Choosing the right gear
#964504 - 17/01/12 02:34 AM
Edit
Reply
Quote
Hello everyone.
I have a query regarding my ideal perfect studio setup. I
attended a Sound Engineering course at a college called IMW in Islington and they housed a
SSL SL4000G+. I LOVED the versatility of this desk, it literally had every single feature
i could possible desire along with the best sound i've ever heard. This has motivated me
to attempt to create a setup using the features I require only but with the same
flexibility, quality and ease of use.
I have a very low budget but am willing
to save up some money for the best possible quality without unnecessary extras costing
more money than its worth to me.
I make beats strictly software and sample
based. I don't play any instruments myself and have only ever recorded any at college,
where I engineered a 10 mic drum set for the first time. I have friends who rap and sing
and I doubt I will be recording anything more than them. At least not all at once.
The ideal setup for me would be this:
RECORDING
Condenser Mic
> XLR Cable > Preamp > Compression > EQ > Digital Cable (SPDIF, etc.) > Pro Tools
Interface > Firewire Cable > Pro Tools
FEATURES
Talkback Mic, Multiple
speaker monitoring, 2+ Headphone Outputs, Midi DAW control, all ins and outs balanced...
and all this preferably in one or two units.
The aim is a central
workstation. Very much like the Mindprint Trio but with an SSL quality preamp and
dynamics. With no loss of quality or inheritance of earth hums or interference.
I may be asking for too much but I thought i'd try my luck here and see if anyone has a
similar setup or knowledge of how to go about it.
Things I've been looking at
with similar setups but just not cutting it:
Custom built Asus tower, AMD Phenom II X4
940 3.00Ghz processors, 4GB RAM, full HD graphics, 500GB 7200 Hard drive 20" monitor.
M-Audio Firewire Solo audio interface.
Yamaha HS80M monitors X2.
Behringer
BCF2000 Midi controller.
Rode NT1A microphone.
Behringer B2 Pro
microphone.
Alesis Monitor Two 3-way monitors - powered by old Pioneer hi fi
amp.
M-Audio Keystation 49 midi keyboard.
All Neutrik connections and premium
cables.
Any ideas/help would be much appreciated!!!!
Please
message me with any questions you have and I will try to answer them to the best of my
knowledge.
Re: Choosing the right gear
[Re: SkamUK]
#964533 - 17/01/12 09:39 AM
Edit
Reply
Quote
I also use an SSL front end. I chose a pair of SSL Superanalogue Channel strips for their
quality and flexibility - these are essentially SSL 4000G channels in a rack box. These
connect to my audio interface digitally (digital I/O was an option for the Superanalogue
Channel Strip), so the audio interface's own A/D isn't used - an important aspect of
keeping the sound quality as high as possible.
I would not routinely use any
compression/EQ while tracking, but I like to come out/back to the channel strips later, as
necessary.
The Alpha Channel would be a good alternative to a Superanalogue
Channel and is something I've sniffed at a few times to provide me with more SSL-ish
channels.
For monitor/headphone outputs (and to enable me to use external
effects, including my SSL Channels) I chose an audio interface with a healthy amount of
I/O - an RME Fireface 800. The main headphone output is for my monitoring. I use separate
outputs for control room headphones, studio headphones, main monitors, alternative
monitors, etc - each to their own amp. The main monitors are connected via a monitor
controller (Furman), which gives me level control, switchable speaker options and a
further headphone output. For talkback I simply use one of the Fireface's mic input and a
PA mic with latch/momentary switch.
Cubase's Control Room is a massive
advantage for monitor/foldback control. Ffor me that's where the story ends. With Pro
Tools I set up a similar routing system, but I handle the routing in RME's TotalMix. It's
not as slick as Control Room, but it works
HTH!
-------------------- An Eagle for an Emperor, A Kestrel for a Knave.
Re: Choosing the right gear
[Re: The Elf]
#964623 - 17/01/12 03:06 PM
Edit
Reply
Quote
Thanks for your reply!
I can't find anywhere that sells that superanalogue
channel. The alpha channel only had some form of limiter and I would rather have more
control with compression. SSL have released the new range of superanalogue and the nearest
thing is the x-rack which is capable of too much. I just want the one mono channel.
