Stevedog
Joined: 01/09/04
Posts: 3002
Loc: Mercia
|
Re: Survey Of Working Dual-Core PC Music Systems
[Re: Martin Walker]
#270544 - 20/03/06 11:26 PM
|
|
|
The PCIe issues were mainly to do with addon cards like the UAD rather than basic
soundcards. I think, that by and large the later N4 boards have at least resolved some of
this problem and also people seem to say that running and X2 chip cleared the problem up
mostly anyway. Onething, and pain as it maybe, its worth doing a fresh install
of windows from word go for a new mobo. As for the help, no worries, this is to
a large degree one of the least judgemental music forums around. No matter how seemingly
*trivial* or *basic* a problem is there is usally someone around to at least point one in
the right direction. No one was born understanding how to mix, use compression,
or build a successful DAW we all learned , often the hard way, from somewhere or
someone. Ayway, good luck hope this helps resolve the problems
-------------------- nibbled to death by an Okapi http://www.soundclick.com/tubilahdog
|
Stevedog
Joined: 01/09/04
Posts: 3002
Loc: Mercia
|
Re: Survey Of Working Dual-Core PC Music Systems
[Re: Martin Walker]
#270548 - 20/03/06 11:31 PM
|
|
|
Damn ive made a bit of a boo boo here.... your Matrox AGP card wont run on a PCIe board
you will need to change it... many apologies.... Gigabyte GA-K8NS Ultra-939 nForce 3... if
you dont want to buy a new graphics card try looking for one of these boards from
Gigabyte. If not, most cheap vid cards have dual outputs on them these days.
-------------------- nibbled to death by an Okapi http://www.soundclick.com/tubilahdog
|
fdotbone
member
Joined: 07/02/04
Posts: 121
Loc: Zürich,Switzerland.
|
Re: Survey Of Working Dual-Core PC Music Systems
[Re: Stevedog]
#270549 - 20/03/06 11:33 PM
|
|
|
Hey Thanks again Stevedog , I've ordered the board , any thoughts on a Graphic card as it
will have to be a pci express!? bearing in mind the only game I ever played was pacman.It
just has to work. Thanks again
|
Stevedog
Joined: 01/09/04
Posts: 3002
Loc: Mercia
|
Re: Survey Of Working Dual-Core PC Music Systems
[Re: Martin Walker]
#270553 - 20/03/06 11:40 PM
|
|
|
Again im biased towards ATI cards cos i like the colour better than Nvidia boards... Make
of that what you will but like you i dont have any games on my system.  So id go for something like a Radeon X550
-------------------- nibbled to death by an Okapi http://www.soundclick.com/tubilahdog
|
Peter C
active member
Joined: 08/01/04
Posts: 3054
Loc: London, England
|
Re: Survey Of Working Dual-Core PC Music Systems
[Re: Stevedog]
#270574 - 21/03/06 12:48 AM
|
|
|
Hi, Quote Stevedog:
The PCIe issues were mainly to do with addon cards like the UAD rather than basic
soundcards.
I don't entirely
agree with this.
The problem lies in the support for PCI provided by the
nF4 PCIe switch. PCIe is now the principal data transport protocol on PCIe mobos, and the
legacy PCI bus is attached to the PCIe switch as a PCIe device.
Soundcards
certainly are affected, not jusst UADs and PoCos.
However it is true that
running an X2 alleviates the problems with the soundcards. I'd be happier if I had the
faintest idea why...
Peter
-------------------- PaQ
|
fdotbone
member
Joined: 07/02/04
Posts: 121
Loc: Zürich,Switzerland.
|
Re: Survey Of Working Dual-Core PC Music Systems
[Re: Peter C]
#270655 - 21/03/06 10:02 AM
|
|
|
Hi Peter C, thanks for your input.First to stevedog I'll probably go for a PCI express
graphics card.Thanks for your suggestions.On your point Peter C ,this is what I understood
as well regarding PCI express and this was part of my reason for going with a pure PCI
board in the form of the MSI above.Also I now remember reading the review in the January
issue of SOS of the Scan3XS which uses the ABiT AV8 board with the same VIA K8T800 pro
chipset ,same as the MSI I decided upon.I rather niavely, it seems now,thought that would
be ok!? I think ppl will now get the point that there are varying opinions on these issues
and consequently the less experienced of us,ie me, are prone to confusion.Anyhow I take on
board what you say.The question remains however if the chipset is the problem as Stevedog
thinks, then if I had bought a Scan 3XS would I have had the same problem with this
card.There's the rub.Ah well I shall keep you all posted on the outcome.If I have further
problems then it may be a faulty sound card or an even greater incentive to buy an Apple
Mac and logic!...lol...
|
fdotbone
member
Joined: 07/02/04
Posts: 121
Loc: Zürich,Switzerland.
