You are here

Home Studio vs Professional Studio

Page 3 of 7

Re: Home Studio vs Professional Studio

PostPosted: Fri Dec 06, 2019 7:28 pm
by MOF
I know we're all different, but for me, there is no difference at all, between studio or live performances, I'm still giving a performance, the audience is just different, or just me!

A mate of mine, who enjoys going to gigs, says that later live performances are often better than the original record because the band have improved on it over time.
Now that could just be the live atmosphere that’s psychologically affecting his judgement or there might be something in it.
It might be worth delaying going into a studio with new tracks so that it’s second nature to play them and hone them first.

Re: Home Studio vs Professional Studio

PostPosted: Fri Dec 06, 2019 8:40 pm
by CS70
MOF wrote:
I know we're all different, but for me, there is no difference at all, between studio or live performances, I'm still giving a performance, the audience is just different, or just me!

A mate of mine, who enjoys going to gigs, says that later live performances are often better than the original record because the band have improved on it over time.
Now that could just be the live atmosphere that’s psychologically affecting his judgement or there might be something in it.
It might be worth delaying going into a studio with new tracks so that it’s second nature to play them and hone them first.

You hit a quite complex point. Most of my band's song change very much when played live - some because the original recordings have no drums or bass, others because I've had different melodic guitar parts on the way me and the backing sing it has changed over time, or we have added different harmonies and melodies. So in a way it's a good idea to wait.

In another way, however, it's hard to keep the raw excitement and novelty of the first few times you play a song after making it. With a band, there's that magic moment when, after messing about a fair amount of time, finally everyone "gets" their role and finally the song clicks.. that is imho the absolutely ideal moment to record it, even if if it's not perfect and certainly a performance is more polished after the 100th time you play it.

Re: Home Studio vs Professional Studio

PostPosted: Sat Dec 07, 2019 9:03 am
by Guest
On a slightly unrelated yet related note, I beleve Angel studios is closing soon which is a real shame. Maybe a tribute piece is an idea for an SOS article? It has been a great studio.

Re: Home Studio vs Professional Studio

PostPosted: Sun Dec 08, 2019 4:48 pm
by John Willett
MOF wrote:A mate of mine, who enjoys going to gigs, says that later live performances are often better than the original record because the band have improved on it over time.
Now that could just be the live atmosphere that’s psychologically affecting his judgement or there might be something in it.
It might be worth delaying going into a studio with new tracks so that it’s second nature to play them and hone them first.

More likely because the band did not give a "performance" in the recording - spending the time on getting it to sound "right" that they missed the most important bit - the performance.

A musician will put his/her heart and soul into performing on stage - they need to do the same in the studio to get a really great recording that the listener will want to hear again and again. :thumbup:

Re: Home Studio vs Professional Studio

PostPosted: Mon Dec 09, 2019 10:44 am
by Arpangel
John Willett wrote:
MOF wrote:A mate of mine, who enjoys going to gigs, says that later live performances are often better than the original record because the band have improved on it over time.
Now that could just be the live atmosphere that’s psychologically affecting his judgement or there might be something in it.
It might be worth delaying going into a studio with new tracks so that it’s second nature to play them and hone them first.

More likely because the band did not give a "performance" in the recording - spending the time on getting it to sound "right" that they missed the most important bit - the performance.

A musician will put his/her heart and soul into performing on stage - they need to do the same in the studio to get a really great recording that the listener will want to hear again and again. :thumbup:

That's interesting, when I'm playing at a gig I'm not really there in my head, I'm sort of going through the motions.
But when I'm in "a studio" or recording at home, I'm right there, emotionally 150%
I think some people have different priorities, recordings, or performance.

Re: Home Studio vs Professional Studio

PostPosted: Mon Dec 09, 2019 11:14 am
by CS70
Arpangel wrote:That's interesting, when I'm playing at a gig I'm not really there in my head, I'm sort of going through the motions.
But when I'm in "a studio" or recording at home, I'm right there, emotionally 150%
I think some people have different priorities, recordings, or performance.

