Main Forums >> Recording Techniques
        Print Thread

Pages: 1
pano



Joined: 03/12/06
Posts: 10
Demoralising acoustic guitar issues - Please listen! new
      #960776 - 27/12/11 01:15 PM
I'm really trying to sort my acoustic guitar recording, maximising what I have before deciding what to upgrade.

I've recorded some short clips using 2 guitars: a £350-ish Suzuki solid top (rest of body laminate), and a £2500-ish Fylde (lovely luthier guitar). The Fylde is a more recent addition. I thought my previous poor acoustic sound was due to the quality of the Sazuki (although it's an ok sound, neck lovely to play). I was wrong. Both sound horrible when tracked.


I'm using a Tascam USB interface with built in pres, and a cardioid Red5 RV8. I acknowledge this is budget stuff, but I sould still be able to get a nicer sound than this, surely? Both guitars (new strings) recorded with cardioid around 8-10" in front of 12th fret. Recordings are raw with no db cut or hp roll off from the mic. I' playing with some DIY acoustic treatment behind me, slightly bright floor.


Clip 1: The Sazuki (@24bit). I put on new strings, started recording, and noticed I could hear what sounds like warm clipping/distorting. At no point in the recording chain was there any clipping. I do need the pres turned up high to get a decent signal, a common issue with these cheaper interfaces. I've had this set up for a few years and didn't notice this before. I get it when tracking using different PCs, so it's not a USB power issue from the computer end.

Q: is the clipping my imagination? If not, is it the interface or the mic? I'm wondering if the Tascam is just getting old - either the pres or falling power from the USB.

Clips 2 & 3 are the Suzuki and Fylde @ 16bit. Again, raw audio. You can clearly hear the different tone and the better quality of the Fylde, but the recording is still horrible - boomy, and nothing like the guitar actually sounds.

Q: is this really what I can expect in a raw tracked acoustic guitar before hp, eq, compression etc? i.e. Is this really as good as it gets using the equipment I have? If not, either the equipment isn't performing up to par (mic and interace are both around 5-6 years old), or my technique sucks. I've played around a little with different positions, with audible differences, but nothing I'd say that was sonically pleasant.

Would really appreciate help as am now at hair-pulling stage. I'd like to develop skills that maximise what I have, before blindly buying the next bit of kit in the hope it will sort out problems. Clearly, the Fylde hasn't sorted it.

Thanks!

Edited by Martin Walker (28/12/11 03:16 PM)


Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator     Back to top
Mike Stranks
active member


Joined: 03/01/03
Posts: 3609
Loc: Oxford, UK
Re: Demoralising acoustic guitar issues - Please listen! new [Re: pano]
      #960797 - 27/12/11 04:14 PM
Greetings!

Have you looked at this video from SoS?

Recording Acoustic Guitar

I think you need to experiment with mic position to capture the sound you are looking for. Although there are some general rule-of-thumb approaches, with the huge variation in mics, instruments and rooms I have found that sometimes the 'best' sound results from an unconventional approach.

And don't despair. I was expecting something that sounded absolutely appalling, but it's not that bad. I will resist the temptation to give you a quick-fix answer, but do come back if, having experimented as per the video you still can't capture the sound you are looking for.


Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator     Back to top
pano



Joined: 03/12/06
Posts: 10
Re: Demoralising acoustic guitar issues - Please listen! new [Re: pano]
      #960800 - 27/12/11 04:39 PM
Thanks DC. Have read quite a bit about recording acoustic, but not this vid, so will take a look.

I've also experimented a bit, but to be honest assumed I'd get a decent sound from a 'standard' approach - i.e. 12th fret etc - I mean, that's why it's a standard approach right?

So started thinking I should be considering stereo mic'ing with pencil condensers etc., or upgrading interface, but just thought I'd be able to at least get a better result with what I already have - especially with a very decent guitar.

Will give the video a run through and come back.

Cheers


Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator     Back to top
pano



Joined: 03/12/06
Posts: 10
Re: Demoralising acoustic guitar issues - Please listen! new [Re: pano]
      #960818 - 27/12/11 07:10 PM
Enjoyed the SOS video, but a shame the sound quality isn't good to hear differences in detail.

Anyway, it really encouraged me to spend a few hours experimenting with mic positions.

I've now uploaded 15 second clips of the best 7. I've now tired ears so would be very interested to hear other opinions on which works best. All played through the cheaper Suzuki (again with philosophy of getting most out of modest equipment).

Which is best:

A: 14 inches in front of neck-body join (=15th fret)
B: 7 inches in front of neck-body join
C: 14 inches in front of 12th fret
D: 7 inches in front of 12th fret
E: mid-way from floor to hole, mic looking up
F: mid-way from floor to neck join, mic looking up
G: behind and over shoulder

Not sure how I can improve further?

Personally I think I prefer (at the moment anyway)the behind and over shoulder position, but perhaps that's because I'm a guitarist and is I'm used to. I suppose a high pass across all of them may reveal a better one? Of course, they all sound much better when I slap on a stereo-widening VST, but that's not the point of this exercise...

