Frank Rideau
Joined: 21/03/11
Posts: 186
|
Recording acoustic guitar to sound like a classical
#919048 - 08/06/11 03:45 PM
|
|
|
This question may sounds strange but... Is it possible to record an
acoustic guitar (Steel strings) and to make it sound a bit softer like a nylon strings
classical guitar. Is there some specific EQuing and/or mic placement that could help ? Currently, my recording with an acoustic sounds like...an acoustic steel-strings
guitar (part played with the fingers). I used my Audio-Technica T2020 near the body from
under ( I thought that close-miking near the neck would give too much high frequencies
from the steel strings). Anyway, I know I should ask someone to lend me his
classical  , but I was just asking for fun what would be possible to do during recording
or with processing.
-------------------- http://soundcloud.com/orgasmo-sonore Revisiting Obscure Film Music
|
zenguitar
active member
Joined: 05/12/02
Posts: 7592
Loc: Devon
|
Re: Recording acoustic guitar to sound like a classical
[Re: Frank Rideau]
#919065 - 08/06/11 05:07 PM
|
|
|
The only thing I can think of that would even get slightly close would be the Fishman Aura
16. Dave Lockwood reviewed it for SOS in the Nov 07 issue. When Dave reviewed
it there were different versions loaded with suitable models for different types of
acoustic, including nylon strings. It appears now it comes pre-loaded with 16 Dreadnought
models and software that allows you to download alternative models. So that's how you get
the nylon string models. It works by creating a fingerprint EQ using two
thousand EQ bands. Dave's review tells you a little more about how it works. But if you
are thinking of 'emulating' a nylon stringer with EQ, this will work a lot better than
desk EQ and any plugins you might have. One thing is certain though, it won't
sound remotely like a real nylon stringer. But it might have enough of that flavour to
work in your mix. Andy
-------------------- When the going gets weird, the Weird turn Pro.
|
zenguitar
active member
Joined: 05/12/02
Posts: 7592
Loc: Devon
|
Re: Recording acoustic guitar to sound like a classical
[Re: Frank Rideau]
#919067 - 08/06/11 05:13 PM
|
|
|
And as a quick second thought.... You can buy nylon strings with ball ends. So
at a push you could try a set of those on your steel string. HOWEVER, the saddle
compensation is different for nylon strings so it won't intonate perfectly. And you might
need to reduce the tension on the truss rod to avoid a back bow on the neck with the nylon
strings fitted. It will sound better than my previous suggestion, but still not
as good as a real classical guitar. You need to make some serious adjustments to the
guitar, and you might need Melodyne DNA to sort out the tuning problems. So still not an
easy or effective solution. Andy
-------------------- When the going gets weird, the Weird turn Pro.
|
DAGGILARR
Joined: 22/09/10
Posts: 540
Loc: Exeter, Devon.
|
Re: Recording acoustic guitar to sound like a classical
[Re: Frank Rideau]
#919076 - 08/06/11 05:30 PM
|
|
|
|
I think depends on what you want. If you want the listener to truly believe it is a nylon
strung classical guitar then It will probably be tricky, but if you just want it to sound
a bit "classical like" then first look to your playing style strike the strings way
towards the neck, and adjust the angle of attack. Using a pick up DI may give you more
potential to mess with the sound, EQ, comp, you may get a version that works
OR get a midi set up and use a sampled classical. I have tried some samples and it not
that great to be honest.
-------------------- Strictly an amateur with some nice toys,
|
grab
Joined: 08/07/07
Posts: 2626
Loc: Cambridge, UK
|
Re: Recording acoustic guitar to sound like a classical
[Re: Frank Rideau]
#919102 - 08/06/11 07:28 PM
|
|
|
|
Re stringing a steel-string-designed guitar with nylons, you're also going to have
problems with the string action. Nylon strings tend to travel further than steel strings,
so your strings are likely to keep bashing and buzzing on the frets.
Cheap
classicals are (by definition) inexpensive, and they're usually perfectly reasonable
instruments. Check your local Gumtree or other free ads page - if you can't find
something under £50, you really aren't looking. If you can play then you can rule out any
complete dogs when you give them a quick try before buying. Sure it won't sound like a
million bucks, but with new strings it'll still sound like a reasonable nylon-string
guitar. And the player always makes more difference anyway.
|
Dave B
Joined: 03/04/03
Posts: 5366
Loc: Maidenhead
|
Re: Recording acoustic guitar to sound like a classical
[Re: Frank Rideau]
#919129 - 08/06/11 10:24 PM
|
|
|
I find myself smiling at Zen's solutions. Whilst completely fine and totally do-able, it
could well be pointed out that a dedicated processor, strange strings and a huge amount of
ITB processing might well be the definition of over-engineering a solution......  Just borrow a classical!!!
