The Elf
active member
Joined: 14/08/01
Posts: 8216
Loc: Sheffield, UK
|
Re: Awesome product v's Fair Price?
[Re: Korff]
#934854 - 17/08/11 11:31 AM
|
|
|
Quote Korff:
Quote Commander:
speak.
Ghastly word, that. Very
tinny...
Aaaaaaiiiiiieeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee!!!!!
-------------------- An Eagle for an Emperor, A Kestrel for a Knave.
|
The Red Bladder
Joined: 05/06/07
Posts: 2100
Loc: . ...
|
Re: Awesome product v's Fair Price?
[Re: sthum]
#934855 - 17/08/11 11:36 AM
|
|
|
All of you, you are trying to discuss the following topics, without actually known what it
is you are trying to discuss -
Cross_elasticity_of_demand
Price_elasticity_of_demand
Marginal_costs
Fixed_costs
Snob_effect
Your homework is now to actually write 250 of your own words (that this time make
sense) avoiding the word 'nub', introducing no fewer than two of the above concepts, as
applied to sample libraries. At least one calculation, showing changes in profit at
different prices, is to be included and at least one example of fixed costs in software
must be shown and discussed. Marks will be deducted for excessive length.
|
narcoman
active member
Joined: 14/08/01
Posts: 8476
|
Re: Awesome product v's Fair Price?
[Re: The Red Bladder]
#934858 - 17/08/11 11:41 AM
|
|
|
Quote The Red Bladder:
All of
you, you are trying to discuss the following topics, without actually known what it is you
are trying to discuss -
Ah bladders. But I DO know
Seems a couple of others do too - it's the decriers that don't!
|
The Elf
active member
Joined: 14/08/01
Posts: 8216
Loc: Sheffield, UK
|
Re: Awesome product v's Fair Price?
[Re: The Red Bladder]
#934861 - 17/08/11 11:50 AM
|
|
|
Dear lord!! I have visions of my old red A-Level 'Economics' folder with a
'Wind and Wuthering' sticker on the cover, a drawing of a MiniMoog in every margin and
lots of cost/benefit diagrams in blue and red ink. No - I won't go back there I
tell you. No! No!
-------------------- An Eagle for an Emperor, A Kestrel for a Knave.
|
jellyjim
active member
Joined: 15/05/02
Posts: 2957
Loc: uk
|
Re: Awesome product v's Fair Price?
[Re: narcoman]
#934866 - 17/08/11 12:07 PM
|
|
|
Quote narcoman:
Quote The Red Bladder:
All of
you, you are trying to discuss the following topics, without actually known what it is you
are trying to discuss -
Ah bladders. But I DO know 
Seems a couple of others do too - it's the decriers that don't!
bladder!
Now that's a hell
of a word!
"Speak!" He cried as he caught his bladder between the buttocks
of that damn nub.
-------------------- Original artwork and unique devices inspired by vintage technology http://www.thisisobsolete.com
|
The Red Bladder
Joined: 05/06/07
Posts: 2100
Loc: . ...
|
Re: Awesome product v's Fair Price?
[Re: narcoman]
#934873 - 17/08/11 12:22 PM
|
|
|
Quote narcoman:
But I DO know

Seems a couple of others do too - it's the decriers that don't!
Marks can only be allocated for topics that
are clearly linked to a named and established economic theory or phenomenon. Candidates
must be able to show that, when discussing broad issues of commercial economic theory,
they are able to identify and discuss the theories underlying such topics and provide
examples of calculations based on these.
Extra points may be awarded for
graphs with included formulae, showing optimum pricing for intellectual property. Special
attention is to be paid to the differences between physical goods and such intellectual
property as a sample library, outlining the variations in importance of fixed and variable
costs in different types of goods.
|
JamesSimpson
Joined: 24/12/05
Posts: 1066
|
Re: Awesome product v's Fair Price?
[Re: sthum]
#934880 - 17/08/11 12:43 PM
|
|
|
Many of us are not rich or snobs. As you have rather wonderfully put it shtum. I run a recording studio for the love of it, I compose music with some like minded
cohorts in my spare time in some wild aim for some success somehow. My studio
has very expensive high quality equipment in it. My flat is a 1 room studio with very
little else apart from a bed a sofa and a basic kitchen. My monitoring system
is worth well over £3000, my computer £2000, Pro Tools rig £2000, Mic pre's £1000.
