Main Forums >> PC Music
        Print Thread

Pages: 1 | 2 | (show all)
DPolwarth



Joined: 13/08/07
Posts: 62
88 key MIDI controllers - KX8, CME UF80, FATAR, what to get?
      #727732 - 21/04/09 03:25 PM
Hi guys,

I really need some advice. I'd like to get a good quality 88 key MIDI controller with a good 'feel' to it. Ideally it should have a sustain pedal and preferably (but not necessarily) a controller pedal. Mod wheels and knobs and sliders would also be a bonus.


Here are my priorities in order of importance:

Good keyboard
Sustain pedal
Good software integration
Mod wheel
Knobs and sliders

I use Cubase, and I'm drawn to the new Yamaha KX8. It looks ideal, with Cubase integration and a Yamaha pedigree. Apparently it has a GHS keyboard design. Does anyone know anything about how the keyboard feels? It is supposed to have a piano feel, but how good is it really? I think the KX8 is already shipping, so has anyone tried it? Does it compare well to the competition?

Another possibility is the Studiologic Fatar range. Every review from users or magazines seem to suggest that the build quality of the Fatar keyboards are poor. I've heard tales of keys not providing the full 127 point MIDI range, cheap connectors, sliders not working, and so on. This is surprising as they market themselves as top-end. Has anyone used a FATAR keyboard? Are they as bad as people say they are?

Finally, the CME UF80 is a possibility. Feature-rich, but I'm very wary of anything made by CME. In the past Sound on Sound has damned them with faint praise, though to be fair a lot of users swear by the keyboard. Apparently they have poor driver support, and they make a lot of errors in their design. But the CME UF80 is now in its second iteration - is it a good product? Or does it cut too many corners?

Here's my judgement so far: I'm feeling that the Yamaha is a solid option - Yamaha build quality, integration with Cubase. Unfortunately, no controller pedal output - just sustain. On paper it looks the best, but that's why I'm turning to the experts - you guys!

Of these keyboards, which do you feel would make the best purchase? Should I go for the Yamaha? Or are the others better? If you have tried out these keyboards, what would you prefer?

The keyboard I get now will last me for years, so I'm prepared to stretch to £400 or more. But I want to make the right purchase, going for quality.

Any advice would be greatly welcomed.

Daniel


Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator     Back to top
The Elf
active member


Joined: 14/08/01
Posts: 9383
Loc: Sheffield, UK
Re: 88 key MIDI controllers - KX8, CME UF80, FATAR, what to get? new [Re: DPolwarth]
      #727744 - 21/04/09 03:52 PM
I can't comment directly on any others of the above, but I'd say that you'd do well to be wary of CME. I was almost bitten once...

I don't get on with weighted keyboards, but if I needed one I'd look at (not necessarily brand new) devices from Kurzweil, Yamaha and Roland.

--------------------
An Eagle for an Emperor, A Kestrel for a Knave.


Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator     Back to top
The_Big_Piano_Player
active member


Joined: 13/05/04
Posts: 1657
Loc: Lincolnshire
Re: 88 key MIDI controllers - KX8, CME UF80, FATAR, what to get? new [Re: DPolwarth]
      #727747 - 21/04/09 04:07 PM
I like the list of importance, but does the budget feature on this list? four hundred squids does put you in the fatar bracket.

I've used the SL990 for a few years now, and it's a fairly solid feel, to be honest. If you're a piano player, and not too bothered about bangs and whistles, then it's not a bad option.

--------------------
Touch & Go


Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator     Back to top
infiniteloop
member


Joined: 09/08/04
Posts: 461
Loc: 3rd rock from the sun
Re: 88 key MIDI controllers - KX8, CME UF80, FATAR, what to get? new [Re: The Elf]
      #727748 - 21/04/09 04:08 PM
Be wary of buying a weighted keyboard if you're planning any MIDI drum-programming, it's a bit trickier than using a normal 'plastic' synthesizer keyboard...

--------------------
Mac G5 Dual 2.3/6gb Ram, MOTU 828mkII, Yamaha 02r, DBX 286A, Logic 8, Roland SRV-3030D, Roland JV-1080, Roland JV-1010, Emu Proteus 2000, Roland SC55 MK2, Tascam DA-30 MK2


Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator     Back to top
The_Big_Piano_Player
active member


Joined: 13/05/04
Posts: 1657
Loc: Lincolnshire
Re: 88 key MIDI controllers - KX8, CME UF80, FATAR, what to get? new [Re: infiniteloop]
      #727753 - 21/04/09 04:18 PM
Quote infiniteloop:

Be wary of buying a weighted keyboard if you're planning any MIDI drum-programming, it's a bit trickier than using a normal 'plastic' synthesizer keyboard...




I agree. In fact, I'd say synth solos are easier on a non-weighted keyboard, too.

--------------------
Touch & Go


Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator     Back to top
DPolwarth



Joined: 13/08/07
Posts: 62
Re: 88 key MIDI controllers - KX8, CME UF80, FATAR, what to get? new [Re: DPolwarth]
      #727778 - 21/04/09 06:04 PM
I actually already have a semi-weighted Axiom 61 by M-Audio. It's a useful keyboard as far as it goes, but it has an ugly action and I was hoping to supplement it with something more suitable for piano playing. As I have the Axiom 61 I can always use that for drum programming and synth work, but I recently won a competition with Time and Space for the whole Synthogy Ivory collection, and I would dearly like to get a keyboard that would shine on piano work.

