Difficult call. Usually when offered a choice between two I like the
option of having both, but this is a little more complicated...
Well, I am a
long term Orange fan
The Rockerverb 50 is a fine tool, and it seems that it ticks plenty of boxes for you.
Have you considered some form of power soak or attenuator to use with the Orange instead?
I love the clean sound from Orange amps (I have an early 70's graphic 120, and with the
gain pulled back it sounds lovely. Not a Fender but plenty of clean headroom.) and if you
love the hi gain sounds so much, you won't find anything else quite the same.
Sorry if that puts a spanner in the works, but it's always a good rule of thumb to
remember that you bought your current gear for a reason. No matter what has happened
since, when it came to putting your hand in your pocket and handing over the cash (or
signing the agreement), you shopped around and decided it was what you wanted.
When the going gets weird, the Weird turn Pro.