|
Re: Survey Of Working Dual-Core PC Music Systems
[Re: fdotbone]
#271127 - 21/03/06 11:37 PM
|
|
|
Well here is an update on my situation for those who are interested.I bought today a Giga
byte GA-K8N Pro -SLI and a Gigabyte GV-RX60P128D Graphics card finished the windows
install about 9.30pm UK time.All fine installed the MaXio 032 card all fine for about 5
minutes then it all crashed.Couldn't even boot into safe Mode this time.Had to do a
Windows repair from the install CD.I had a email from the ESI support asking me to try the
card in a another system, so I have just written them to say I have and it has crashed.I
am now convinced the card has been defective all along.No component in this current except
the case and power supply, floppy is the same everything else is new.Currently listening
to the onboard soundcard, which I must say is rahter good actually.Will run the machine
all night without the card to make sure.Seems I got one built if a friday afternoon as
they used to say.I will keep you posted.
|
Stevedog
Joined: 01/09/04
Posts: 3002
Loc: Mercia
|
Re: Survey Of Working Dual-Core PC Music Systems
[Re: Martin Walker]
#271177 - 22/03/06 02:42 AM
|
|
|
Well if its any recompense... At least you have a system that will now work with any
number of other soundcards without any problems in all probability........... err fingers
crossed
-------------------- nibbled to death by an Okapi http://www.soundclick.com/tubilahdog
|
danilop
Joined: 20/03/06
Posts: 8
|
Re: Survey Of Working Dual-Core PC Music Systems
[Re: Martin Walker]
#271873 - 23/03/06 03:04 AM
|
|
|
Hi, My working dual-core setup: mobo: Asus P5P800 SE (AGP, 4xPCI)
CPU: Intel D 830 3.0 GHz dual core mem: 1 GB Audio: Terratec EWS88D DSP: Powercore PCI mkII, 2 x UAD-1 Note: After nightmare with new
Poco PCI mkII and my previous DAW (AMD XP2600+, ASUS A7N8X, ...), I've considered two
options for the new dual-core DAW: AMD64X2 and Intel D series. Ok, Intel is
slower than equivalent AMDx2, but at the moment, it is practically impossible to build a
AMD64X2 system which doesn't have issues with both UAD-1 and Powercore PCI mkII! So I've
played safe and built an Intel D system instead!. It works!  Cheers!
|
klagga
member
Joined: 15/05/03
Posts: 43
|
Re: Survey Of Working Dual-Core PC Music Systems
[Re: danilop]
#273354 - 25/03/06 05:20 PM
|
|
|
There seems to be a consensus around quite a few forums, for example the nuendo-forum http://www.nuendo.com/phpbb2/viewtopic.php?t=7386, that for an AMD X2
setup, the Asus A8V VIA mobo is among the best.
Problem is, they all say the
mobo has to come with an AGP graphics card to play it safe. Since motherboards with AGP
are getting old and rare, I would like to ask if you think this is still the case?
|
BigDave
Joined: 26/03/06
Posts: 2
|
Re: Survey Of Working Dual-Core PC Music Systems
[Re: Martin Walker]
#273678 - 26/03/06 02:40 PM
|
|
|
Hi Martin I am currently in the throes of changing our main studio machine & am
anxious not to waste money buying kit that is not going to do the job so any advice you
can offer would be gratefully be received. I am currently running an
athlon1800xp machine with a moto i/o24 & a motu 2408 mk3 using the motu proprietory pci
card with Logic 5.5 I do own a p4 3ghz system & an athlon64 3200 system & have
been wondering whether to just move my hardware into one of these machines as a temporary
measure, or to buy/build a new dual core box for the additional plug in power? I haven't seen any posts using the motu hardware so I wonder if anyone has heard
anything about any issues with it? My initial thoughts are to get an Asus a8v &
an athlon64 x2 but I am open to suggestions & want to keep latency to a minimum.
-------------------- BigDave - Merfangle Music
|
fdotbone
member
Joined: 07/02/04
Posts: 121
Loc: Zürich,Switzerland.
|
Re: Survey Of Working Dual-Core PC Music Systems
[Re: Stevedog]
#273857 - 26/03/06 09:10 PM
|
|
|
Just thought you ppl may be interested in the following regarding PCI express cards.... http://www.motu.com/newsitems/the-pcie-424-card-is-now-shippinghttp://www.maxioxd.com/ check
out the ESI Pci express card. Any reviews planned?
|
Martin Walker
Watcher Of The Skies
Joined: 28/02/01
Posts: 16477
Loc: Cornwall, UK
|
Re: Survey Of Working Dual-Core PC Music Systems
[Re: fdotbone]
#274035 - 27/03/06 09:55 AM
|
|
|
Excellent news fdotbone - at last we PC Musicians have some PCI Express interfaces to
consider. As soon as I've built my proposed PCIe-equipped PC we may well review
one of these  Thanks for the heads-up. Martin
-------------------- YewTreeMagic
|
BigDave
Joined: 26/03/06
Posts: 2
|
Re: Survey Of Working Dual-Core PC Music Systems
[Re: fdotbone]
#274064 - 27/03/06 10:52 AM
|
|
|
Thanks for the heads up fdotbone - the only problem is I see they are charging $295 to
upgrade the pci424 card to pcie. I look forward to a test of this in the near future. This now opens up the debate about motherboards again though - I believe pcie is
more stable on the pentium boards than the athlon boards?