The Yamaha appeals because it has good control features for parameter changing in Cubase and, hopefully, has a top quality keyboard. The CME is very fancy but the company has an awful reputation, so I would prefer to stay clear of it. Nonetheless, some people really like it.

I'm fascinated by the Fatar Studiologic range. I was originally looking at the 188+, but I've read several reviews that suggest the build quality is poor. Has anyone here had any trouble with a Fatar keyboard? Would you consider them better than the Yamaha?

Essentially I'm looking for a keyboard to serve a precise purpose - piano playing, ideally with good software connectivity. I don't intend it to use for everything as I have an Axiom 61 already, so I won't be needing it for fast synth work or drum programming.

Any recommendations?


Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator     Back to top
The_Big_Piano_Player
active member


Joined: 13/05/04
Posts: 1657
Loc: Lincolnshire
Re: 88 key MIDI controllers - KX8, CME UF80, FATAR, what to get? new [Re: DPolwarth]
      #727781 - 21/04/09 06:14 PM
I've got a roland piano for gigging. It's superior to the equivalent yamaha in the quality of the action.

If you're not planning on gigging that piano, I would recommend the fatar. The action is good, and if it's going to stay in one place, then reliability isn't particularly an issue. (I've never had a problem with my fatar studio keyboard).

I've been playing the piano for 30 years (old fart that I am),and the graded hammer action on the 990 XP is spot-on in my opinion.

--------------------
Touch & Go


Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator     Back to top
DPolwarth



Joined: 13/08/07
Posts: 62
Re: 88 key MIDI controllers - KX8, CME UF80, FATAR, what to get? new [Re: DPolwarth]
      #727784 - 21/04/09 06:26 PM
That's really interesting. I was originally looking at the Fatar types, but was put off by some of the comments I had heard.

I am now torn! I could go for the Fatar, or I could go for the Yamaha.

Here's the tie breaker: does the Fatar have the better keyboard that the Yamaha? If it does, then I'll go for the Fatar as I'm really looking for a good keyboard above all else. If they are pretty much similar, then I'd probably go for the Yamaha because of the Cubase integration.

What do you guys think?


Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator     Back to top
Bob Moose



Joined: 17/01/08
Posts: 885
Re: 88 key MIDI controllers - KX8, CME UF80, FATAR, what to get? new [Re: DPolwarth]
      #727787 - 21/04/09 06:32 PM
The keyboard action feeling is always subjective. You should try it before buying.

All the best,
-j


Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator     Back to top
Martin WalkerModerator
Watcher Of The Skies


Joined: 28/02/01
Posts: 17409
Loc: Cornwall, UK
Re: 88 key MIDI controllers - KX8, CME UF80, FATAR, what to get? new [Re: DPolwarth]
      #727811 - 21/04/09 07:59 PM
Indeed you should - action is such a personal thing.

However, having said that I have to admit that I still like my CME UF8. The CME series is good value, I like its action a lot (I directly compared it very favourably with quite a few other makes and models, as well as various upright and grand pianos, while at the Frankfurt Musikmesse a few years ago), and I bypassed any USB driver problems by using a direct MIDI connection, which has never let me down.


Martin

--------------------
YewTreeMagic


Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator     Back to top
DPolwarth



Joined: 13/08/07
Posts: 62
Re: 88 key MIDI controllers - KX8, CME UF80, FATAR, what to get? new [Re: DPolwarth]
      #727845 - 21/04/09 09:32 PM
So Martin is vouching for the CME UF80, Big Piano Player recommends the Studiologic Fatar, and most seem indifferent to the Yamaha.

While I completely agree that trying the action out is probably the smart thing, unfortunately this isn't possible for me. So I'm left a little stuck.

Let's sum up what we know:

The CME UF80 seems to be either loved or hated. I've met several people who swear it has the best action, but on the downside it is poorly supported. It is in its second iteration, and so it can be hoped that most of the early teething problems have been teased out. Without doubt it has a fantastic feature set. In short, it sounds a pretty good bet.

The Studiologic Fatar keyboards do seem to have a lot of praise heaped on them, and yet I have read some pretty shocking reports of build quality. It seems that if you get a working one its excellent, but many of them seem to slip past quality control. It has the weakest feature set of the three by some way. Can't dismiss it outright, but it is an outside bet.

Then comes the Yamaha. This one is something of a dark horse. Yamaha stuff is always innovative, but they suffer from 'big company' syndrome. A lot of their stuff is merely adequate. They always get positive comments (it seems no one ever dislikes a Yamaha keyboard). It also has the advantage of being totally integrated into Cubase. On paper it looks the best.

So I need to come to some sort of conclusion. On paper the Yamaha looks an excellent deal, but I suspect its keyboard action is perhaps not as good as the Fatar range. The UF80 must be doing something right, because although people seem suspicious of the company, users seem to love it. It seems that no end of people are queueing up to praise the action on the Studiologic Fatar's and UF80's.

Could it be that all three keyboards are each excellent, and it merely comes down to which suits my personal preferences? Certainly it seems that the Fatar and CME keyboards have an avid following, with some reservations in build quality. I was perhaps too hasty to dismiss them.

I'm going to do a little more research. If anyone else has an opinion that would help make up my mind, then please let me know!

Thanks for the help so far,

Daniel


Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator     Back to top
Jabba1



Joined: 19/11/07
Posts: 326
Loc: Aylesbury
Re: 88 key MIDI controllers - KX8, CME UF80, FATAR, what to get? new [Re: DPolwarth]
      #727866 - 21/04/09 10:50 PM
I've been using an M Audio Keystation 88ES for the last two years, bought on Ebay... has never let me down at all.