That is so much more than the contents of my flat. I am not rich neither are many of the
people I collaborate or hang around with. Most of us, due to my persuasion have
considered that paying proper prices for software is a good thing. If you need to save up
lots of money for that £300 drum library, it will make you think is it what you really
need and is it worth it? Stuff like this is actually made worse by cut down
versions of things or bundling Logic Pro to students for £120, the content you get is
RIDICULOUS, by ridiculous I mean fantastic value for money and an absolutely amazing
deal. I have only just recently finished a university course with huge debt and
mostly a big fat waste of time, but I am not about to start pirating sample libraries. I
would perhaps have understood more if you had made the statement about something far more
expensive for example Hollywood strings is more than double your £300 statement and all
you get in that is strings right? But even then the development costs are huge numbers for
recording large numbers of top level players with the right gear in the right rooms. I guess the thing is you can't fake orchestral sampling too well, you need the
best to sound the best. And the best costs....
-------------------- Squarehead Jam Jar Facebook Jam Jar
|
narcoman
active member
Joined: 14/08/01
Posts: 8476
|
Re: Awesome product v's Fair Price?
[Re: The Red Bladder]
#934893 - 17/08/11 02:05 PM
|
|
|
Quote The Red Bladder:
Quote narcoman:
But I DO know
Seems a couple of others do too - it's the decriers that don't!
Marks can only be allocated for topics
that are clearly linked to a named and established economic theory or phenomenon.
Candidates must be able to show that, when discussing broad issues of commercial economic
theory, they are able to identify and discuss the theories underlying such topics and
provide examples of calculations based on these.
Extra points may be
awarded for graphs with included formulae, showing optimum pricing for intellectual
property. Special attention is to be paid to the differences between physical goods and
such intellectual property as a sample library, outlining the variations in importance of
fixed and variable costs in different types of goods.
OR
I make money.
|
Steve Hill
member
Joined: 07/01/03
Posts: 13140
Loc: Oxfordshire
|
Re: Awesome product v's Fair Price?
[Re: The Red Bladder]
#934896 - 17/08/11 02:12 PM
|
|
|
Quote The Red Bladder:
All of
you, you are trying to discuss the following topics, without actually known what it is you
are trying to discuss -
Less
of the "all" please.
-------------------- Dynamite with a laser beam...
|
Shreddie
Joined: 16/01/08
Posts: 319
|
Re: Awesome product v's Fair Price?
[Re: Hugh Robjohns]
#934897 - 17/08/11 02:12 PM
|
|
|
Quote Hugh Robjohns:
It feels a
bit like the world is against Sthum and he feels the need to keep repeating his views in
an ever-more strident way as a defence.
Of course, everyone is entitled to their opinion but the reason why
many of us seem to be against Sthum are because we're struggling to make sense of their
views.
In my own case, I did used to have similar views to Sthum... Until I
started to learn more about it.
Now Sthum... What I don't understand about your
argument is how you'll happily pay for a Mercedes C class and some rather expensive
monitors... Take your Mercedes, I believe it's a £32,000 car or there abouts. Now, why
did you pay that much? It's clearly over priced considering that similarly sized Fords and
Skodas etc can be than half the price yet cost roughly the same to produce.
And
what about your monitors? £2500?!?!?! Jeez! When there are others for £250 that once
again have a comparable production cost? Why do it?
Could it possibly be
because they are better products? And could it be that those products are better because
the manufacturers have spent so much more on development? And that's why they cost so much
more then their less expensive counterparts?
I used to work in manufacturing so
I know how the costs are broken down... Profit and the cost of the components are amongst
the smallest things (your Mercedes for example will cost less than £5000 in terms of the
component costs for example), it's usually the cost of development that's the biggie.
That's why your Mercedes costs £32,000 and a similar Ford or Skoda doesn't, Mercedes
spend around £5 million per day on development and the others don't. The only way the
development costs can be offset is by economies of scale... There more you expect to sell,
the lower the price can be. If it's something that you're only going to sell a few of
(such as the Spitfire Audio products mentioned earlier) then the prices have to be much
higher.
It doesn't matter whether it's a car, a pair of monitors or a sample
library, all of the above still applies. Ok, so a downloadable sample library can
effectively be duplicated for free but that's not where it's cost lies.