-------------------- BigDave - Merfangle Music
|
Sam Handwich
new member
Joined: 09/03/04
Posts: 217
Loc: Actually, quite close by
|
Re: Survey Of Working Dual-Core PC Music Systems
[Re: Martin Walker]
#276038 - 30/03/06 07:10 PM
|
|
|
|
Just to add to that, TC Electronics have now announced that a PCIe Powercore will be
available in summer - no details, though. Time to abandon PCI-only mobos?
SH
-------------------- This message was sent from my I and I-phone, an' t'ing.
|
BassPilot
Joined: 06/04/06
Posts: 1
Loc: Kentucky, USA
|
Re: Survey Of Working Dual-Core PC Music Systems
[Re: Martin Walker]
#278936 - 06/04/06 12:20 AM
|
|
|
|
Hello to all.
After about 6 months of research, I built my DAW PC about 3 weeks
ago. Here's what I chose:
AMD Athlon 64 X2 4400+ (not overclocking at present),
Asus A8R-MVP Radeon Express 200 Crossfire mobo (with BIOS revision 0402), 2 x 1GB Corsair
Twinx3200C2 RAM (timing set at 2.5-3-3-6-1T), Antec Phantom 500-watt pwr supply, ATI
FireMV2200 128MB video card (thinking that I'd save on processor headroom with a
lower-capacity video card), 3 WD Caviar 7200RPM SATA 3Gb/s HDs in a RAID 5 array, 2 x Asus
DVD burners, WinXP SP2 with all updates.
My audio/MIDI interface is a Tascam
FW1082 (using version 1.50 of the XP drivers). It works very well with Cubase SX3.1 (once
I figured out how to set it up!), controlling all of the functions I care to access from
the control surface.
I purchased a single AGM Neovo 19" widescreen flat panel
for use initially and plan to purchase a second one soon, since I'm happy with the AGM's
performance in this application. The ATI card supports dual monitors.
Everything is very stable and I'm getting processor temps in the 35C range with two
stock case fans and the supplied processor cooling fan. Admittedly, I haven't been pushing
the system very hard yet. I'm still tweaking some settings in BIOS and the OS to determine
what will provide optimum performance.
This was a major upgrade for me, since
my old rig was a Yamaha MD-8 minidisk recorder synced to a Win95 PC (Pentium 100!!!). Hope
everyone else who decides to go the build-it-yourself route has as good an experience as I
have.
-------------------- BassPilot
|
Domsmart
Joined: 29/03/06
Posts: 90
|
Re: Survey Of Working Dual-Core PC Music Systems
[Re: Martin Walker]
#282309 - 13/04/06 11:59 AM
|
|
|
|
OK, I built the system...full component list is
Athlon 64 X2 4200 Asus
A8N32-SLi Deluxe nForce4 Corsair 2GB DDR XMS3200C2PT TwinX (2x1GB) CAS2 Tagan
TG530-U15 530W ATX2.01 Easycon SLi Compliant Modular Silent PSU Saffire ATI Radeon
X1300 Pro ICEQ 256MB DDR2 Antec P180 SPCR Advanced Super Midi Tower Case 2 *
Western Digital Cavier 200HG 7,000rpm PATA hard disks (from old PC) for storage and
audio 2 * Western Digital Raptor 80GB 10,000rpm SATA hard disks in RAID config for
system Cubase SX 2 Focusrite saffire audio interface
I've not been
able to stress test it with cubase sx yet, but...
I tested it with a cubase
project. On my old Athlon XP2000+, VIA KT266A, 1GB, Audiophile 2496 system with the
latency set to about 50ms, it had the CPU up to about 95% and still glitched.
On the new system using the saffire set to 10ms latency, the CPU is fairly steady at
about 27%, playback is rock solid, screen refreshes are fast and the project loads in a
fraction of the time (from the same hard disk as was in the old machine)
...so
I'm very happy so far.