Doesnt come with the pedal, doesnt have a lot of buttons and sliders... but it depends on exactly what you want to do with it. I find it more than adequate for my needs (basic studio midi input into Cubase or Reaper).

--------------------
www.alterzero.com || "Semper in excremento sum... solum profunditas variat"


Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator     Back to top
DPolwarth



Joined: 13/08/07
Posts: 62
Re: 88 key MIDI controllers - KX8, CME UF80, FATAR, what to get? new [Re: DPolwarth]
      #727898 - 22/04/09 06:17 AM
Thanks Jabba. To be honest, I have an M Audio keyboard and I'm not too enamoured with the action on it. They're great value, but I don't think I'd want to take that route again. It's a personal preference, though, and I'm sure they're good keyboards.


Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator     Back to top
The_Big_Piano_Player
active member


Joined: 13/05/04
Posts: 1657
Loc: Lincolnshire
Re: 88 key MIDI controllers - KX8, CME UF80, FATAR, what to get? new [Re: DPolwarth]
      #727917 - 22/04/09 07:56 AM
I had the M-audio stage piano. It was excellent for the price, but I wouldn't pit it against the competition.

--------------------
Touch & Go


Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator     Back to top
Pink Fluid
new member


Joined: 19/09/02
Posts: 519
Re: 88 key MIDI controllers - KX8, CME UF80, FATAR, what to get? new [Re: DPolwarth]
      #727923 - 22/04/09 08:26 AM
Much as we all want to, it's hard to make these decisions based on the specs alone - you have to try them out, simple as that. You can see from the different opinions that what suits one players style may not suit you. Also, if you really like playing keys in general, it's much better having something either non or semi-weighted for synth/organ/drum duties in addition to a weighted keyboard for piano/orchestral stuff is thats your bag. FWIW I use a Studiologic SL880 which is about 10 years old, has never gone wrong and is built like a tank. I've also got a much cheaper 61 key Studiologic model that perches on the SL880. It only cost about £60 but is fine for all non-piano stuff. No sliders or anything though.


Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator     Back to top
Zuben El Genubi
member


Joined: 22/04/04
Posts: 25
Re: 88 key MIDI controllers - KX8, CME UF80, FATAR, what to get? new [Re: DPolwarth]
      #727936 - 22/04/09 08:51 AM
There is a new 88 key controller from Akai:

MKP88
http://www.akaipro.com/mpk88

Looks really cool and solid.

Anyway I would wish there would be something similar solid with 88 semi-weighted keys as I'm more a synth player, and piano sometimes, too.

There is the Fatar/Studiologic VMK-88 plus
http://www.studiologic.net/vmk-88plus.html
but that looks very cheesy.

Or the mentioned M-Audio Keystation 88es
http://www.m-audio.com/products/en_us/Keystation88es.html
which had bad reviews on key action at KVR. And has no controllers.

Did anyone test or compare these?

I wish there would be an Akai MPK88(es?) with quality semiweighted keys.

Best,
Zuben


Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator     Back to top
Jabba1



Joined: 19/11/07
Posts: 326
Loc: Aylesbury
Re: 88 key MIDI controllers - KX8, CME UF80, FATAR, what to get? new [Re: Zuben El Genubi]
      #727988 - 22/04/09 10:40 AM
Yeah.... 'spose the fact that I'm not a keyboard player by trade might have something to do with it just another three-finger-chord bassist getting ideas above his station

same as anything with instruments though, its a personal preference thing.

--------------------
www.alterzero.com || "Semper in excremento sum... solum profunditas variat"


Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator     Back to top
James PerrettModerator



Joined: 10/09/01
Posts: 10652
Loc: The wilds of Hampshire
Re: 88 key MIDI controllers - KX8, CME UF80, FATAR, what to get? new [Re: DPolwarth]
      #728000 - 22/04/09 11:00 AM
I've had an old Fatar keyboard that looks a little like the Studiologic 990 although it also has an LED display with a few more buttons. It plays fine and I like the different velocity curves available but programming it is a little fiddly and the pitch bend wheel has always been a little noisy which means that pitch bends aren't always as smooth as they should be.

Cheers

James.

--------------------
JRP Music - Audio Mastering and Restoration.
http://www.jrpmusic.net


Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator     Back to top
DSch



Joined: 18/08/05
Posts: 24
Re: 88 key MIDI controllers - KX8, CME UF80, FATAR, what to get? new [Re: DPolwarth]
      #728058 - 22/04/09 01:26 PM
As tempting as it is to have everything you want on the same instrument, I would be more inclined to go for whatever you feel has the best keyboard action, and then add whatever midi controller(s) you might need later. Having said that, the CMEs i've tried (in stores only) felt reasonably good, if a little heavy. The VX8 felt a bit better than the UF80, but comes with a lot of potentially superfluous features. I use an Oberheim MC2000, which is no longer manufactured, but is built to a much higher quality than what is available now.


Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator     Back to top
McGreevy



Joined: 02/04/08
Posts: 40
Re: 88 key MIDI controllers - KX8, CME UF80, FATAR, what to get? new [Re: DPolwarth]
      #728069 - 22/04/09 01:47 PM
Hey!
On a quick skim through your thread it seems nobody has suggested the M-Audio Keystaion 88 Pro. I see other M-Audio devices have been mentioned, but strangely not this one.