Ive been looking at some other forums on choosing the right pre-amp for rap
vocals. The Mindprint Envoice MKII looks perfect but is it going to produce the right
sound I'm looking for? I definitely want a preamp with built in compressor and eq, with a
gate and or valve being a bonus, with a digital output.
Below is a draft song
of my mate rapping. It has been recorded on my behringer b2 pro through my firewire solo
processed after using waves ssl channel rtas plugins, although I plan to use the NT1A
unless anyone thinks otherwise? It doesnt sound bad but i want a more powerful and rich
sounding vocal. The instrumental is also an mp3 taken from youtube so it doesnt help with
judgement. I can upload clean and processed vocals if it helps.
I think i'll
stick with the Presonus Monitor Station, I was considering the central station due to it
being passive but it's twice the price and i've heard people have problems with the
remote. My room is untreated, do you think i will be able to hear the difference? I spent
a lot of money on these HS80M's i dont want to compromise any quality.
Re: Choosing the right gear
[Re: SkamUK]
#964636 - 17/01/12 03:48 PM
Edit
Reply
Quote
The Superanalogue Channel is secondhand only, I'm afraid, hence my suggesting the Alpha as
a good alternative.
You seem to be fighting a lot of battles all at once
here. I'd advise stepping back and sorting out a list of priorities, then work through
them without rushing things.
Some items will have a bigger impact on your
recordings than others - some items need the support of other purchases to make the best
of them. There's little point in springing for an SSL front end, then feeding it with a
Behringer mic for vocals. Good monitoring and room treatment will likely have a much
bigger early impact than a boutique mic pre.
First up I'd look to replace
that Behringer mic as soon as possible TBH. Then roll up your sleeves and look at room
treatment. A decent vocal mic and a sympathetic room will likely have a significant
positive impact at this stage - the mic pre can wait. That's quite a woolly-sounding mix
above, and that could be relective of your room.
-------------------- An Eagle for an Emperor, A Kestrel for a Knave.
Re: Choosing the right gear
[Re: The Elf]
#964640 - 17/01/12 04:09 PM
Edit
Reply
Quote
Problem I have is that im using my bedroom at the moment, I placed the mic in the corner
of the room with duvets hung around it. Im moving my bedroom/studio into a larger room
soon, and the mrs wants it all decorated nice and isnt happy with the idea of having foam
on the walls (annoying). I might be able to push to build a very small booth in the corner
but am i better off in a bigger space or small space acoustically treated. Im talking
enough room to fit mic and artist only!
The only reason i'm looking at pre's is
because i want to have compresson and eq on my vocals before they enter pro tools, and
figured it would make sense to buy a unit with a pre at a similar cost. Surely any
dedicated pre is going to sound better that the one built into my Firewire solo.
Also are mic reflection filters worth looking at?
The behringer won't sell
for anything i doubt so i'll just keep it in the cupboard. But do you think the NT1A is
suitable for this type of recording?
Re: Choosing the right gear
[Re: SkamUK]
#964667 - 17/01/12 07:04 PM
Edit
Reply
Quote
Quote: ...I have a query
regarding my ideal perfect studio setup. I attended a Sound Engineering course at a
college called IMW in Islington and they housed a SSL SL4000G+. I LOVED the versatility of
this desk, it literally had every single feature i could possible desire along with the
best sound i've ever heard. This has motivated me to attempt to create a setup using the
features I require only but with the same flexibility, quality and ease of use.
I have a very low budget but am willing to save up some money for the best possible
quality without unnecessary extras costing more money than its worth to me.
I
make beats strictly software and sample based. I don't play any instruments myself and
have only ever recorded any at college, where I engineered a 10 mic drum set for the first
time. I have friends who rap and sing and I doubt I will be recording anything more than
them. At least not all at once.
The ideal setup for me would be this:
RECORDING Condenser Mic > XLR Cable > Preamp > Compression > EQ > Digital Cable
(SPDIF, etc.) > Pro Tools Interface > Firewire Cable > Pro Tools
FEATURES Talkback Mic, Multiple speaker monitoring, 2+ Headphone Outputs, Midi DAW control, all
ins and outs balanced... and all this preferably in one or two units.
The aim
is a central workstation. Very much like the Mindprint Trio but with an SSL quality preamp
and dynamics. With no loss of quality or inheritance of earth hums or interference.