In the
case of the one you mention, it's very much a niche product that few will be interested
in... Even if it was available for free I wouldn't bother with it and I guess many others
may feel the same. Lets say for example, at $299, they get 1000 customers over the next 12
months (that's probably a fairly realistic number of customers btw)... If it was sold for
$99, how many more sales would they get? I'd guess, given the kind of product it is, that
they'd struggle to get 500 more which would result in a significant loss of revenue and
could well result in wiping out any profit. And you really expect them to sell it for
$99?
Seriously, while we would all like things to be less expensive, this is
the real world, we can't always get what we want.
|
narcoman
active member
Joined: 14/08/01
Posts: 8476
|
Re: Awesome product v's Fair Price?
[Re: Steve Hill]
#934904 - 17/08/11 02:41 PM
|
|
|
Quote Steve Hill:
Quote The Red Bladder:
All of
you, you are trying to discuss the following topics, without actually known what it is you
are trying to discuss -
Less
of the "all" please.
Oops!! Forgot about you!!
|
hollowsun
Joined: 20/01/05
Posts: 4592
Loc: Cowbridge, South Wales
|
Re: Awesome product v's Fair Price?
[Re: Commander]
#934910 - 17/08/11 02:57 PM
|
|
|
Quote Commander:
my first
sampler (Akai S900 - still got it in a lock up somewhere)
And ironically, some of the very people who
complain about the cost of software and libraries, etc., will give you good money for that
old relic!
-------------------- Website / Music Lab Machines / Blog
|
. . . Delete This
Here be Dragons
Joined: 23/06/08
Posts: 3888
|
Re: Awesome product v's Fair Price?
[Re: The Elf]
#934912 - 17/08/11 02:59 PM
|
|
|
Quote The Elf:
Dear lord!!
I have visions of my old red A-Level 'Economics' folder with a 'Wind and
Wuthering' sticker on the cover, a drawing of a MiniMoog in every margin and lots of
cost/benefit diagrams in blue and red ink.
No - I won't go back there I tell
you. No! No!
we share the
same nightmare-ish memories.... barring the minimoog, mine had pictures of les pauls
and pointy headstocks.
|
JamesSimpson
Joined: 24/12/05
Posts: 1066
|
Re: Awesome product v's Fair Price?
[Re: narcoman]
#934922 - 17/08/11 03:49 PM
|
|
|
Quote narcoman:
Quote The Red Bladder:
Quote narcoman:
But I DO know

Seems a couple of others do too - it's the decriers that don't!
Marks can only be allocated for topics that
are clearly linked to a named and established economic theory or phenomenon. Candidates
must be able to show that, when discussing broad issues of commercial economic theory,
they are able to identify and discuss the theories underlying such topics and provide
examples of calculations based on these.
Extra points may be awarded for
graphs with included formulae, showing optimum pricing for intellectual property. Special
attention is to be paid to the differences between physical goods and such intellectual
property as a sample library, outlining the variations in importance of fixed and variable
costs in different types of goods.
OR
I make money.
Alright for some innit.
-------------------- Squarehead Jam Jar Facebook Jam Jar
|
sthum
Joined: 05/06/08
Posts: 247
|
Re: Awesome product v's Fair Price?
[Re: sthum]
#934924 - 17/08/11 04:13 PM
|
|
|
. I AM SO GLAD I STARTED THIS THREAD...... Thanks
to everyone for their honest views! Regardless of whether you agreed with me or not. I take my hat off to you HOLLOWSUN! You handled yourself impeccably (bar
the odd jibe)  I would never have known (on a personal level) just how deeply
damaging piracy can be to all concerned and the serious emotive issues involved. You think you know... but unless you hear it from the horses mouth you don't really
know anything! And your right when you say that the pirates believe that they are
sticking it to the big companies rather than smaller hard working real life
individuals. To hear a personal account too was very constructive, so I thank
you for taking time to enlighten me! Indeed I believe that I've clearly
demonstrated my sympathies for software developers everywhere! That included you too
Hollowsun! I am still of the opinion that ONE of the main reasons why piracy
exists today and will always continue to flourish is because of excessively high retail
prices! I see and hear this every time I'm out on the ground. From the very
people who do it on a regular basis. Of course there should never be an excuse for
piracy and those that think otherwise are just kidding themselves! As I've said
I have talked at great length with many groups of young people about this very topic and I
can tell you that a good few of them would prefer not to and actually do not download
anything illegally. Instead they save up like everyone else and eventually buy what they
need. On a few occasions (during debate related subjects) they too have stood up for
the music industry. Mainly citing their love for the artist as one of the main reasons
why they are prepared to part with their cash. They believe that if they do not
support their favourite artist that they (the artist) may stop producing great original
music because of lack of financing! Its good to see that they actually embrace this
train of thought. At least its a start! There again over the past
couple of years we've seen a dramatic drop in retail prices for both CD Albums and DVD's.