Full Hammer action 88 Keys
2 pedal inputs which are assignable
21 knobs
9 faders
17 buttons
pitchbend
mod wheel

cant really ask for a more fully featured keyboard at the price. Granted I am not a pianist by any stretch of the imagination but it does the job for me.

Hope to have helped

Chris


Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator     Back to top
DPolwarth



Joined: 13/08/07
Posts: 62
Re: 88 key MIDI controllers - KX8, CME UF80, FATAR, what to get? new [Re: DPolwarth]
      #728096 - 22/04/09 02:45 PM
Well, its make-my-mind-up time. I've had loads of feedback from people, and its given me a good idea of what to expect from all of the keyboards except for the Yamaha. That's a nuisance because the Yamaha is definitely a contender.

I'm going to sum up what I know:

It seems the CME keyboard is well-reviewed, has a heavy action, and is well-liked by the people who have one. Some of them include very skilled pianists, which has to be a plus. On the other hand, there are some doubts about the company. It has a poor reputation for customer support and does not often release new drivers or update its products. Communists playing at Capitalism, in other words.

Fatar keyboards seem to be a firm favourite among those that have one, but there are too many reports of poor build quality for me to ultimately feel comfortable buying one. Their quality control is not what it should be, by all accounts, and there are numerous accounts of broken keys and non-working sliders on reviews and user comments around the net. A dodgy choice.

Then we have the Yamaha KX8. Yamaha's GHS action, new design, Cubase integration and assured build quality and support. Downsides include no expression pedal socket, and some nasty gimmicky features that give the impression its not for the serious professional. Yamaha are always good at what they do, and they do have a reputation for making good keyboard designs. Has to be a serious contender.

Other suggestions include the M-Audio range, and the new Alesis keyboard. I own an M-Audio Axiom61 keyboard, and I can comfortably say I won't be buying another M-Audio product. They're a fair brand, but I don't like their software integration and they cut too many corners for comfort. I'm not sure about Alesis, either - they have never really released any products I would consider exceptional, tending to be a jack-of-all-trades-and-master-of-none. I would give them a miss.

So it seems to come down to the CME, the Yamaha or the Fatar, and I'm having real doubts about the Fatar because of its reputation for bad build quality. I don't really want to be stuck with a machine that might give me trouble after a few months, or worse still when its out of warranty. A shame, because it would otherwise have been near the very top of the list.

So we have two left: the Yamaha, and the CME. I'm no fan of heavy action keys, so it may come down to that in the end. I'll think on it, but right now I'm favouring a Yamaha purchase.

So final chance to put in your thoughts: is the Yamaha the right purchase? Just like at the wedding when the vicar asks if there is anyone who has a reason for the wedding not to go ahead, can someone think of a reason why the Yamaha may not be the right choice?

Over to you ...


Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator     Back to top
Martin WalkerModerator
Watcher Of The Skies


Joined: 28/02/01
Posts: 17409
Loc: Cornwall, UK
Re: 88 key MIDI controllers - KX8, CME UF80, FATAR, what to get? new [Re: DPolwarth]
      #728118 - 22/04/09 03:36 PM
Quote DPolwarth:

So we have two left: the Yamaha, and the CME. I'm no fan of heavy action keys, so it may come down to that in the end. I'll think on it, but right now I'm favouring a Yamaha purchase.




I'm surprised that the CME series has been described as having a 'heavy action'. Here's what I had to say in my review of the UF8:

"I personally found the feel of the UF8 better than or at least as good as any of the other controllers I tried, particularly for the price. It has a positive feel with the right amount of initial resistance, give, and rebound. The action is deliberately not graded (heavier in the lower registers, and lighter at the top) because this controller is not intended solely for piano sounds, and this makes perfect sense. The action is reasonably light as well, and felt fairly similar in this respect to the majority of 'real' pianos I tried (I've never agreed with those that think that weighted keyboards should require a Charles Atlas bodybuilding course to accompany them). However, keyboard actions are a personal choice, and while many other musicians who have tried them seem to agree with my view, one did report that the UF8 felt a little 'spongy', so try before you buy if possible."

Here's my full review:

www.soundonsound.com/sos/aug05/articles/cmeuf8.htm


Martin

--------------------
YewTreeMagic


Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator     Back to top
DPolwarth



Joined: 13/08/07
Posts: 62
Re: 88 key MIDI controllers - KX8, CME UF80, FATAR, what to get? new [Re: DPolwarth]
      #728129 - 22/04/09 03:52 PM
Your comments on the UF80 is surprising - most people on the forums seem to think that the CME is surprisingly hard to play. One person joked about how heavy the feel of the keys are, needing to hit them with earth-shattering power or something.

It could be something to do with the versions. On the CME website they claim that a new version is out, and it could be they have tweaked the action of the keyboard. They changed the colour as well. Mind you, I'm no expert - I'm just repeating the comments I've picked up. Also, the keyboard I'm looking at is called the UF80, not the UF8 - a different version perhaps?

By all means, if you feel the CME keyboard is the way to go then let me know.


Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator     Back to top
Bob Moose



Joined: 17/01/08
Posts: 885
Re: 88 key MIDI controllers - KX8, CME UF80, FATAR, what to get? new [Re: DPolwarth]
      #728166 - 22/04/09 06:08 PM
(wild guess) Perhaps it is because they modified the action some time ago. Yamaha did it lots of times, so why not CME?