Yeah in a way, I like the studio better as well. Live it's always a bit of a compromise, you cannot bring half a dozen guitars and four or five amps to get each song just right (not to mention a truckload of instrumentalists that have collaborated on one song), so you make do with what is sensible or are forced to cut some pieces altogether. There's always that nagging feeling that things are not just entirely right. In a way the most satisfactory songs to play live are the more straightforward ones.

On the other side, it's awesome to play to a crowd who's responding to what you do..

Re: Home Studio vs Professional Studio

PostPosted: Mon Dec 09, 2019 11:33 am
by Sam Spoons
I find it much harder to give a full on performance in studio or rehearsal room. Live a good audience give you a huge boost.

Re: Home Studio vs Professional Studio

PostPosted: Mon Dec 09, 2019 11:44 am
by CS70
Sam Spoons wrote:I find it much harder to give a full on performance in studio or rehearsal room. Live a good audience give you a huge boost.

Yeah I guess most do.

When I'm recording client singers, the thing I have to work the most on is to get them to let go and sing loud and freely without feeling awkward or self conscious.
Singing loud and to your heart's content to a more or less empty room isn't something that comes natural to most of us - I definitely had to learn it.

Re: Home Studio vs Professional Studio

PostPosted: Mon Dec 09, 2019 11:58 am
by Sam Spoons
Yup, bang on the money CS

Re: Home Studio vs Professional Studio

PostPosted: Mon Dec 09, 2019 12:29 pm
by blinddrew
Yep, it's one of the things i'm looking forward to being able to do once my shed is finished. :)

Re: Home Studio vs Professional Studio

PostPosted: Tue Dec 10, 2019 10:19 am
by Arpangel
CS70 wrote:Singing loud and to your heart's content to a more or less empty room isn't something that comes natural to most of us - I definitely had to learn it.

I'm an expert at it, as most of my gigs are done in more or less empty rooms....

:D

Re: Home Studio vs Professional Studio

PostPosted: Tue Dec 10, 2019 12:01 pm
by John Willett
Arpangel wrote:
CS70 wrote:Singing loud and to your heart's content to a more or less empty room isn't something that comes natural to most of us - I definitely had to learn it.

I'm an expert at it, as most of my gigs are done in more or less empty rooms....

:D

:bouncy: :bouncy: :bouncy:

Re: Home Studio vs Professional Studio

PostPosted: Tue Dec 10, 2019 2:20 pm
by Martin Walker
Arpangel wrote:
CS70 wrote:Singing loud and to your heart's content to a more or less empty room isn't something that comes natural to most of us - I definitely had to learn it.

I'm an expert at it, as most of my gigs are done in more or less empty rooms....

Are you sure you're playing in an audi-torium and not a sani-torium Tony? :shock: :crazy: :o


Martin

Re: Home Studio vs Professional Studio

PostPosted: Tue Dec 10, 2019 3:09 pm
by John Willett
Martin Walker wrote:
Arpangel wrote:
CS70 wrote:Singing loud and to your heart's content to a more or less empty room isn't something that comes natural to most of us - I definitely had to learn it.

I'm an expert at it, as most of my gigs are done in more or less empty rooms....

Are you sure you're playing in an audi-torium and not a sani-torium Tony? :shock: :crazy: :o


Martin

:bouncy:

Re: Home Studio vs Professional Studio

PostPosted: Wed Dec 11, 2019 6:04 am
by Ma-Music
Professional studio's are great, but I agree that it is easy to get intimated and not use them to the full potential. A lot of that has to do with you may be using gear that you are not familiar with.

It's tough to match the sound quality that many studio's provide (i.e.: sound proof rooms and rooms made specifically for audio recording). But if you can, I think it's best to have a home studio that you can be yourself in, and master your equipment!