The system is also pretty quiet, and I was particularly
impressed with the Antec P180 case. Highly recommended.
|
Martin Walker
Watcher Of The Skies
Joined: 28/02/01
Posts: 16477
Loc: Cornwall, UK
|
Re: Survey Of Working Dual-Core PC Music Systems
[Re: Domsmart]
#282354 - 13/04/06 01:25 PM
|
|
|
Yes, I liked the Antec P180 case when I reviewed Millennium's PC in SOS March 2006. Did
you use that top vent though, or mount the exhaust fan on the back panel and block the top
vent as I suggested in my review? Martin
-------------------- YewTreeMagic
|
Richard Graham
Joined: 10/04/06
Posts: 2259
Loc: Gateshead, UK
|
Re: Survey Of Working Dual-Core PC Music Systems
[Re: Martin Walker]
#285010 - 20/04/06 02:02 PM
|
|
|
I'm gutted. I bought an A8V when I specced up my Athlon 64 3000+ a year or so ago, but it
was DOA so I got a Gigabyte MB as a replacement, which works but can't overclock properly
(the Venice 3000 has a good reputaion as an Oc'er which is why I got it).
Happy with my quiet Antec case though (cheaper model, no top-blowhole)
|
Crow
Joined: 20/04/06
Posts: 86
|
Re: Survey Of Working Dual-Core PC Music Systems
[Re: jackieT]
#285526 - 21/04/06 04:44 PM
|
|
|
Quote jackieT:
Hello Guys &
Girls? I am looking at Intel Core Duo specs and I can't see the words "64 bit"
anywhere? Are they dual 64 bit cores or dual 32 bit cores with Hyperthreading ??I've
noticed that the systems I have found so far all use XP pro,and not X64.Are they
cheating?? Cheers Jack
The current
Core Duos (codenamed Yonah) are 32 bit CPUs; the second generation models (Merom) will be
64 bit, they are likely to appear in Q4 of this year. They are pin compatible with Yonah,
so upgrades are possible with BIOS updates. Desktop motherboards that support Core Duos
are more likely to receive a BIOS update, as I don’t see laptop manufacturers being that
keen to encourage their customers to upgrade their laptops which are still under
warranty! Martin’s response to your post was referring to the Pentium D chips, so I
guess he misread your post.
You don’t see many systems coming pre-installed
with 64 bit XP Pro; I think that is mainly because there aren’t that many applications
that are 64 bit at this point. Unless one of your main applications has been ported to 64
bit AND it offers a significant performance boost that you need, I would keep away from
XP-64. When Vista is released the situation should change quite quickly as most new
PCs should ship with the 64 bit version; expect a flood of 64 bit applications with
software vendors rubbing their hands with glee at the potential to sell yet another
upgrade.
|
Game0ver
Joined: 25/04/06
Posts: 3
|
Re: Survey Of Working Dual-Core PC Music Systems
[Re: Martin Walker]
#286992 - 25/04/06 12:35 PM
|
|
|
|
Hi all,
Have recently built a dual core system comprising of:
AMD 4200 dual core
Asus A8V
Matrox P650 (Dual DVI outs)
2Gb Corsair
RAM
1 x 80GB Hitachi Deskstar (for system)
1 x 250GB Hitachi Deskstar (for
data)
Antec case
Sony CD/RW - DVD ROM
2 x Dell High Respolution 19inch
monitors
I am still using my old M-Audio Quattro as I couldnt justify any
extra expense at the moment..
Set up the system. and configured it for dual
boot (WinXP Pro for office apps, and Win XP Pro for Music boot). All worked very well for
the first two weeks. I had reason up on one monitor, rewired to Acid on the other, and I
was in remix heaven! It was great, and so fast! I didnt seem to care how many VST's i
added, rock solid.... Untill.....
Two days ago i turned on my system and now
it will not boot. I get the Asus screen, goes through the POST without errors, then I get
the choice of office or music boot. which ever I select, it displays the windows loading
screen, then as soon as it should display the log-in screen , I get a blank monitor (this
is also the point that the two monitors should kick in for dual screen mode).
I can start in safe mode, but it gets as far as loading a driver called GAGp30KX.SYS
and then freezes. I have tried locating that driver using the recovery console, and
renaming it, but when I restart It stall on another driver, so I now think that the
mentioned driver as the last to load successfully, and It is stalling on a driver that I
cannot yet see on the screen.
Matox have advised me to do the following:
Flash the MOBO Bios
Flash the chipset BIOS
Flash the Graphices card
bios
Use the Matros drivers rather than the windows ones
still no
joy....
Its confusing that both operating systems fail in the same place?
This cannot possibly be coinsidence?
I downloaded the microsoft memory tester
programm that runs in DOS, and it reports no errors...
I have tried all the
advanced start up options, It wont even boot in Safe or VGA mode....
Sometimes if i leave the system for half an hour or so, then return I has managed to
load windows, but this is rare and speradic to say the least.
I have also
slightly overclocked the AGP buss from 1.5v to 1.6v, and changed the AGP speed from 8x to
4x, which was suggested whilst researching this on "Tin-ter-net" (I think on the Matrox
user Forum)
I guess my next move is to reinstall windows, but am reluctant to
do this, as im not convinced it is a windows problem, due to the fact that both os's fail
in the same place (two windows operating systems corrupted in exactly the same place at
the same time, unlikely..)