As you all know years ago a cd album used to cost any where between £12.99 and
£16.99. Which even then I thought was disgusting. Now most of them are under £10. I would love to know what the figures are in relation to this? As to whether they're
selling more albums now because of the low prices and has this reinvigorated the publics
interest in buying a legit version? I believe that the average person would rather
pay for and receive the original cd, art work and dual case. So they can be stacked
nicely in their cool neatly displayed album collection. Especially if it doesn't cost
them an arm and a leg. Could this thinking be applied to music software
development? All I've ever received were card board boxes.. BORING!! The logic
Pro box is quite cool and is certainly an attractive way to present the product you've
spent months or years developing. Surely the packaging is an essential part of
getting your product right? I know i'd rather receive a shiny/cool box for my sample
collection than the usual hard paper. Apple excel in this field every time they
package something! Even their iMac's are a delight to unravel. The re
emergence of the Vinyl format too was interesting? As far as I know the pirates haven't
bothered with it? Its just a pity you can't sell your samples via an awkward format
like vinyl? I have also heard many kids state that the reason why they don't
buy into the pirated games scene is because they are afraid that Games developers will
stop making games as a result? To finish.... I am of course entitled
to my own opinion and as such I stand by most of what I've said in this thread. One thing is obvious though.... this is a very hot topic! OK Hugh....
If you like... You can shut it down now? Sthum............ .
|
Steve Hill
member
Joined: 07/01/03
Posts: 13140
Loc: Oxfordshire
|
Re: Awesome product v's Fair Price?
[Re: sthum]
#934926 - 17/08/11 04:19 PM
|
|
|
|
CD sales are down, EMI is in administration, Warners are not far behind.
-------------------- Dynamite with a laser beam...
|
narcoman
active member
Joined: 14/08/01
Posts: 8476
|
Re: Awesome product v's Fair Price?
[Re: JamesSimpson]
#934928 - 17/08/11 04:26 PM
|
|
|
Quote JamesSimpson:
Alright for some innit.
Diversify. It's the only way!
|
A Non O Miss
Joined: 07/02/08
Posts: 914
|
Re: Awesome product v's Fair Price?
[Re: sthum]
#934946 - 17/08/11 06:21 PM
|
|
|
"Everybody is a genius. But if you judge a fish by its ability to climb a tree, it
will live its whole life believing that it is stupid." — Albert Einstein
|
Anonymous
Unregistered
|
Re: Awesome product v's Fair Price?
[Re: sthum]
#934952 - 17/08/11 06:51 PM
|
|
|
|
I suppose there could be an argument that samplists have actually got a bloody cheek
complaining about people ripping off their samples when they, in some cases, are sampling
the sounds of instruments that had fortunes in R&D, manufacture, marketing,
distribution etc, spent on them in the first place.
I mean what have these
sampling Johnnies ever done for us?
I mean really; look at the state of the
music industry? People would say that actually it's never been so lively and varied and
vibrant and exciting and experimental - but thats's rubbish. It's like standing next to a
fax machine which is pumping out page after page of faxes of the paintings of the great
masters, one after the other.
Yes, you can see what they are, but there's no
depth, no originality, no brush strokes. And by now there's so many of the damned things
that you are papering the walls with them. And nobody can sell a real painting because
there's no room on the walls and so artists stop making good paintings and anyway
everyone's had fax painting up to here - everytime they walk past the fax machine there's
another pile of the rubbish!
And the studios are closing and the picture
framers have all shut down and the last of the die-hard professionals are now sucked into
this madness and they are on the fax painting bandwagon and pumping out two a day just to
keep their head above water 'cos a really good fax painting might fetch a penny a copy but
lots of people are doing them for free!
I know, silly aren't I?
But a lot of people say they can trace the demise of what we used to know as the music
industry back to the internet, but me, i say it was the proliferation of relatively
cheap/free high quality samples.