I may be asking for too much but I thought i'd try my luck here and see if anyone
has a similar setup or knowledge of how to go about it...
You have in general shown interest in a
production rig that has: -presumably low simultaneous input channel count -cue
mix ability -control surface ability -monitoring control ability -basic
signal processing ability -interfacing with Pro Tools -all the necessary
peripherals
...and you want everything to sound good.
That can
definitely be assembled for a few thousand to tens of thousands of dollars and plenty of
people can name drop which brands you could buy. But none of that will make your work
sound good. You could go out and buy an SSL Duality and put it in your house and it still
wouldn't necessarily solve anything. Because the quality of your work comes from how you
use the stuff. You have to know enough about why things sound like they sound before you
can envision a truly "ideal" rig.
You already have things to work with. If I
was in your position I'd start with thinking about one piece to upgrade at a time. Start
with the stuff that is closest to the source.
I'd think more about: -room acoustics -microphones -a simple, high quality channel input
You might be surprised how much you can get out of something like a nice channel strip
with a nice mic. I'm not completely sold on the idea of SSL as the main channel input
(nothing wrong with SSL, just not as much sonic "extra" as I like for a main channel
input).
You might consider the CAD e100s as a mic. I find it versatile, quiet
and very classy sounding. A good channel input unit you might consider would be the
Universal Audio 6176 channel strip. It's great for many things, especially vocals, has a
simple, powerful EQ and a really nice compressor that is very similar to an 1176LN. It
has "vibe" which is often something that is hard to get form SSL on the preamp, channel
strip side of things. As always, to each their own way.
Re: Choosing the right gear
[Re: SkamUK]
#964723 - 18/01/12 07:03 AM
Edit
Reply
Quote
Quote SkamUK: The only reason i'm
looking at pre's is because i want to have compresson and eq on my vocals before they
enter pro tools
Why? There's
absolutely no need.
Quote: I might be able to push to build a very small booth in the corner but am i better
off in a bigger space or small space acoustically treated. Im talking enough room to fit
mic and artist only!
It's a tall
order to construct something that small that won't make your vocals sound like they are
being recorded in a cupboard. I really wouldn't go down this route.
Quote: Also are mic reflection
filters worth looking at?
Certainly, but a couple of well-placed duvets can be just as effective.
Quote: The behringer won't
sell for anything i doubt so i'll just keep it in the cupboard. But do you think the NT1A
is suitable for this type of recording?
I believe the Rode would probably be better suited than the Behringer,
but let your ears tell you - don't just take the word of a forum post!
Wise
words from Liz above! Aspiring to an SSL if all well and good, but I'm unconvinced it's
your top priority at this stage, given your mic collection and recording environment. Slow
down, think it through and spend your money wisely.
-------------------- An Eagle for an Emperor, A Kestrel for a Knave.
Re: Choosing the right gear
[Re: EnlightenedHand]
#964862 - 18/01/12 09:44 PM
Edit
Reply
Quote
I've taken everything youve said on board and it makes a lot more sense to start with the
fundamentals first...
So, after some hard thinking and some persuasion with
the mrs, i am able to look at acoustically treating the bedroom! So I'm over the moon at
the moment!!!
I've been reading sos smart guide magazine on monitors and
headphones in the acoustic treatment section. I understand placement using mirror points,
bass traps etc. Im going to cover around 20% of the walls as I have a very large window, 2
doors and a double bed in the room. Also the room is not a boxed shape as i have 2 alcoves
and a cylinder cupboard so its got a lot of angles.
Design of bedroom layout
without treatment:
It seems correct after reading here and
on various forums and websites to construct some 600x1200 panels from wood rockwool and
foam. I might be asking the wrong people here but is there a specific type of foam to use
as i have seen flat sheets of furniture foam cut to size that are 1" thick for very cheap!
Ive looked on auralex and other commercial acoustic foam sites and it all seems
ridiculously over priced. If not are there any other alternatives to foam. I can't have
old duvets or things like that as it has to look good in order for it to be possible. Were
going to be spending a lot of money re-decorating and re-furnishing the bedroom we don't
want it ruined.
A good example of what i want to build:
I also want to get some chrome pipe and some long
screws to pull them away from the wall a little to make more use of the panels. Also have
some dim lights behind them to keep the mrs happy and set a comfortable mood in the
studio.