I am also going to try another graphics card.
The pain is, that I deleiberately went for the Asus A8V to avoid and PCI-X
issues, and now am wondering if there is a compatability problem between the A8v and the
Matrox card (hightened only by that fact the most of the Mobo problems reported on the
matrox forum are to do with the A8v... not very encouraging..)
Ohh well... I
will keep you posted if i manage to work it out...
Nick.
Edited by Game0ver (25/04/06 12:52 PM)
|
royleith
Joined: 21/04/06
Posts: 5
|
Re: Survey Of Working Dual-Core PC Music Systems
[Re: Martin Walker]
#287164 - 25/04/06 05:55 PM
|
|
|
Quote:
at last we PC
Musicians have some PCI Express interfaces to consider.
I'm beginning to wonder if PCIe is the
right issue to worry about. The word is that Vista will mandate signed drivers. Quite a
lot of my consumer and pro computer drivers are unsigned.
It occurs to me
that a Firewire audio system will work on Win98, WinXP, OSX and Vista without needing
signed drivers and, because the motherboard-based Firewire ports are effectively just
connectorless PCI devices, one gets the benefits of optimised PCIe when the right mobo
comes along, but can use one's ancient 2 month old X2 PCI mobo in the mean time. What
happens to a PCIe card with an unsigned driver when Vista comes along?
Am I
missing something? Isn't Firewire more future-proofed in terms of performance than a PCIe
audio card? The other benefit is that the interface can be swapped from desktop to laptop
thus getting the expensive, but high quality audio wherever you need it.
The
real issue is whether the performance and features of Firewire audio will match the
equivalent PCIe card. Any thoughts?
Regards Roy Leith
|
ewiggy
Joined: 19/04/06
Posts: 4
|
Re: Survey Of Working Dual-Core PC Music Systems
[Re: Martin Walker]
#287207 - 25/04/06 07:25 PM
|
|
|
I am awaiting my Inta Audio AMD workstation, which i upgraded to a X2 3800 processor. Will
repost when its up and running. This is kind of a pointless post really, I'm
just a little over excited and struggling with the wait, my current, dying, DAW being a
PIII and a very old version of cubase.
|
Peter C
active member
Joined: 08/01/04
Posts: 3054
Loc: London, England
|
Re: Survey Of Working Dual-Core PC Music Systems
[Re: Game0ver]
#287398 - 26/04/06 08:42 AM
|
|
|
Hi Nick, Quote Game0ver:
Hi all,
Have recently built a dual core system comprising of:
...
Until.....
Two days ago i turned on my system and now it will
not boot.
Ohh well... I will keep you posted if i manage to work it out...
Nick.
You clearly have a hardware fault. The question is: in which component?
It
seems to me the key evidence is:
1. Same problem in two OSs running (please
confirm this) from two differnet partitions. 2. Won't boot in Safe or VGA mode 3. Will boot into DOS and run MS memory tester
So we are looking from
some item of hardware that Windows depends on (even in safe mode), but DOS doesn't.
If you have a spare HD lying around I'd remove all the existing HDs and try
installing windows onto the spare. My guess is that it won't work, but even that tells us
something. It eliminates the HD, and the exact point where it stops working may provide a
clue. And of course, you might get lucky and end up with a working system.
Based on what you have said I'd be inclined to suspect a mobo or graphics card fault;
but at this stage that's no more than a guess.
Peter
-------------------- PaQ
|
Game0ver
Joined: 25/04/06
Posts: 3
|
Re: Survey Of Working Dual-Core PC Music Systems
[Re: Peter C]
#288028 - 27/04/06 10:59 AM
|
|
|
Hi Peter,
Indeed you are correct. Last night I removed the 2nd data HD, and
the PC booted fine...
So I then assumed a failed HD, so I downloaded the
Hitachi deskstar HD fault Finder DOS programe, and scanned both the drives.
The test concluded that both drives were indeed ok, with no errors.
I then
booted into windows, but windows would not read the 2nd drive at all. It appears that the
file structure must have corrupted somehow, although the eventlog doesn't shed any light
on it.
Reformatted the 2nd HD, and all now ok
(lost a few new samples created last weekend, but I store all the arrangements on the
system drive, so shouldnt be too hard to re-create)
Thanks for your thoughts!
(After this episode Im now considering purchasing a 3rd drive, and having my Data
drive mirrored across two drives for some extra redundancy...)
Edited by Game0ver (27/04/06 11:01 AM)
|
jalapeno
new member
Joined: 15/02/04
Posts: 105
Loc: Hertfordshire, UK
|
Re: Survey Of Working Dual-Core PC Music Systems
[Re: Martin Walker]
#289493 - 30/04/06 11:00 AM
|
|
|
|
Just about to order ASUS Nforce4 mobo, AMD X2 4200, GEoForce 6800 PCIe dual head graphics
- barebone system.