Because now anyone with a keyboard and one
of those piano roll editor DAW gadgets can make studio quality sounding music to
their hearts content and they are, and they are flooding the earth with this crap to - imo
- the detriment of music itself.
|
hollowsun
Joined: 20/01/05
Posts: 4592
Loc: Cowbridge, South Wales
|
Re: Awesome product v's Fair Price?
[Re: sthum]
#934953 - 17/08/11 06:51 PM
|
|
|
Quote sthum:
I take my hat off to
you HOLLOWSUN! You handled yourself impeccably (bar the odd jibe) 
I would never have known (on a personal level) just how deeply damaging piracy can be to
all concerned and the serious emotive issues involved. You think you know... but
unless you hear it from the horses mouth you don't really know anything! And your
right when you say that the pirates believe that they are sticking it to the big companies
rather than smaller hard working real life individuals.
To hear a personal
account too was very constructive, so I thank you for taking time to enlighten me!
Indeed I believe that I've clearly demonstrated my sympathies for software
developers everywhere! That included you too Hollowsun!
I know that and no animosity here (despite the odd
jibe!) - I am glad I have been able to maybe give you an insight or two of life on the
other side of the fence. Pass it on.
Must dash, though - have to dress for
dinner as the butler's just banged the gong to summon us!
-------------------- Website / Music Lab Machines / Blog
|
turtles
Joined: 22/10/04
Posts: 235
Loc: Notts, mostly.
|
Re: Awesome product v's Fair Price?
[Re: hollowsun]
#934980 - 17/08/11 09:29 PM
|
|
|
|
Way way waaaay back to the beginning...
The cost of those sample packages = ten
hours of my local top class drummer's time and travel costs, i.e. Two live sessions if
he's parachuted in to replace some i-go-faster-when-i-hit-harder talent.
Everyone has a cost of living, and for equivalent top dollar samples that doesn't seem
an unreasonable cost in comparison, particularly as the samples don't get tired, spill
drinks over my kit, lose time, smack the OH mic because they missed their last fill, or
cough during a cymbal tail-off which is a &£!?@! to clean up in post.
Nothing stopping you sampling a kit yourself, if you think the cost is prohibitive.
Tell us how you get on :-)
|
russ123
Joined: 01/10/05
Posts: 612
Loc: northwest uk
|
Re: Awesome product v's Fair Price?
[Re: sthum]
#934985 - 17/08/11 09:49 PM
|
|
|
|
Nub, nub speak Nub, speak Nub, nub speak Nub, speak
..................This thread's got a great beat!
|
jellyjim
active member
Joined: 15/05/02
Posts: 2957
Loc: uk
|
Re: Awesome product v's Fair Price?
[Re: sthum]
#935011 - 18/08/11 12:37 AM
|
|
|
I've just spent $99 on some plug-ins for Adobe Premiere Pro that make video look like
OH MY GOD ALL
THIS FOR $99 LOUSY BUCKS THAT"S MENTAL!
(the main demo is a bit cheesy,
look at the demos in each plug-in page instead, they're only 10 seconds long or
thereabouts)
Amazing stuff.
I think that's cheap. Their full
suite is $500. That's too expensive for me but that doesn't mean it's
expensive per se. In reality the kind of video guys who use this sort of stuff in
their jobs probably earn that in a day anyway.
I think some people who don't
place a high value on software either don't know how to use it or lack the imagination to
see it's potential.
-------------------- Original artwork and unique devices inspired by vintage technology http://www.thisisobsolete.com
Edited by jellyjim (18/08/11 12:39 AM)
|
hollowsun
Joined: 20/01/05
Posts: 4592
Loc: Cowbridge, South Wales
|
Re: Awesome product v's Fair Price?
[Re: jellyjim]
#935023 - 18/08/11 02:05 AM
|
|
|
Sorry but I can't resist... The photo/video version of THIS
for audio (if you have Kontakt) ... Put the turd back into your polish!!  Bugger - Hugh's chasing me round the room now with a baseball bat!
-------------------- Website / Music Lab Machines / Blog
|
Stan
Joined: 17/01/05
Posts: 1311
Loc: Big Rock Candy Mountain
|
Re: Awesome product v's Fair Price?
[Re: sthum]
#935025 - 18/08/11 02:16 AM
|
|
|
|
sthum did say Sample Logic Rumble pack, Marching and Cinematic Drums was an awesome
product - which is nice.
sthum - did you need it?