Long time ago I had a Yamaha P-200 (used for shamefully replacing an acoustic piano in a small flat) that I sold because I really needed the half-pedal feature. I tried all the pianos in a shop and chose the P-250 over the RD700 and the Kawai MPC9500. And the action of the P-250 was really lighter than the one of the P-200. Actually some people had complained about the "dangerous" hardness of the P-200 on various forums. Fortunately I found the P-250 action adapted to my way of playing.
Later Yamaha released some new keyboards that were even softer to play, because for lots of pop players the P-250 was still too hard. I tried some and thought they were really too soft. If I played that for too long I would then be unable to play on an acoustic piano.
So today I don't really know how the Yamaha action is. Of course all this is not mentionned in the specifications. On some forums, there are some geeks who measure the weight required to depress a key (they have to do this on different octaves because the weight is different) and they compare it to whatever acoustic piano -- but on an acoustic piano the weight is easily tunable so it's something pretty useless to do. And the required weight is far from being the only parameter that often makes acoustic pianos somehow more difficult to play than electronic pianos, but with a better overall rendering...

Also, as some others already mentionned, different actions fit different sounds. I choose the P-250 because of its very good mapping between the key feeling and the Grand Piano 1 sound (yes, the Rhodes is crappy). Most probably, there were some pianos that sounded better or that had a better action than the P-250, but the mapping was not done properly, so the musical rendering in live was less good.


Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator     Back to top
John Reid
member


Joined: 11/09/02
Posts: 133
Loc: Craggy Island
Re: 88 key MIDI controllers - KX8, CME UF80, FATAR, what to get? new [Re: McGreevy]
      #728169 - 22/04/09 06:17 PM
Quote McGreevy:

On a quick skim through your thread it seems nobody has suggested the M-Audio Keystaion 88 Pro. I see other M-Audio devices have been mentioned, but strangely not this one.



I'd be very interested to hear some feedback from an 88Pro user ... this is on my own shortlist as well!


Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator     Back to top
The_Big_Piano_Player
active member


Joined: 13/05/04
Posts: 1657
Loc: Lincolnshire
Re: 88 key MIDI controllers - KX8, CME UF80, FATAR, what to get? new [Re: John Reid]
      #728279 - 23/04/09 07:58 AM
Quote John Reid:

I'd be very interested to hear some feedback from an 88Pro user ... this is on my own shortlist as well!




I have the M-audio ProKeys 88, a stage piano which, I can only assume, has a similar action to the 88pro.

I'll be honest, I found the action to be a little clunky, and the unit has gradually become more unreliable. Granted, it did a lot of gigs, and was bashed about a lot, so I did expect a bit of wear-and-tear.

I wouldn't recommend it. The action just isn't fast enough for a competent player. The fatar, or roland keyboards have a much better action, in my opinion.

--------------------
Touch & Go


Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator     Back to top
DPolwarth



Joined: 13/08/07
Posts: 62
Re: 88 key MIDI controllers - KX8, CME UF80, FATAR, what to get? new [Re: DPolwarth]
      #728287 - 23/04/09 08:22 AM
Okay guys, here's an update. I've managed to find the Yamaha KX8 on Soundslive for £399 - a great price when you consider that DV247 are charging £499 for it, and are selling a B-stock repaired item for the same price that Soundslive is charging for a brand new unit. The next cheapest is still £40 more expensive, so it looks like Soundslive are seriously undercutting the competition. Whilst they have none in stock at the moment, this gives me a breather. The item's on order, but I can always cancel before it comes in.

But I have nagging doubts. Should I have gone for the Fatar Studiologic, and risked a badly made keyboard? Should I have gone for the Chinese CME?

Have I made the right decision?

So here it is: please tell me what you would have bought had you been in my position, and give me your reasons. There is still time to change my mind, and I really would like to hear your opinions on this.

Thanks again, guys!


Daniel


Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator     Back to top
Stephen Parker



Joined: 28/02/05
Posts: 180
Loc: Falmouth, Cornwall
Re: 88 key MIDI controllers - KX8, CME UF80, FATAR, what to get? new [Re: DPolwarth]
      #728314 - 23/04/09 09:45 AM
Just to correct some assumptions on Fatar - I used to be the distributor for both Fatar and CME so have a reasonable idea on them - and I'm not any more so can be relatively impartial.

Fatar keyboards strength is that their keyboard action is almost always better than the competition - they've been doing these for years and all of the bigger manufacturers used to use Fatar keys before some moved production in house.

The two weaknesses are that the older packaging used to be poor so that they would often sustain damage in transit - partly due to the older boxes being badly fitting, and partly because UK courier drivers don't tend to like carrying a 30kg keyboard - my favourite one was a courier picking up 3 or 4 keyboards from Arbiter, throwing them in the back of the van and then stamping on one to get the door shut - in front of me!!

I digress - second the MIDI controller sections were a little basic compared to the competition - you'll notice that their newer NUMA models (inc the NUMA NANO)don't really feature too many knobs or faders - they've decided to leave this to those manufacturers who do it better and concentrate on the keyboard playing action and the general packaging.

So to summarise - get a Fatar if you want really good keyboard action..

CME - they're well packaged and the UF series are pretty solid - there have been some USB issues but not a very large incidence of failure - we never got many back at all - build is good and features are pretty strong although I always found that there were sometimes a few too many features - ie you wished they hadn't tried to cram so much in.

hope that helps..