I am planning a clean install of XPHome+SP2
Anything to worry about or gotchas ?
|
bmfbmf
new member
Joined: 05/09/03
Posts: 15
|
Re: Survey Of Working Dual-Core PC Music Systems
[Re: Martin Walker]
#290015 - 01/05/06 07:02 PM
|
|
|
Hi All,
After trying in vain to get Asus PCI only boards in south africa I
settled for:
AMD 4200 64 X2 dual core
MSI NEO 2 Platinum
2 x 1gb
Corsiar value ram
Seagate 250 gig SATA drive
Matrox G450
Thermaltake
500w Psu
whatever case was handy
A
very flakey Polar TI (+ internal PCI card for i)
echo gina (the old 20 Bit job - no
really)
Aftert a VERY frustrating evening where I though I'd blown R7000
after the system kept freezing, it turned ou the pc builders had put the ram in the wrong
slots -After that everything is running REALLY well -
I stress tested the
system and the max tem the processor got to (running 2 instances of prime 95, one for each
core) was 37 degrees)
cheers
Brett
Edited by bmfbmf (01/05/06 07:11 PM)
|
adrian_k
Joined: 30/01/03
Posts: 1741
Loc: Gloucestershire
|
Re: Survey Of Working Dual-Core PC Music Systems
[Re: Martin Walker]
#290540 - 02/05/06 07:50 PM
|
|
|
OK here's mine:
Asus A8R-MVP motherboard
AMD X2 4200 CPU
ThermalRight XP-120 CPU cooler
Seasonic S-12 430W PSU
Corsair XMS PC3200
Cas2 TwinX - 2 x 1GB
Gforce 6200 graphics
2 x Maxtor MaxLine3 Reliability
250GB HD
Pioneer DVD/CD Writer
RME Fireface
So far so good -
running comfortably at reported 2.9ms latency (I know the Firewire adds a bit more) -
haven't seen average CPU over 17% so far, bags of headroom for the additional stuff I want
to do.
Touch wood - I'm actually now able to concentrate on making music
again after fighting with my old machine all these years
Thanks to forum members CC (for showing an interest last year when I was close to
convincing myself that PC music wasn't worth the effort) and PeterC (who built the
system).
cheers
Adrian
{edit} PS - hard to compare with my
old P4 1.7GHz system, but the same project I am running at 2.9ms/17% CPU now would not run
at all at less than 50ms on the old machine.
-------------------- getting better all the time..
Edited by dunch (02/05/06 07:53 PM)
|
Richiebee
Joined: 09/05/05
Posts: 162
Loc: Newfoundland, Canada
|
Re: Survey Of Working Dual-Core PC Music Systems
[Re: Martin Walker]
#292405 - 06/05/06 03:41 AM
|
|
|
|
Processor; Intel Pentium D Processor 920 Processor Speed; dual core 2.8Ghz Processor Cache; L2 Cache 2x2MB Bus Speed; 800MHz Front-side Bus Memory; 2.0GB
PC2-4200 DDR2 SDRAM memory 2x1GB Windows XP Media Center Hard Drive; Samsung
250GB 7200RPM Serial ATA hard drive Maxtor 100Gb SATA Ultra drive Tascam
US122
This is an off the shelf HP computer that I bought on special. It's very
quiet, and works very well with Cubase SX3, Kontakt 2.1, Garritan J&BB and Virtual
Guitarist 2.
Had problems with an external USB2 hard drive (Maxtor One Touch
II) that kept blue screening the computer, but replaced it with an internal drive and
haven't had a crash since.
I don't know what the motherboard is... how do you
find out?
R.
|
adrian_k
Joined: 30/01/03
Posts: 1741
Loc: Gloucestershire
|
Re: Survey Of Working Dual-Core PC Music Systems
[Re: Richiebee]
#292439 - 06/05/06 08:27 AM
|
|
|
Quote Richiebee:
I don't
know what the motherboard is... how do you find out?
R.
Hi - try CPU-Z.
cheers A
|
Richiebee
Joined: 09/05/05
Posts: 162
Loc: Newfoundland, Canada
|
Re: Survey Of Working Dual-Core PC Music Systems
[Re: adrian_k]
#292501 - 06/05/06 12:33 PM
|
|
|
Quote dunch:
Hi - try
CPU-Z.
That worked...
The
motherboard is an ASUS P5LP-LE (it seems... it actually comes up Emery).
|
tex
active member
Joined: 01/04/03
Posts: 1087
|
Re: Survey Of Working Dual-Core PC Music Systems
[Re: Martin Walker]
#294010 - 09/05/06 02:42 PM
|
|
|
|
Enermax 480watt PSU/Abit AI7 MB'd/P4x3.06 Dual core (HT On)/2gig ram/160+160+80
Maxtors/Nvidea GE Force 5200/Delta 1010lt+EmulatorX//Win XP Home SP2/Cubase 3.1/EmuX
VSTi/LM4 MK2/ All usual FX and VSTi's etc.
