: Matt Houghton]
      #908078 - 14/04/11 08:34 AM
What a waste of a great song and a good singer.

Baz


Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator     Back to top
Tomás Mulcahy
active member


Joined: 25/04/01
Posts: 2954
Loc: Cork, Ireland.
Re: Ellie Goulding: 'Your Song' new [Re: Matt Houghton]
      #912916 - 07/05/11 11:35 AM
Have to agree with all of the above. Especially that the piano part sounds more like a place holder than an actual performance. And it's especially annoying that they missed out on the nice harmony, as already pointed out.

I did think that the vocal performance was good, and it's a better vocal recording than the rest of the album. Not that the other vocals are actually bad recordings, but they're not world class. A bit too sizzly for my taste.

--------------------
madtheory creations
Synths and pianos for Kontakt


Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator     Back to top
Hairy Ears
member


Joined: 06/09/03
Posts: 617
Loc: UK
Re: Ellie Goulding: 'Your Song' new [Re: Matt Houghton]
      #913263 - 09/05/11 12:21 PM
When this track first appeared I saw a comment from Mitch Benn that made me smile, along the lines of 'did nobody think to say to her "that's not how it goes"?'

Well, it amused me anyway

--------------------
* Soundcloud *
* Bandcamp *


Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator     Back to top
ian2



Joined: 09/10/04
Posts: 61
Loc: Oxfordshire, U.K.
Re: Ellie Goulding: 'Your Song' new [Re: Hairy Ears]
      #913349 - 09/05/11 05:58 PM
...all of which reminds me of a quip from a music teacher from my secondary school days. I think the context was his invitation to pupils to bring in something from their own music collection for the class to hear. One of the pupils, known to be a huge fan of Rush, suggested that he might bring in a Rush LP. Paraphrasing the music teacher (a bit more politely): "You're so crazy about Rush, if they released a record of themselves breaking wind on stage you'd probably want to buy it."





Disclaimer 1: I'm not impartial to a bit of Rush myself (although I wasn't that pupil and do have to draw the line somewhere!).

Disclaimer 2: Hearing one of Ellie Goulding's original tracks a week ago I was reminded how delightful her music can be.

Edited by ian2 (09/05/11 06:01 PM)


Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator     Back to top
TSH-Tim



Joined: 21/02/11
Posts: 828
Loc: Guildford
Re: Ellie Goulding: 'Your Song' new [Re: Matt Houghton]
      #913785 - 11/05/11 07:20 PM
Even though i don't understand everything talked about in these reviews i just want to say i love reading them and thank you my week would go very slowing without them

--------------------
PA Hire Surrey
Lighting Hire Surrey


Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator     Back to top
Pages: 1

Rate this thread

Jump to

Extra Information
1 registered and 7 anonymous users are browsing this forum.

Moderator:  David Etheridge, James Perrett, zenguitar, Martin Walker, Hugh Robjohns, Zukan, Frank Eleveld, SOS News Editor 
Forum Permissions
      You cannot start new topics
      You cannot reply to topics
      HTML is enabled
      UBBCode is enabled
Rating: *
Thread views: 9325

September 2014
On sale now at main newsagents and bookstores (or buy direct from the
SOS Web Shop)
SOS current Print Magazine: click here for FULL Contents list
Click image for September 2014
DAW Tips from SOS

 

Home | Search | News | Current Issue | Tablet Mag | Articles | Forum | Subscribe | Shop | Readers Ads

Advertise | Information | Privacy Policy | Support | Login Help

 

Email: Contact SOS

Telephone: +44 (0)1954 789888

Fax: +44 (0)1954 789895

Registered Office: Media House, Trafalgar Way, Bar Hill, Cambridge, CB23 8SQ, United Kingdom.

Sound On Sound Ltd is registered in England and Wales.

Company number: 3015516 VAT number: GB 638 5307 26

         

All contents copyright © SOS Publications Group and/or its licensors, 1985-2014. All rights reserved.
The contents of this article are subject to worldwide copyright protection and reproduction in whole or part, whether mechanical or electronic, is expressly forbidden without the prior written consent of the Publishers. Great care has been taken to ensure accuracy in the preparation of this article but neither Sound On Sound Limited nor the publishers can be held responsible for its contents. The views expressed are those of the contributors and not necessarily those of the publishers.

Web site designed & maintained by PB Associates | SOS | Relative Media