What I have learned is that in efforts to limit room ambiance I've probably had mic too near (7-8 inches). I didn't think proximity effect was noticable at that distance on a guitar? Either way, 12-14 inches delivers a more balanced, less boomy tone.

Thanks for listening!

Edited by pano (27/12/11 07:25 PM)


Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator     Back to top
DAGGILARR



Joined: 22/09/10
Posts: 641
Loc: Exeter, Devon.
Re: Demoralising acoustic guitar issues - Please listen! new [Re: pano]
      #960821 - 27/12/11 07:36 PM
It is a tricky bizniz recording acoustic. It would seem from what I have learnt that mic position is a BIG factor. In order to get this right I would suggest you have a helper and a good set of headphones, you listen and play, while they move the mics around when you get a combo you like make a recording and remember the position (gaffer tape or diagram and notes) also look at the room, is it hard, or is it soft? would a bit of reflection help or is there too much? New strings can add a bit freshness.

I still have not got the sound I am looking for, but will keep trying, just waiting to find a helper. Trying to audition mic position on my own is just not working

--------------------
Strictly an amateur with some nice toys,


Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator     Back to top
pano



Joined: 03/12/06
Posts: 10
Re: Demoralising acoustic guitar issues - Please listen! new [Re: pano]
      #960826 - 27/12/11 08:31 PM
Agreed, it's hard alone. I've someone coming armed with supplementary mics (and guitars) in a few weeks, so that should fill a good afternoon. My monitoring headphones are good (HD600s) but open backed so not quite appropriate!

Forgot to clarify: A-G above relate to the 7 15 second clips I've uploaded. Returning to these after a few hours I still have difficulty choosing the best - they're all different and equally bad as each other.

edit: @ Daggilarr - just listened to your Carlos. Some lovely definition, but tone not quite there. a little too harsh/aggressive (but far better than mine!)

Edited by pano (27/12/11 09:03 PM)


Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator     Back to top
RegressiveRock
Just half a pint of cherryade for me


Joined: 01/09/04
Posts: 5585
Loc: Buntingford, Herts
Re: Demoralising acoustic guitar issues - Please listen! new [Re: pano]
      #960827 - 27/12/11 08:55 PM
Quote pano:

Agreed, it's hard alone. I've someone coming armed with supplementary mics (and guitars) in a few weeks, so that should fill a good afternoon. My monitoring headphones are good (HD600s) but open backed so not quite appropriate!

Forgot to clarify: A-G above relate to the 7 15 second clips I've uploaded. Returning to these after a few hours I still have difficulty choosing the best - they're all different and equally bad as each other.




It's not that hard. The trick is to move the instrumentalist and not the mike when you are on your own. Maintaining objectivity is the tough bit, particularly if you are the instrumentalist. For that a pair of closed cans with good isolation really helps. You really need to hear what the mike is hearing and not get distracted by what is going outside of your cans.

Reg

--------------------
Google less; read more!


Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator     Back to top
shufflebeat



Joined: 09/12/07
Posts: 2961
Loc: Manchester, UK
Re: Demoralising acoustic guitar issues - Please listen! new [Re: pano]
      #960832 - 27/12/11 10:18 PM
I've not got the chance to listen to the clips yet but there are a few things that strike me from what you write.

When I read or hear people discuss recording acoustic I'm always reassured by the extent to which the best of them experiment. What starts off as a standard setup is soon tweaked to capture the best of the instrument. This is missing in your post.

In my experience the most pleasing sounds I've recorded sometimes sound radically different to how I hear the guitar/mandola/bouzouki acoustically. That doesn't bother me, in fact it can encourage me to play with a different approach to make the most of this unfamiliar character.

Forgive me for jumping in uninformed so to speak. I'll have a listen when I can get to WiFi.

--------------------
Anagrams can be fnu.


Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator     Back to top
Jack Ruston



Joined: 21/12/05
Posts: 4426
Re: Demoralising acoustic guitar issues - Please listen! [Re: pano]
      #960837 - 27/12/11 11:40 PM
I'm not at work today, so I can't listen and give any feedback on your recordings directly, but I can tell you that new strings are a disaster for recording guitars. They're way too bright, but in a really nasty, shiny, rattly sort of way. They vibrate oddly against the fret and they clutter the sound with a lot of metallic 'mess'. You need to find the window after they lose all that stuff and before the intonation gets affected by age and corrosion.

The guitars themselves are also a huge factor. In my experience about 7/10 acoustic guitars actively fight against you when trying to record them. In other words they exhibit traits in the sound which you find become undesirably obvious as you go in search of the traits that you do want to hear. The design of the instrument, type of wood and age are all factors. Generally speaking you do not want a resonant, vibrant guitar with lots of projection and extended highs and lows, but rather a dry, middly, tight sound without too much high frequency.

I'll have a listen when I can and see if there's anything to suggest.

J

--------------------
www.jackruston.com


Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator     Back to top
Guy Johnson



Joined: 02/05/03
Posts: 4283
Loc: North Pembrokeshire
Re: Demoralising acoustic guitar issues - Please listen! new [Re: pano]
      #960839 - 28/12/11 12:08 AM
well, of course it depends on the context .. but I like the over the shoulder one the best.