Steve Parker
2twenty2


Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator     Back to top
The_Big_Piano_Player
active member


Joined: 13/05/04
Posts: 1657
Loc: Lincolnshire
Re: 88 key MIDI controllers - KX8, CME UF80, FATAR, what to get? new [Re: DPolwarth]
      #728315 - 23/04/09 09:46 AM
That's a good price for the KX8. I've used one, and it's perfectly acceptable. The difference between that and the equiv. Fatar model (SL990XP) is as much about personal taste as anything (as has been pointed-out already).

--------------------
Touch & Go


Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator     Back to top
onesecondglance



Joined: 02/01/08
Posts: 2140
Loc: Reading, UK
Re: 88 key MIDI controllers - KX8, CME UF80, FATAR, what to get? new [Re: Stephen Parker]
      #728320 - 23/04/09 10:05 AM
Quote Stephen Parker:



I digress - second the MIDI controller sections were a little basic compared to the competition - you'll notice that their newer NUMA models (inc the NUMA NANO)don't really feature too many knobs or faders - they've decided to leave this to those manufacturers who do it better and concentrate on the keyboard playing action and the general packaging.

So to summarise - get a Fatar if you want really good keyboard action...




that's a good point - i've got an SL990 Pro and the action is great, but one of the keys has had a nasty squeak since day one as if one of the mechanisms has been damaged; still plays fine though so doesn't really bother me. i can well imagine how less-conscientious couriers would not exactly take care of them given their weight and bulk... you're right, too, that they've never really gone for lots of controllers - but then there are folks out there like myself who have no need for these, so if you're one of them i can't recommend Fatar enough.

--------------------
hourglass | random thoughts | doubledotdash!? collective


Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator     Back to top
DPolwarth



Joined: 13/08/07
Posts: 62
Re: 88 key MIDI controllers - KX8, CME UF80, FATAR, what to get? new [Re: DPolwarth]
      #728351 - 23/04/09 11:04 AM
Just to add to the growing list of nightmares about the Fatar keyboards, I read a review yesterday from someone who received his keyboard with the modulation wheel damaged. He contacted the manufacturer and they sent him out a new wheel with instruction on how to take apart the keyboard and reassemble it to put the new component in place! Stories like this are so common for Fatar stuff its frightening. Another guy wrote how the keyboard arrived with three 'limp' keys.

While I totally accept that some damage may be due to transit, there seems to be an awful lot of people complaining about the condition of these items. And that does not explain about the electrician who opened one up to find that they use the same electrical controllers that you would find in a remote control, rather than a quality electrical instrument.

Here is an excerpt from the customer review:



Quote:

"While I was impressed about overall manufacturing quality, I noticed some serious weak points. First of all, I clearly heard that C1 sounds much louder than adjacent keys. To make it clear, I connected SL-990 to MIDI analyzer. Can you imagine my surprise when C1 and D1 being pushed together gave velocity difference about 20???30%!!! For example, C1 velocity value 55 while D1 ??? 40! Also, I discovered many other keys with nonuniformity about 10??? 15%
The second problem was occasional Pitch Bend false response ??? of course, without touching any wheel.
And third, I was disappointed because of non-supporting Sostenuto and Soft pedals ??? it???s very serious shortcoming for piano-MIDI. As a result, your claim in Manual about ???full-featured instrument??? sounds ridiculous.

"Since I professional in electronics, I disassembled the keyboard and investigated key sensors. As I can see, it???s no wonder that velocity mismatch occur: the design of sensor just the same as in cheap remote controls, without trimming possibility. I hoped you employed accelerometer sensors but truth was shocking."





I apologise for the appalling grammar in the quote, not to mention the bizarre punctuation, but then I didn't write it.

In short, it looks like Fatar are taking shortcuts 'underneath the hood.' Also, even if it is the couriers fault, it does not counter the argument that the item is not likely to get to me in one piece, and that Fatar should be aware of the problem and package their items properly.


As for the CME, I don't know. Too many people have advised against one of these for me to be totally confident in them. If people say 'don't buy CME' its hard to ignore their advice. I would be more conducive to purchasing their products if Sound on Sound hadn't given on of their MIDI controllers a total beasting in a review. I can't remember the exact model, but it was the one with the motorised faders that proved to be utterly unfit for purpose.

And yet I am torn. I would dearly love to get the Fatar keyboard for the action. But after the horror stories from end users, I'd be a fool to take the risk, surely?

Or would I? Please give me your advice. In particular, I'd like to hear from Fatar users who have not had trouble with their keyboards. Sure there must be some ...


Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator     Back to top
onesecondglance



Joined: 02/01/08
Posts: 2140
Loc: Reading, UK
Re: 88 key MIDI controllers - KX8, CME UF80, FATAR, what to get? new [Re: DPolwarth]
      #728358 - 23/04/09 11:16 AM
Quote DPolwarth:


And yet I am torn. I would dearly love to get the Fatar keyboard for the action. But after the horror stories from end users, I'd be a fool to take the risk, surely?

Or would I? Please give me your advice. In particular, I'd like to hear from Fatar users who have not had trouble with their keyboards. Sure there must be some ...




i suppose i count - the only "fault" (as above) is a small mechanical squeak on one key. it's completely imperceptible when playing at usual listening volumes - i only noticed it when my cat walked across it whilst the computer was off!