-------------------- .. is this thing on?
Edited by Stan (18/08/11 02:22 AM)
|
Music Manic
active member
Joined: 20/12/02
Posts: 1945
Loc: London UK
|
Re: Awesome product v's Fair Price?
[Re: ]
#935033 - 18/08/11 04:51 AM
|
|
|
Quote ow:
The Bow is used to play
rhe violin (and other stringed instruments) and create the music; it's part of the
intsrument so to speak.
Hope this helps.
Computers are a musical instrument too.
Believe it or not engineers are a part of the music. Do you think Hendrix built all
his effects and engineered his own stuff to create the final sound?
The bow
won't make the player more imaginative but will create a sweeter sound. Just like 96k.
Hope that helps you understand my point.Feel free to ask if you still don't get it.
Too many nitpickers here who think they're smart!
|
Anonymous
Unregistered
|
Re: Awesome product v's Fair Price?
[Re: Music Manic]
#935034 - 18/08/11 05:44 AM
|
|
|
Quote Music Manic:
...The bow
won't make the player more imaginative...
I disagree
Quote:
Too many nitpickers here who think they're smart!
I agree
|
* User requested ...
Joined: 31/08/05
Posts: 1693
|
Re: Awesome product v's Fair Price?
[Re: Music Manic]
#935040 - 18/08/11 07:03 AM
|
|
|
Quote Music Manic:
The bow
won't make the player more imaginative
Oh I dunno. Jimmy Page seemed to find a new lease of life with
it.
|
* User requested ...
Joined: 31/08/05
Posts: 1693
|
Re: Awesome product v's Fair Price?
[Re: ]
#935041 - 18/08/11 07:04 AM
|
|
|
Quote ow:
Quote Music Manic:
...The bow
won't make the player more imaginative...
I disagree
Quote:
Too many nitpickers here who think they're smart!
I agree
I concur with those sentiments.
|
* User requested ...
Joined: 31/08/05
Posts: 1693
|
Re: Awesome product v's Fair Price?
[Re: A Non O Miss]
#935042 - 18/08/11 07:16 AM
|
|
|
Quote A Non O Miss:
"Everybody is a genius. But if you judge a fish by its ability to climb a tree, it will
live its whole life believing that it is stupid." — Albert Einstein
"On my first day at
Princeton, one of the class bought me an enourmous round chocolate cake with 'Saturnian
rings' made from marzipan and jam. At the time I was pleased and took it home to my wife
who, whilst appreciating the sentiment, was a little angry because she had put me on a
strict diet the week before...in the end, we ended up giving it to Mr. Ovenwald next
door..."
|
Howdy Doody Time
Joined: 18/01/09
Posts: 437
Loc: Huai Yai, Chon Buri, Siam
|
Re: Awesome product v's Fair Price?
[Re: sthum]
#935045 - 18/08/11 07:29 AM
|
|
|
If this is not a wind up, then it is trolling. This particular troll has managed to
get more 'air space' than any other I've seen by retaining enough apparent integrity to
fool the forum experts here, who would certainly have given short shrift to a more easily
classified troll.
-------------------- The only excuse we have for making music in the first place is to make it differently..vis-a-vis our own difference (Glenn Gould)
|
jellyjim
active member
Joined: 15/05/02
Posts: 2957
Loc: uk
|
Re: Awesome product v's Fair Price?
[Re: Music Manic]
#935051 - 18/08/11 07:58 AM
|
|
|
Quote Music Manic:
Too many
nitpickers here who think they're smart!
Too many nitpickers here who ARE smart you mean
-------------------- Original artwork and unique devices inspired by vintage technology http://www.thisisobsolete.com
|
hollowsun
Joined: 20/01/05
Posts: 4592
Loc: Cowbridge, South Wales
|
Re: Awesome product v's Fair Price?
[Re: Music Manic]
#935072 - 18/08/11 09:20 AM
|
|
|
Quote Music Manic:
The bow won't
make the player more imaginative but will create a sweeter sound.
I am assuming you don't actually play the violin.
-------------------- Website / Music Lab Machines / Blog
|
Music Manic
active member
Joined: 20/12/02
Posts: 1945
Loc: London UK
|
Re: Awesome product v's Fair Price?
[Re: hollowsun]
#935160 - 18/08/11 03:51 PM
|
|
|
Quote hollowsun:
Quote Music Manic:
The bow
won't make the player more imaginative but will create a sweeter sound.