-------------------- Veni, Vidi, Aesculi
(I came, I saw, I conkered)
|
zenguitar
active member
Joined: 05/12/02
Posts: 7592
Loc: Devon
|
Re: Recording acoustic guitar to sound like a classical
[Re: Frank Rideau]
#919145 - 09/06/11 12:06 AM
|
|
|
Yes Dave, I agree, borrow (or even buy a cheap) classical, the OP mentioned it himself But in the spirit of answering the original question I thought it might be
informative to look at the alternatives. Partly because it shows the extent of the
compromise required and makes the argument to use the real thing perfectly. But also
because it does open the door for happy accidents. Andy
-------------------- When the going gets weird, the Weird turn Pro.
|
Dynamic Mike
Joined: 31/12/06
Posts: 1471
|
Re: Recording acoustic guitar to sound like a classical
[Re: Frank Rideau]
#919146 - 09/06/11 12:34 AM
|
|
|
In Cubase6 you can record an audio track as usual from your steel strung guitar, then
using Variaudio enable pitch-to-midi & play it back using a classical guitar sample in
Halion. However your playing style needs to be very clean otherwise you can lose a day
cleaning up the midi-track. Actually it might be quicker to dispense with the guitar
altogether & just whistle it into pitch-to-midi.
-------------------- Not much in life worth running for. Or from.
|
Jack Ruston
Joined: 21/12/05
Posts: 4064
|
Re: Recording acoustic guitar to sound like a classical
[Re: Frank Rideau]
#919151 - 09/06/11 03:45 AM
|
|
|
As suggested, buy or borrow a classical guitar. You can get something decent for very
little money. There is honestly no other way to do this properly. All digital mucking
about with acoustic stringed instruments sounds deeply unconvincing. You could spend
hundreds of quid and hours of time with midi pickups, samplers, sound shaping this and
that and will sound absolutely rubbish compared with a cheap classical. The tension,
action and spacing change the way you play too. J
-------------------- www.jackruston.com
|
djangodeadman
member
Joined: 18/02/03
Posts: 300
Loc: Brighton
|
Re: Recording acoustic guitar to sound like a classical
[Re: Dynamic Mike]
#919268 - 09/06/11 12:39 PM
|
|
|
Quote Dynamic Mike:
In Cubase6
you can record an audio track as usual from your steel strung guitar, then using Variaudio
enable pitch-to-midi & play it back using a classical guitar sample in Halion. However
your playing style needs to be very clean otherwise you can lose a day cleaning up the
midi-track. Actually it might be quicker to dispense with the guitar altogether & just
whistle it into pitch-to-midi.
Variaudio only works on monophonic sources,
though, so it would depend on what you were playing.
|
Dynamic Mike
Joined: 31/12/06
Posts: 1471
|
Re: Recording acoustic guitar to sound like a classical
[Re: djangodeadman]
#919442 - 10/06/11 12:29 AM
|
|
|
Quote djangodeadman:
Quote Dynamic Mike:
In Cubase6
you can record an audio track as usual from your steel strung guitar, then using Variaudio
enable pitch-to-midi & play it back using a classical guitar sample in Halion. However
your playing style needs to be very clean otherwise you can lose a day cleaning up the
midi-track. Actually it might be quicker to dispense with the guitar altogether & just
whistle it into pitch-to-midi.
Variaudio only works on monophonic sources,
though, so it would depend on what you were playing.
True, although I suppose you could just play the root &
insert the rest of the chord if you wanted. And I defy anyone to whistle a chord!
-------------------- Not much in life worth running for. Or from.
|
Richie Royale
Joined: 12/09/06
Posts: 3350
Loc: Bristol, England.
|
Re: Recording acoustic guitar to sound like a classical
[Re: Dynamic Mike]
#919478 - 10/06/11 07:55 AM
|
|
|
Quote Dynamic Mike:
And I defy
anyone to whistle a chord!
Tuvan throat singing is essentially multiple tones.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VTCJ5hedcVA (Not sure if this is a good
example, I'm at work)
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tuvan_throat_singing
-------------------- http://soundcloud.com/richie-royale
http://www.mixcrate.com/richieroyale
|