--------------------
hourglass | random thoughts | doubledotdash!? collective


Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator     Back to top
Stephen Parker



Joined: 28/02/05
Posts: 180
Loc: Falmouth, Cornwall
Re: 88 key MIDI controllers - KX8, CME UF80, FATAR, what to get? new [Re: DPolwarth]
      #728770 - 24/04/09 02:56 PM
Quote DPolwarth:

Just to add to the growing list of nightmares about the Fatar keyboards, I read a review yesterday from someone who received his keyboard with the modulation wheel damaged. He contacted the manufacturer and they sent him out a new wheel with instruction on how to take apart the keyboard and reassemble it to put the new component in place! Stories like this are so common for Fatar stuff its frightening. Another guy wrote how the keyboard arrived with three 'limp' keys.

While I totally accept that some damage may be due to transit, there seems to be an awful lot of people complaining about the condition of these items. And that does not explain about the electrician who opened one up to find that they use the same electrical controllers that you would find in a remote control, rather than a quality electrical instrument.

Here is an excerpt from the customer review:



Quote:

"While I was impressed about overall manufacturing quality, I noticed some serious weak points. First of all, I clearly heard that C1 sounds much louder than adjacent keys. To make it clear, I connected SL-990 to MIDI analyzer. Can you imagine my surprise when C1 and D1 being pushed together gave velocity difference about 20???30%!!! For example, C1 velocity value 55 while D1 ??? 40! Also, I discovered many other keys with nonuniformity about 10??? 15%
The second problem was occasional Pitch Bend false response ??? of course, without touching any wheel.
And third, I was disappointed because of non-supporting Sostenuto and Soft pedals ??? it???s very serious shortcoming for piano-MIDI. As a result, your claim in Manual about ???full-featured instrument??? sounds ridiculous.

"Since I professional in electronics, I disassembled the keyboard and investigated key sensors. As I can see, it???s no wonder that velocity mismatch occur: the design of sensor just the same as in cheap remote controls, without trimming possibility. I hoped you employed accelerometer sensors but truth was shocking."





I apologise for the appalling grammar in the quote, not to mention the bizarre punctuation, but then I didn't write it.

In short, it looks like Fatar are taking shortcuts 'underneath the hood.' Also, even if it is the couriers fault, it does not counter the argument that the item is not likely to get to me in one piece, and that Fatar should be aware of the problem and package their items properly.


As for the CME, I don't know. Too many people have advised against one of these for me to be totally confident in them. If people say 'don't buy CME' its hard to ignore their advice. I would be more conducive to purchasing their products if Sound on Sound hadn't given on of their MIDI controllers a total beasting in a review. I can't remember the exact model, but it was the one with the motorised faders that proved to be utterly unfit for purpose.

And yet I am torn. I would dearly love to get the Fatar keyboard for the action. But after the horror stories from end users, I'd be a fool to take the risk, surely?

Or would I? Please give me your advice. In particular, I'd like to hear from Fatar users who have not had trouble with their keyboards. Sure there must be some ...




I'm sorry, but one unclear review from an 'electrical engineer' does not mean that Fatar are 'taking shortcuts'.. When the guy says "the design of sensor just the same as in cheap remote controls, without trimming possibility. I hoped you employed accelerometer sensors but truth was shocking." He's saying the design, not the actual components - after all I would imagine that components such as resistors and capacitors are used in all kinds of electronic devices, but that doesn't mean they are unsuitable for use in a controller keyboard.

He also mentions that the keyboard is the SL-990 - is that the original, the SL-990 Pro or the SL-990XP, all of which are different?

I'd suggest that maybe you speak to our old service engineers at Cimple Solutions who carried out warranty work for Fatar and they can give you a completely unbiased opinion - as I said earlier, I used to be the distributor so may have a slightly better idea of the keyboards reliability than an anonymous forum poster.

Or you could just buy the KX8..

Cheers

Steve Parker
2twenty2


Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator     Back to top
DPolwarth



Joined: 13/08/07
Posts: 62
Re: 88 key MIDI controllers - KX8, CME UF80, FATAR, what to get? new [Re: DPolwarth]
      #728791 - 24/04/09 03:36 PM
Quote:

as I said earlier, I used to be the distributor so may have a slightly better idea of the keyboards reliability than an anonymous forum poster.

Or you could just buy the KX8..






I've bought the KX8.


Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator     Back to top
Stephen Parker



Joined: 28/02/05
Posts: 180
Loc: Falmouth, Cornwall
Re: 88 key MIDI controllers - KX8, CME UF80, FATAR, what to get? new [Re: DPolwarth]
      #728801 - 24/04/09 03:56 PM
Excellent - hope you enjoy it - i've heard that the KX8 is a decent keyboard and I hope you understood my points on Fatar - and that they came across correctly.

Cheers

Steve Parker
2twenty2


Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator     Back to top
DPolwarth



Joined: 13/08/07
Posts: 62
Re: 88 key MIDI controllers - KX8, CME UF80, FATAR, what to get? new [Re: DPolwarth]
      #728822 - 24/04/09 04:48 PM
I'm sure the Fatar is an excellent keyboard. But it doesn't take many searches on the internet to find people who are unhappy with the condition they receive it in. I find it hard to dismiss the evidence. I don't doubt you feel the Fatar is an excellent product, and many people who have a working Fatar keyboard are more than happy with it.

Let me put it this way. When I went online I had certain expectations. I thought that people would complain about the build quality of the CME, and say that it was a poor keyboard at a knockdown price. I was equally expecting the Fatar to get rave reviews, but complaints about its lack of features. And I was expecting the Yamaha to be a nice 'in-between' kind of keyboard - solid, but not fantastic.