I am assuming you don't actually play the violin.
No I don't, but I know a
stradivarius will sound better than a £50 violin because of the engineering and physics.
Nothing to do with musicianship which, again, is my point of wanting to know the mechanics
of how a computer re-produces sound which is sweetest to my ears. Please don't talk about
production. How will the bow be creative? If it's different to a bow that you've
learnt on. then your mechanics will have to readjust and most probably dampen you. Living
life and the conditions you're under makes me more creative than having to try a different
pick on my guitar.
As to Jimmy Page's use of one? Mmm! didn't really do much
for me. Did it help him create those great riffs? I don't think so, I reckon it was the
sound of his guitar and amp and the contemporary sound of rock/blues. I don't think he
would of got the same feel by using a mandolin.
It's an engineers job to get
the best sound recording and the artist's to create the best performance. I've had to
learn how to mix and engineer my songs because there are too many cowboys out there.
Computers win hands down when you think of all the processes you had to go through in the
analogue world. There are too many bad productions and mixes that spoil my enjoyment.
I have many different recordings of the four seasons. Some send a shiver down my spine
and some don't even move me. Exactly the same notes on each.
If you believe
this forum is just for the experts to talk, then we'll all leave you to it and you'll have
a magazine that sells 20 copies only.
Hugh and Dan don't nitpick, they educate
and correct while airing there views without taking sides. IMO that's the sign of a true
pro.
|
Music Manic
active member
Joined: 20/12/02
Posts: 1945
Loc: London UK
|
Re: Awesome product v's Fair Price?
[Re: Howdy Doody Time]
#935161 - 18/08/11 03:55 PM
|
|
|
Quote Howdy Doody Time:
If
this is not a wind up, then it is trolling. This particular troll has managed to get more
'air space' than any other I've seen by retaining enough apparent integrity to fool the
forum experts here, who would certainly have given short shrift to a more easily
classified troll.
That's
Democracy.
|
Anonymous
Unregistered
|
Re: Awesome product v's Fair Price?
[Re: Music Manic]
#935168 - 18/08/11 04:36 PM
|
|
|
Quote Music Manic:
Quote Howdy Doody Time:
If this is not a wind up, then it is trolling. This particular troll has managed to get
more 'air space' than any other I've seen by retaining enough apparent integrity to fool
the forum experts here, who would certainly have given short shrift to a more easily
classified troll.
That's
Democracy.
[deepWestCountryAccent]
Might not be a troll, might be a WITCH!
Lots'a'witches round these parts at this time'a'year, havin' opinions and changin' their
minds - tricky they be - tricky as a fox. I've seen 'em, at dusk, arguin' amongst
'emselves and cookin' up their trouble.
Look at his nose! If that ain't a
witches nose i dunno what is. Lets get the boys from the village and show this bloody big
nosed witch what we do to his kind round these parts.
[/deepWestCountryAccent]
|
hollowsun
Joined: 20/01/05
Posts: 4592
Loc: Cowbridge, South Wales
|
Re: Awesome product v's Fair Price?
[Re: Music Manic]
#935171 - 18/08/11 04:49 PM
|
|
|
Quote Music Manic:
How will the
bow be creative?
Because it
enables you to play better and articulate and phrase better.
Buy some lumpen
cheap carbon fibre thing and it's a struggle when crossing strings especially in faster
pieces with rapid arpeggios, etc. (such as Bach's violin concerto, for example).
And balance is important. The bow is held and moved (bowed) and subtly rotated
with just a few fingers that have to deal with all sorts of techniques from long,
sustained languid notes to tight marcato and detaché and countless other techniques. And
there's playing on the edge of the bow or playing with a flatter bow and anywhere in
between and all of this can change in microseconds. Balance, therefore, is vitally
important for the player to manipulate the bow effectively to obtain the most expression
(and hence 'creativity') out of the instrument.
Weight is also important and
a heavier (cheap) bow is more difficult to manipulate. You can't compare it with playing a
guitar, the strings of which are on a flat plain; with a fiddle and the arc of the
strings, the angle of the bow and the point of contact is vital and a heavy bow is hard to
manage and articulate phrases, etc., fluidly. And tiring - if you have seen the right hand
arm movement of a typical violinist, you might understand how weight matters.
