Unlock the potential of overlooked but useful Live effects devices.
If you held a competition to find Live's most exciting audio effect, Utility would undoubtedly come in last, and Auto Pan would not be far ahead. However, these devices offer easy solutions to a lot of common problems relating to level, stereo image and panning, and they have surprisingly creative applications as well. In this month's column, we're going to look at several ways to get the most out of them.
For the best results when reproducing the following examples, start with a simple audio loop with three mono parts: keys or guitar panned hard left, bass panned centre, and drums panned hard right. Screen 1 shows how to derive this from separate MIDI instrument or audio tracks with the help of Utility. The examples will also be clearer if monitored via headphones, to avoid the vagaries of speaker placement and room reflections.
Once you've created the resampled file, pan its track hard right and then hard left, and notice that the left channel contains only piano and bass whereas the right channel contains only drums and bass. In a stereo signal, the 'phantom' centre comprises everything common to both the right and left channels, in this case the bass. Now insert an instance of Utility on the resampled track and set Width to 0.0 percent. The image will become mono, and you can pan it from side to side. Next set Width to 200 percent and notice that the bass disappears and the piano and drums have an odd presence, sometimes called the 'out of speakers' effect. This is because the channels are phase-inverted copies of each other. Click the Phz-R button at the bottom right of the Utility panel and that effect goes away. You can use similar Utility settings for Mid/Side conversion — see the 'What Side Are You On?' box.
Here are five common problems you can solve with a single Utility device.
- Stereo width and enhanced panning: In Live, and many other DAWs, stereo panning just rebalances the left and right channels, and for widely panned material, that does not move the image much. Piano and drum parts often fall into this category when recorded to emulate the player's perspective. To create a more pannable image, insert a Utility device and try Width settings of between 25 and 50 percent.
- Post-automation control of level: Once you've automated track volume, you can regain the ability to change the overall level using a Utility's Gain control. I prefer to reserve the track volume sliders for final mixing and apply the automation to Utility's Gain control.
- Post-fader control of pre-fader sends: You can use Utility's Gain control to get the best of both worlds from pre‑fader send effects. When inserted on the source track, Gain affects both the track and send levels, just as the track fader does for post-fader sends. Bear in mind that the tails of effects inserted in the track after the Utility device continue to feed the send effect. This can be quite useful with high-feedback delays and long-tail reverbs.
- Simulating a pre-fader send: When a pre-fader send is not available (for example, in a Drum Rack), you can use Utility to cancel the source signal and simulate a pre-fader send. To do this, set up Utility as an additional send effect and turn on both phase-inversion buttons (Phz-L and Phz-R) at the bottom. Increasing the send level to the Utility cancels progressively more of the source. This is also a quick way to simulate an overall dry/wet control for complex effects chains.
- Mono compatibility check: You can use Utility to check for mono compatibility on individual tracks, track groups or the Master track. Simply set Width to 0 percent to convert the output to mono and listen for what drops down or out of the mix. For example, if you start with a Utility set to 200 percent Width, which puts phase-inverted copies of the same signal in the left and right channels, and follow that with a Utility set to 0 percent Width, everything drops out.
Let's turn our attention to Auto Pan, which you can think of as a two-channel gain LFO. Insert the device on a track with the trio test clip described in screenshot 1 and change the Amount setting from the default 0 percent to 100 percent. You'll hear the keys and drums alternately fade in and out while the bass pans back and forth. If you use a Utility before Auto Pan to narrow the width, you'll hear the whole image panning. If you change Auto Pan's Phase setting from 180 degrees to 0 degrees, you'll get a mono tremolo effect.
Auto Pan's LFO speed can be free‑running (set in Hz) or tempo-sync'ed (set in note divisions). In Notes mode, you get an Offset knob below the Phase knob that shifts the start of both LFO patterns relative to the selected note division. In Hz mode, you get buttons below the Phase knob to change it to a Spin knob. In Spin mode, the knob increases the rate of the right-channel (green) LFO by as much as 50 percent. You can simulate Spin in Notes mode by using two Auto Pan devices in parallel (one for each channel) and adjusting the rate of one relative to that of the other.
The LFOs offer four waveforms (bottom right buttons), but with the help of the Normal/Invert button (bottom left) and the Shape knob you can achieve virtually any shape you need for gating, panning, chopping and simulated delay effects (see screenshot 2). When using Auto Pan to create rhythmic patterns, try applying automation or mod wheel modulation to the Amount knob, to contour the effect to your music.
The processes explained here are only the beginning. You can use Utility devices in an Audio Effect Rack along with Auto Pan and other effects to produce highly complex multi-effects, such as the one shown in screenshot 3.
Utility makes short work of Mid/Side conversion, which you can use for mundane as well as highly creative effects processing. The Mid signal in Mid/Side conversion is the mono sum of the left and right channels, which is then panned hard left. The Side signal is the mono sum of the left channel and the phase-inverted right channel, which is then panned hard right. Live compensates for channel summing by subtracting 6dB and employs a -3dB pan law, adding 3dB when panning hard left or right. So as long as both incoming channels peak below -3dB, you can use the same Utility settings to convert Mid/Side signals back to stereo (see screenshot 4). You can use separate tracks and track groups for the conversions and effects, or you can set the whole thing up in an Audio Effect Rack, placing any effects between the two conversions.
You don't need this setup for two of the most common Mid/Side processes: controlling stereo width and separate EQ of the Mid and Side signals. The Utility's Width control accomplishes the former and Live's EQ Eight in M/S mode accomplishes the latter. You do need this setup for separate compression of the Mid or Side signals, which is another common process. Many Live and third-party plug-ins provide interesting and useful results when used independently on the Mid and Side signals. Good examples include delay, reverb, pan modulation and moving-filter effects.