In reality, I found something totally different. People genuinely like the CME and loved the feel of the keyboard. Their only gripe was lack of support. No problems about build quality mentioned.

The Yamaha no one had much of an opinion on, other than to say it was a bit plasticky but was genuinely pretty good.

The Fatar got an extreme reaction. It had far, far more complaints about the build quality than the CME did - the opposite of what I was expecting. Of course there were a lot of people who loved the keyboard, and it does seem it has the best feel. But the reports of poor build-quality cannot be ignored. They are universal. So many people have complaints about it that it would be foolish to even consider making the purchase. Word of mouth counts, and word of mouth on the Fatar is very, very bad.

Put it another way: for me, this is a big purchase, like buying a car. If people complained about a car company as much as people complain about the Fatar, that company would not be receiving a bailout from Barack Obama ...


Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator     Back to top
John Reid
member


Joined: 11/09/02
Posts: 133
Loc: Craggy Island
Re: 88 key MIDI controllers - KX8, CME UF80, FATAR, what to get? new [Re: DPolwarth]
      #728971 - 25/04/09 09:26 AM
Congratulations on your KX8, hopefully once you've had some time with it you'll let us know what you think of it!

As a Cubase-using guitarist in the market for a good 88-key weighted MIDI master keyboard, I've found this thread very informative and the integration with Cubase would be of particular interest.


Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator     Back to top
aviray



Joined: 20/11/08
Posts: 242
Loc: frankfurt
Re: 88 key MIDI controllers - KX8, CME UF80, FATAR, what to get? new [Re: DPolwarth]
      #728979 - 25/04/09 09:47 AM
KX series of Yamaha is the biggest recycling attempt in this industry. They repacked huge stocks of the parts that were used in their cheapo series from past decade, that goes for all the smaller models, perhaps 88 uses different keys , I hope for you.
Regarding Fatars I dont know where the "better" keys would be coming from, China ? All the decent controllers like Doepfer, Clavia even Novation use Fatar keys. That Fatar never had good chassis that is another story but myself am not aware of better keys, parts/keyboards for other manufacturers is Fatars main biz.
CME is not bad at all for the money, unreliable USB, technology that challanges intellectual capacity of the company but hooked via midi can work fine.
My personal fav - Doepfer, will serve you forever.


Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator     Back to top
Stephen Parker



Joined: 28/02/05
Posts: 180
Loc: Falmouth, Cornwall
Re: 88 key MIDI controllers - KX8, CME UF80, FATAR, what to get? new [Re: DPolwarth]
      #729734 - 28/04/09 09:08 AM
I forgot to add, for the record earlier that on my last trip to Fatar at the end of Dec 07 we spent a lot of time working on the packaging for the newer keyboards - they improved the boxes for the older keyboards, but the boxes for the NUMA and now Numa Nano are much more robust (and better fitting), and the design of the keyboards themselves should improve their ability to withstand even UK couriers handling.

Cheers

Steve Parker
2twenty2


Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator     Back to top
aviray



Joined: 20/11/08
Posts: 242
Loc: frankfurt
Re: 88 key MIDI controllers - KX8, CME UF80, FATAR, what to get? new [Re: Stephen Parker]
      #729877 - 28/04/09 03:11 PM
Quote Stephen Parker:

I forgot to add, for the record earlier that on my last trip to Fatar at the end of Dec 07 we spent a lot of time working on the packaging for the newer keyboards - they improved the boxes for the older keyboards, but the boxes for the NUMA and now Numa Nano are much more robust (and better fitting), and the design of the keyboards themselves should improve their ability to withstand even UK couriers handling.

Cheers

Steve Parker
2twenty2



I really like that Numa Nano , good keys that do not weight a tone, that is tempting Could you say something more about the keys? How do they compare to other (heavy) models.


Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator     Back to top
Pages: 1 | 2 | (show all)

Rate this thread

Jump to

Extra Information
0 registered and 41 anonymous users are browsing this forum.

Moderator:  David Etheridge, James Perrett, zenguitar, Martin Walker, Forum Admin, Hugh Robjohns, Zukan, Frank Eleveld, SOS News Editor,  
Forum Permissions
      You cannot start new topics
      You cannot reply to topics
      HTML is disabled
      UBBCode is enabled
Rating: *****
Thread views: 20285

August 2014
On sale now at main newsagents and bookstores (or buy direct from the
SOS Web Shop)
SOS current Print Magazine: click here for FULL Contents list
Click image for August 2014
DAW Tips from SOS

 

Home | Search | News | Current Issue | Tablet Mag | Articles | Forum | Subscribe | Shop | Readers Ads

Advertise | Information | Privacy Policy | Support | Login Help

 

Email: Contact SOS

Telephone: +44 (0)1954 789888

Fax: +44 (0)1954 789895

Registered Office: Media House, Trafalgar Way, Bar Hill, Cambridge, CB23 8SQ, United Kingdom.

Sound On Sound Ltd is registered in England and Wales.

Company number: 3015516 VAT number: GB 638 5307 26

         

All contents copyright © SOS Publications Group and/or its licensors, 1985-2014. All rights reserved.
The contents of this article are subject to worldwide copyright protection and reproduction in whole or part, whether mechanical or electronic, is expressly forbidden without the prior written consent of the Publishers. Great care has been taken to ensure accuracy in the preparation of this article but neither Sound On Sound Limited nor the publishers can be held responsible for its contents. The views expressed are those of the contributors and not necessarily those of the publishers.

Web site designed & maintained by PB Associates | SOS | Relative Media