Ok, so, forget SSL. I was just using that as an example. It was just
the only channel strip i knew much about really. Ive seen channel strips for £300-400
that have digital output, preamp, comp, gate, limiter and tube. I was just wondering if
anyone here has had an encounter of a good mic/channel strip combination for rap vocals,
obviously rap is a lot faster regarding attack release ect, and im looking for a sense of
warmth and oldschool, similar to reel to reel tape recording but this is another device
that i dont think i should be buying until i have a good mic and channel strip. Im trying
to kill a few birds with one stone.
I thought the nt1a sounded reasonable but
i want a signiture sounding recording that stands out. The nt1a doesnt seem to do that at
the moment but with a good channel strip it may? and i don't mean good as in
expensive.
I don't plan to buy all of these things any time soon, at least
not all at once. I just want to paint a picture of what I'm going to need in the near
future.
Thanks for your reply's everyone it's been very helpful and much
appreciated!
Re: Choosing the right gear
[Re: EnlightenedHand]
#964876 - 18/01/12 11:34 PM
Edit
Reply
Quote
Quote: You might consider the
CAD e100s as a mic. I find it versatile, quiet and very classy sounding. A good channel
input unit you might consider would be the Universal Audio 6176 channel strip. It's great
for many things, especially vocals, has a simple, powerful EQ and a really nice compressor
that is very similar to an 1176LN. It has "vibe" which is often something that is hard to
get form SSL on the preamp, channel strip side of things. As always, to each their own
way.
Thanks I will defo have
a look into these. Reading about the mic now, looks good so far but would like to test it
somewhere.
Re: Choosing the right gear
[Re: SkamUK]
#964904 - 19/01/12 07:42 AM
Edit
Reply
Quote
Quote SkamUK: I was just
wondering if anyone here has had an encounter of a good mic/channel strip combination for
rap vocals, obviously rap is a lot faster regarding attack release ect,
This is largely irrelevant if you track cleanly,
then process in the box afterwards. There's absolutely no need to compress as you record.
Once you have a clean, unprocessed recording, with ample headroom, into your DAW you have
a world of plug-in compressors with which to tweak your vocals to perfection without
risking having mucked it up with inappropriate settings at the tracking stage.
The SSL Alpha is a good pre and worthy of your attention once you have a good mic under
your belt. I'm also a huge fan of the Focusrite Liquid Channel, which covers many bases
and can also be accessed as an external plug-in, after tracking, via its digital I/O. Not
cheap, but when you consider its capabilities this remains one of my best buys.
I'm generalising here, but many rappers seem to prefer dynamic mic's, with the humble
SM57 putting in many appearances in my experience, though I often use an MD421 to good
effect. The SM7 and RE20 also crop up quite often too. Any of these mic's will represent a
good investment as they can be used in all styles and over a wide range of sources to good
effect.
That said, if you're looking for a more impressive/larger than life
tone then a decent LDC is still the order of the day - and there's much more to recording
vocals than just rap, after all. At this point you can pay anything you like and it's
pretty much down to 'you get what you pay for'. At the budget end I like the MXL V67G,
which, although it suffers from a massive amount of proximity effect, is still a great
sounding mic on many vocalists, if you can get hold of one. After that it's all about what
takes your fancy and how much you want to pay - and auditioning a few mic's becomes more
important the more you pay.
Good luck with it!
-------------------- An Eagle for an Emperor, A Kestrel for a Knave.
Re: Choosing the right gear
[Re: The Elf]
#964927 - 19/01/12 10:02 AM
Edit
Reply
Quote
Quote SkamUK:
Thanks I will
defo have a look into these. Reading about the mic now, looks good so far but would like
to test it somewhere.
If
that's in reference to the CAD then I think the's only two places holding these currently
(well Google didn't prove me wrong) in the UK and that's us in the north and the distro
itself (based in a shop) in the south so if you can get to either I'm sure a demo would be
viable. They are nice through with a sweet frequency response curve that strangly
resembles a mic worth 4 or 5 times the asking price, althrough they've never really got a
footing in the UK... in fact the only reason we know about them is down to one of Hughs
old articles:
Re: Choosing the right gear
[Re: SkamUK]
#964929 - 19/01/12 10:13 AM
Edit
Reply
Quote
I use a Focusrite Penta to record vocals and I have been recording mainly Hip-Hop for
about 8 years using it. It is quite adequate and I record without compression; as stated
above several times, you don't need to compress on the way in. I were to be in the market
for a new mic pre I would be considering the Audient Mico.