Self build, no surprise troubles of
the kind plaguing some Cubase SX users. Some crackles but that's the EmuX samplers
multitimbral overload if I forget to use something else instead. Midi stable with Audio
priority set normal or high.
-------------------- Success is round the corner. It's also round the bend.
|
Bob Bryars
new member
Joined: 12/11/02
Posts: 3
Loc: Leicester
|
Re: Survey Of Working Dual-Core PC Music Systems
[Re: royleith]
#297778 - 15/05/06 10:56 PM
|
|
|
|
Hi All,
I think royleith's post about firewire (powercore for ex) rather than
the PCI version is a good point. I'm not tech spec'd enough to be able to answer but would
welcome someones thoughts.
Put my money down at Millennium today for
Asus A8N SLi Deluxe for Athlon s939 Athlon 64 X2 4800+ 2.4ghz S939 2x1mb 1GB
DDR SO-DIMM Memory x2 Raptor 74GB 10,000RPM SATA Hard Drive 250GB Serial ATA
Hard Drive Configure 2 x 250Gb Serial ATA hard drives as RAID 0. RME digi
9632 Matrox Parhelia 128MB TripleVGA Graphics & Windows XP Pro.
Thought
about Powercore firewire but haven't got £. Will be running Giga studio & SX and groovey
stuff like Spektral delay. Movin' up from my old Win 98 P3 450, which still works well and
can record 20 or so tracks of audio. Millenium are going to rack mount it and I'll use it
for recording gigs from my 01v via adat.
Can't wait.
Bob Bryars
|
heedthebaw
new member
Joined: 22/08/02
Posts: 9
|
Re: Survey Of Working Dual-Core PC Music Systems
[Re: Martin Walker]
#300096 - 20/05/06 06:44 PM
|
|
|
My pal just helped me build a dual core machine. and it goes like stink. dont know what
the technical term for that is! it's a 2 x dual core opteron 266 Gigabyte NVIDIA
Fanless 6600GT+HSI 128MB Tyan K8WE S2877 2 gig registered ram with 2 sata
300G maxtor drives RME HDSP 9652 UAD card it's shaping up really
well, I seem to be able to load tonnes of plug ins, even at 96k and the hard drive isn't
dropping out like it used to... the only thing needed ironed out is the UAD card only
works at a latency of 3ms! no bad thing, except the IR1 reverb only works at 12ms! I've no
idea how this stuff works, I just really like it when it does. I've posted this question
on this forum too.. see if anyone can help.. cheers andy
|
Humf
member
Joined: 22/10/03
Posts: 694
|
Re: Survey Of Working Dual-Core PC Music Systems
[Re: Martin Walker]
#306825 - 03/06/06 02:27 PM
|
|
|
|
I've just finished my first self build. It's an Athlon Dual Core:
AMD X2 4200
CPU Gigabyte GA-K8NSC-939 Motherboard (nForce 3) Antec P180 Case Seasonic
S12 430W PSU Crucial 4GB DDR Radeon ATI 9250 256MB Graphics WD 80GB ATA WD 300GB ATA Intel Pro 1000MT Ethernet EgoSys WamiRack 192X
Everything went surprisingly smoothly until I ran into problems with MOTU's MachFive
Sampler causing the entire machine to reboot without warning. Although I had already
successfully run this software on a P4 for sometime with XP service pack 2, I took it back
to service pack 1 and this sorted the problem...
Now awaiting Cubase SE3 in the
post so that I can fully utilise my brand new dual core DAW.
Chuffed to
bits.
Ben
|
Neil_
Joined: 24/03/06
Posts: 15
|
Re: Survey Of Working Dual-Core PC Music Systems
[Re: Humf]
#307035 - 04/06/06 11:24 AM
|
|
|
|
How quiet is that setup BHWH ? Did you purchase any specifically quiet fans? Ta
|
Humf
member
Joined: 22/10/03
Posts: 694
|
Re: Survey Of Working Dual-Core PC Music Systems
[Re: Martin Walker]
#307215 - 04/06/06 10:40 PM
|
|
|
|
Neil
I can't really give you any specifics (ie. dB levels) but what I would
say is that with the 3 standard P180 case fans set to low, CPU heatsink & fan and
Seasonic PSU fan all running it's still a whole lot quieter than my old 'off the shelf'
Evesham P4.
I don't really have much experience of other quiet PCs but
considering what's going on inside the beast it's quiet enough for me!