If I was to draw any kind of comparison with a guitar, it'd be to suggest doing some
high speed shredding with a 50p coin instead of your usual plectrum ... which might give
you some idea but it's not an ideal analogy.
Modern carbon fibre bows
are good but they can't compare with a hand crafted, hand balanced, lightweight wooden bow
of old. And you pay for those.
And £2,000 is actually not a lot compared
with some and if you watch The Proms, each of the string players in the orchestra may well
have £75,000's worth of fiddle and bow under their chins.
Yes - you can get
cheaper bows and you may well be lucky. There's one violin soloist of yesteryear who was
appearing in a concert in America and broke his bow and bought some cheap thing for
something like $1 in a second-hand shop...
And it was perfect for him and
stayed with him all his career.
Our daughter had this bow on loan from her
teacher for quite a while (it was the one he used when he was a pro player) and she
immediately felt 'at one' with it - the balance and weight, etc., suited her physique and
strength. Then it came up for sale (only because her teacher bought a better one - price
unknown but more than we paid). If her teacher had chosen to, he could have put it on the
open market and got three times that much (or more) but he wanted it to go to a good
home.
So having established that the bow is an essential part of
playing the violin, how that player is recorded is of no consequence to me. I have
recordings of her on a cheap VCR and recordings of her done in a professional studio that
caters specifically for classical music recording and it's the 'performance' that's the
most important thing, not the recording quality necessarily and whether my daughter is
recorded on a cassette machine or ProTools running at 192kHz is irrelevant - her
'performance' is all-important and this bow, though it may seem overkill, allows her to
perform better and more expressively and more creatively.
-------------------- Website / Music Lab Machines / Blog
|
Music Manic
active member
Joined: 20/12/02
Posts: 1945
Loc: London UK
|
Re: Awesome product v's Fair Price?
[Re: ]
#935177 - 18/08/11 05:13 PM
|
|
|
Quote ow:
Quote Music Manic:
Quote Howdy Doody Time:
If this is not a wind up, then it is trolling. This particular troll has managed to get
more 'air space' than any other I've seen by retaining enough apparent integrity to fool
the forum experts here, who would certainly have given short shrift to a more easily
classified troll.
That's
Democracy.
[deepWestCountryAccent]
Might not be a troll, might be a WITCH!
Lots'a'witches round these parts at this time'a'year, havin' opinions and changin' their
minds - tricky they be - tricky as a fox. I've seen 'em, at dusk, arguin' amongst
'emselves and cookin' up their trouble.
Look at his nose! If that ain't a
witches nose i dunno what is. Lets get the boys from the village and show this bloody big
nosed witch what we do to his kind round these parts.
[/deepWestCountryAccent]
Yes witches have that label because
they they don't agree with everyone and don't succumb to the sycophants.
Enjoy
your forum it belongs to you.
|
* User requested ...
Joined: 31/08/05
Posts: 1693
|
Re: Awesome product v's Fair Price?
[Re: Music Manic]
#935179 - 18/08/11 05:18 PM
|
|
|
Quote Music Manic:
Quote ow:
Quote Music Manic:
Quote Howdy Doody Time:
If this is not a wind up, then it is trolling. This particular troll has managed to get
more 'air space' than any other I've seen by retaining enough apparent integrity to fool
the forum experts here, who would certainly have given short shrift to a more easily
classified troll.
That's
Democracy.
[deepWestCountryAccent]
Might not be a troll, might be a WITCH!
Lots'a'witches round these parts at this time'a'year, havin' opinions and changin' their
minds - tricky they be - tricky as a fox. I've seen 'em, at dusk, arguin' amongst
'emselves and cookin' up their trouble.
Look at his nose! If that ain't a
witches nose i dunno what is. Lets get the boys from the village and show this bloody big
nosed witch what we do to his kind round these parts.
[/deepWestCountryAccent]
Yes witches have that label because
they they don't agree with everyone and don't succumb to the sycophants.
Enjoy
your forum it belongs to you.
clunkety clunk...ting..ting..ting...clunk...
(this is the unmistakeable
sound of toys being thrown out of a pram...)
|
Music Manic
active member
Joined: 20/12/02
Posts: 1945
Loc: London UK
|
|
Quote:
clunkety
clunk...ting..ting..ting...clunk...
(this is the unmistakeable sound
of toys being thrown out of a pram...)
Your pram obviously.
Words of a coward viewing the
action
How sweet!
|