Try sitting on a high stool or stand up; make sure you are away from any walls: I'm guessing you are getting some reflections from adjacent surfaces.

--------------------
Facebok Page for acoustic music PA-ing in smaller venues


Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator     Back to top
pano



Joined: 03/12/06
Posts: 10
Re: Demoralising acoustic guitar issues - Please listen! new [Re: shufflebeat]
      #960844 - 28/12/11 01:21 AM
Thanks for feedback - appreciated.

Quote shufflebeat:


When I read or hear people discuss recording acoustic I'm always reassured by the extent to which the best of them experiment. What starts off as a standard setup is soon tweaked to capture the best of the instrument. This is missing in your post.




Point well taken. I've experimented over the years a bit, but not substantially because (i) I never had the opportunity to record with a fantastic guitar (until now) and (ii) when I did move the mic around, while the tonal quality certainly changed, it was a hard call to say whether it was for better or worse. so - I spent energy trying to fix in the mix and apply various work-around strategies to hide what i considered to be poor recording (double tracking etc). Now I want to come clean and get a simple, good signal.

Quote Jack Ruston:

I can tell you that new strings are a disaster for recording guitars. They're way too bright, but in a really nasty, shiny, rattly sort of way.

The design of the instrument, type of wood and age are all factors. Generally speaking you do not want a resonant, vibrant guitar with lots of projection and extended highs and lows, but rather a dry, middly, tight sound without too much high frequency.




Excellent advice - thanks. I assumed that bright strings would add some zing to what I considered to be muddy, dull recordings. The Fylde, with toned down strings might be just the ticket - it's smaller, projects less, but much tighter.


Quote Guy Johnson:

well, of course it depends on the context .. but I like the over the shoulder one the best.

Try sitting on a high stool or stand up; make sure you are away from any walls: I'm guessing you are getting some reflections from adjacent surfaces.




Was mine too, but once you run them through an hp, there's not a huge difference tbh. It seems to me that different positions change the tonal balance, but not so much the quality of the recording - that's a combination of room, guitar and signal chain?

FYI I'm sitting in a corner facing into room, with a corner-shaped 7ft screen covered with 2 duvets behind me. It's a wooden floor so getting some bright reflections there - especially from the shoulder position (this also gives more reflections from other sources given it's facing more into the room).


Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator     Back to top
DAGGILARR



Joined: 22/09/10
Posts: 641
Loc: Exeter, Devon.
Re: Demoralising acoustic guitar issues - Please listen! new [Re: Jack Ruston]
      #960854 - 28/12/11 08:34 AM
Quote Jack Ruston:

I can tell you that new strings are a disaster for recording guitars. They're way too bright, but in a really nasty, shiny, rattly sort of way. They vibrate oddly against the fret and they clutter the sound with a lot of metallic 'mess'. You need to find the window after they lose all that stuff and before the intonation gets affected by age and corrosion.
J




@ Jack. Well I advised differently, but bow to far greater experience.

(especially in the light of the fact I still have not achieved a decent sound myself)

In my researches on this there is some mention of some strings are better than others. I changed strings for this reason and found new D'ads to be an improvement over older Newtones. I will resist the temptation to put a new set on before having another go at recording acoustic

--------------------
Strictly an amateur with some nice toys,


Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator     Back to top
Pages: 1

Rate this thread

Jump to

Extra Information
1 registered and 24 anonymous users are browsing this forum.

Moderator:  David Etheridge, James Perrett, zenguitar, Martin Walker, Forum Admin, Hugh Robjohns, Zukan, Frank Eleveld, Will Betts,  
Forum Permissions
      You cannot start new topics
      You cannot reply to topics
      HTML is disabled
      UBBCode is enabled
Rating:
Thread views: 3276

May 2014
On sale now at main newsagents and bookstores (or buy direct from the
SOS Web Shop)
SOS current Print Magazine: click here for FULL Contents list
Click image for May 2014
DAW Tips from SOS

 

Home | Search | News | Current Issue | Tablet Mag | Articles | Forum | Subscribe | Shop | Readers Ads

Advertise | Information | Digital Editions | Privacy Policy | Support | Login Help

 

Email: Contact SOS

Telephone: +44 (0)1954 789888

Fax: +44 (0)1954 789895

Registered Office: Media House, Trafalgar Way, Bar Hill, Cambridge, CB23 8SQ, United Kingdom.

Sound On Sound Ltd is registered in England and Wales.

Company number: 3015516 VAT number: GB 638 5307 26

         

All contents copyright © SOS Publications Group and/or its licensors, 1985-2014. All rights reserved.
The contents of this article are subject to worldwide copyright protection and reproduction in whole or part, whether mechanical or electronic, is expressly forbidden without the prior written consent of the Publishers. Great care has been taken to ensure accuracy in the preparation of this article but neither Sound On Sound Limited nor the publishers can be held responsible for its contents. The views expressed are those of the contributors and not necessarily those of the publishers.

Web site designed & maintained by PB Associates | SOS | Relative Media