Oh -
and I made sure I bought a fanless graphics card.
|
joystick
Joined: 07/05/06
Posts: 408
|
Re: Survey Of Working Dual-Core PC Music Systems
[Re: Game0ver]
#310815 - 13/06/06 06:58 PM
|
|
|
Quote Game0ver:
Hi Peter,
Indeed you are correct. Last night I removed the 2nd data HD, and the PC booted
fine...
So I then assumed a failed HD, so I downloaded the Hitachi deskstar HD
fault Finder DOS programe, and scanned both the drives.
The test concluded that
both drives were indeed ok, with no errors.
I then booted into windows, but
windows would not read the 2nd drive at all. It appears that the file structure must have
corrupted somehow, although the eventlog doesn't shed any light on it.
Reformatted the 2nd HD, and all now ok 
(lost a few new samples created last weekend, but I store all the arrangements on the
system drive, so shouldnt be too hard to re-create)
Thanks for your thoughts!

(After this episode Im now considering purchasing a 3rd drive, and having my Data
drive mirrored across two drives for some extra redundancy...)
Try to Zero Fill the defective drive and it
will work again like a dream. Oh it's a deskstar!!!??? Just released! Throw it away
mate... Go for Western Digitals and Seagates only...
-------------------- http://www.myspace.com/joystickmusicgreece
|
fdotbone
member
Joined: 07/02/04
Posts: 121
Loc: Zürich,Switzerland.
|
Re: Survey Of Working Dual-Core PC Music Systems
[Re: fdotbone]
#310885 - 13/06/06 10:23 PM
|
|
|
Well anyone who followed my tale of woe in March may be interested to know I now have a
working computer.Well sort of...lol.Alas! There was a problem from the start with my ESI
Maxio o32 sound card and indeed this was confirmed after it was returned to the supplier
in germany who subsequently returned it to ESI who then replaced the breakoutbox and
returned it to me.I can only say that their support from the UK via email was very very
good and helpful and friendly.I chose the UK as I am english speaking although based in
Switzerland.Well after that i had a new breakout box within a few weeks.Ok I was
unfortunate in that I got one made on a friday as they used to say.All in all I have no
real complaints and the card itself is first class.On top of that I had a Western Digital
HD 10,000 rpm SATA a week before it started sounding like a Massey Ferguson with two ton
of cow [ ****** ] on the back and it had to go back and took a lot longer to be replaced,
although they did in the end.This is just another in a long line of electronics that I
have had to return due to faults in the last year or so.My Korg D1600MkII arrived new but
defective!! maybe I have an Albatross although I don't remember shooting one!  Water water
everywhere and not a drop to drink etc etc.... Anyhow if you're interested I really
do believe that this ESI card would have worked with any of the three computer
configurations that I tried and am now convinced that the faulty card was the problem all
along.I now have a Gigabyte based GA-K8N Pro-SLI Dual core AMD which is very good apart
from the fact the Bios has a mind of its own in that it some times makes a very long bleep
and then reboots and then starts fine.It has never failed to boot as of yet.One tip is
don't try to update the bios from the web browser I had problems making it "stick" use a
floppy and update from within the Bios itself .It also has Dual Bios anyhow.The ESI card
is PCI and I also have a PCI-E firewire card on which hangs an epson scanner without any
issuses thus far.The sound card has absolutely no clicks or pops although I'm only running
one 8 channel of ADAT straight into it.Anyways thanks to all who contributed and helped me
out.Cheers....Mike
|
klausko
Joined: 13/05/06
Posts: 2
|
Re: Survey Of Working Dual-Core PC Music Systems
[Re: Martin Walker]
#315958 - 26/06/06 10:35 AM
|
|
|
|
Hi everyone! As a newcomer,first thanks for the great forum!
I built
myself a new PC: Thermaltake "Kandalf" Bequiet dark power pro 530 Watt Asus
A8N-SLI Premium (Nvid4 chipset) AMD Athlon 64X2,4800+,Socket 939 boxed,2x 2,4 GHz 2 x RAM Corsair Twinx PC 3200,400 Mhz,1024MB,CL2 Scythe Ninja Plus Heatpipe
cooler ATI Radeon X1300 Pro DDR 2 PCIe passiv Western digital Raptor
10.000RPM 2x Sata drives
Interface: Edirol UA-1000 USB 2.0 Steinberg Midex 8
Everything worx fine!!No Problems anyway!Scythe is the best
cooler on earth-never over 50 degrees C! I tried to insert all my VST Instruments in
a little song (20 VST`s)-CPU does`nt matter at all! I could increase the latency to
the minimum (6ms on Edirol USB!) I`m glad I`ve changed.The only problem is UAD-1
(since I can get the new PCIe card from UAD,I`m connected with my old PC-AMD 2600+,Asus
A8V deluxe- via Teleport,so Ì´m able to use UAD1 anyway) My old Powercore card
makes no problems. If you have any questions,contact me please Greetings from
Vienna Klaus
|