I use a Joe Meek JM47 as it was cheap and better than the C1000 I was using when I
bought it. I've no idea how it stands up to other mics really, but it does the job and
I've never had any complaints from the people I work with. It is a bit sibilant on some of
my guys, but correct positioning can help combat that.
With regard to bass
traps, I made some recently using RW3 Rockwool and wood frames, using Zukan's tips to help
me
I wouldn't worry about foam for the moment. I
also filled the corners behind my monitors with Studiotips Superchunks style filing, but
bagged up a foot or so of RW3 at a time as I am not in a permanent situation and I wanted
to be able to move them out easily when I finally buy a house.
Re: Choosing the right gear
[Re: Richie Royale]
#964939 - 19/01/12 10:36 AM
Edit
Reply
Quote
Were I to be in your shoes right now, I would get an Allen & Heath GSR24 with Firewire
card and use Reaper (or whatever your poison is!) as DAW. The mic-pres on that GSR24 are
better than on that old SSL desk! That gives you all the possibilities of that 4000G+ you
yearn for, plus very sophisticated DAW control (and reportedly better to come as a free
upgrade) and every tool you will ever need. Add a decent patch-bay and you're in
business!
Re: Choosing the right gear
[Re: The Red Bladder]
#965091 - 19/01/12 11:41 PM
Edit
Reply
Quote
Quote: Were I to be in your
shoes right now, I would get an Allen & Heath GSR24 with Firewire card and use Reaper (or
whatever your poison is!) as DAW. The mic-pres on that GSR24 are better than on that old
SSL desk! That gives you all the possibilities of that 4000G+ you yearn for, plus very
sophisticated DAW control (and reportedly better to come as a free upgrade) and every tool
you will ever need. Add a decent patch-bay and you're in business!
Wow I think you've pointed out a nearly
perfect mixer for me! This thing looks amazing and has every feature that i want and need
(apart from onboard compression but i can live with rigging up a compressor externally if
necessary)!!!
Ur a diamond!
I think the plan now is to get the room sorted and save up for the GSR24, a new mic and
maybe a compressor. I don't think i'll ever replace the desk! Unless music turns into some
form of 25.5 surround 4D magical sound. Its very cheap for what you get, though it is a
lot of money.. I'll be saving up for a long time, but i think it will be worth it. I love
the fact that i can just plug in my firewire and rig up straight to pro tools, nothing in
between, no unnecessary conversions. and full DAW control.
This has answered
all my questions in 3 lines. Cheers mate
Re: Choosing the right gear
[Re: SkamUK]
#965094 - 20/01/12 12:08 AM
Edit
Reply
Quote
Quote: and full DAW control.
Urm, I've just learnt that
the faders are not motorized so it would be completely pointless to have midi control over
pro tools but not get it back in return. I cant see why you would want to mix like this
unless you have total recall on your mixer. Still, would have been better if it had
motorized faders.
Gutted now I thought i found the perfect mixer at a
reasonable price. I suppose you could run all of your outputs from pro tools at zero out
to the mixer and mix like that but still, you cant save you mixer settings and come back
later! FFS!
The perfect mixer seems to be an SSL Matrix. No chance of
affording one though.
I think i'll stick to my original plan and get all of
these features separately.
Re: Choosing the right gear
[Re: Pete Kaine]
#965098 - 20/01/12 12:19 AM
Edit
Reply
Quote
Quote:
Quote: Quote SkamUK:
Thanks I will defo
have a look into these. Reading about the mic now, looks good so far but would like to
test it somewhere.
If that's
in reference to the CAD then I think the's only two places holding these currently (well
Google didn't prove me wrong) in the UK and that's us in the north and the distro itself
(based in a shop) in the south so if you can get to either I'm sure a demo would be
viable.
I've heard the
comparisons between the CAD and the Neumann TLM103 and prefer the TLM. It seems to have a
richer warmer sound and also cleaner, the CAD sounds more suited for an acoustic guitar,
in my ears anyway.
I did think they were a rare mic as I found it hard to track
one down to buy.