You are here

Distribution Service?

Page 1 of 2

Distribution Service?

PostPosted: Sun Jan 26, 2020 8:12 am
by awjoe
I've finished another album, and I'd like to distribute it via a distribution service. For the last two albums I've used Distrokid, and made about a dollar overall. (Cue applause...) So it's obvious I do it for the fun rather than for the money. I'm curious about your experience and opinions about online distribution services in general and Distrokid in particular.

Re: Distribution Service?

PostPosted: Sun Jan 26, 2020 11:24 am
by blinddrew
Are you talking hard-copy or download only?

I'm currently using CD baby for our last band EP but their pricing model works better for albums. Worth a look for sure.
I note that SoundCloud have a comment about distribution to streaming services on their pro unlimited plan now. I've not checked it out yet but am intending to as my solo stuff doesn't tend to fit the album format so much.

Re: Distribution Service?

PostPosted: Sun Jan 26, 2020 1:30 pm
by BigRedX
I use CD Baby and Catapult for two different projects.

Neither has made a profit when you take the upload fee into consideration, despite having had music up there for almost 10 years now.

As part of the overall distribution strategy they are worthwhile especially since neither band is currently playing live, and now we get a small but steady income from Spotify and Apple Music streaming, but while we were gigging, the revenue generated was less than 5% of all sales.

Re: Distribution Service?

PostPosted: Sun Jan 26, 2020 4:51 pm
by awjoe
Well yeah, if it's money you want, then gigging's way way better than the online floggeroo. On Friday night I watched a three-man British band called The Trials of Cato playing in a kind of club way out here on the left coast of Canada. (They described themselves as 'folk' and they are, but intelligently and inventively so. Relatively unknown on this side of the planet, but an awesome talent that I heartily recommend.) They managed to fill a 250-seat venue and got a take of the gate, but they really worked the signed CD sales during the intermission and at the end. *That* is how to make money. And interestingly, they don't even sell CDs online, only mp3s.

In the meantime, I just want to get my stuff out there online, as sensibly as possible. I've checked reviews of Distrokid and some people really pan them along the lines of 'They were good when they started but they've gone to the devil recently - don't trust them' sort of thing. Of course, I know better than to believe anonymous reviews online, so I thought I'd ask here. ... oh hang on... you're online and relatively anonymous too... Never mind. It's all about *degrees* of trust, right? :headbang:

Re: Distribution Service?

PostPosted: Wed Apr 01, 2020 8:16 pm
by connorhawke
I've mainly used CDBaby. They're quick to get music to stores (usually a few days from submission) but somewhat more costly than competitors - e.g. $20 just for an album barcode whereas many other distributors provide this for free.

I tried Distrokid once, which seems more cost-effective if you want to distribute music constantly although there is a fee that pushes it above CDBaby's cost if you want to keep the music on stores after your subscription ends.

amuse is free but very slow - several weeks to get submission to stores, and long wait times for customer service. I'm trying their Pro service which should be slightly faster and I'll see how it fares.

ONErpm and RouteNote are other free options I've tried for my collab tracks as they offer automated split earnings.

Each service has their own drawbacks which may or may not affect you / your group so it's worth doing some individualized research and perhaps test-trialing to see what works best for what type of work. There's also a great summary article which covers a lot of the pros and cons of common distributors: https://aristake.com/post/cd-baby-tunec ... imbalam-or

Hope this helps.

Re: Distribution Service?

PostPosted: Wed Apr 01, 2020 9:35 pm
by CS70
So far I’ve seen only a parameter which means something: you either you pay the one-off processing fee but give them a cut for every sale, or pay every year a publishing fee but they take no cut. If you estimate lots of sales, the latter is best, if not the former is.

I have good experience with cd baby service and interface but I’m pretty sure it can be said for others.

The one above is imho the most meaningful difference between all these services.

Re: Distribution Service?

PostPosted: Wed Apr 01, 2020 10:25 pm
by blinddrew
I did look at SoundCloud Pro as it was on offer recently but you need to be hitting a certain level of plays to get on their Premiere service - and I was nowhere close!

Re: Distribution Service?

PostPosted: Wed Apr 01, 2020 11:33 pm
by MOF
You might consider your own YouTube channel for monetising and cross promotion. Also some promotion through Facebook and Instagram on a regular basis.

Re: Distribution Service?

PostPosted: Thu May 21, 2020 12:57 pm
by timoc
This guy made a neat, massive comparison chart. It might be a year old or so:

https://aristake.com/posts/images/distro-chart-6-19.jpg

Re: Distribution Service?

PostPosted: Sun Jul 05, 2020 3:12 pm
by Stickman0_3
I use Ditto for distribution, I do everything myself and then upload MP3's and artwork to Ditto, then they distribute it to a number different sites.

Re: Distribution Service?

PostPosted: Sun Jul 05, 2020 7:04 pm
by CS70
awjoe wrote:I've finished another album, and I'd like to distribute it via a distribution service. For the last two albums I've used Distrokid, and made about a dollar overall. (Cue applause...) So it's obvious I do it for the fun rather than for the money. I'm curious about your experience and opinions about online distribution services in general and Distrokid in particular.

You made a dollar, and you're actually better off than a lot of signed artists! :D

Re: Distribution Service?

PostPosted: Mon Jul 06, 2020 8:00 pm
by awjoe
I'm up to $6 now, mostly through Amazon. I'm almost impressed. I'd like to know how many (units?) have to be sold to generate six bucks for the artist. When I reach the price of a bottle of wine, there WILL be a party.

Re: Distribution Service?

PostPosted: Mon Jul 06, 2020 9:02 pm
by Stickman0_3
lots of streaming!

Re: Distribution Service?

PostPosted: Mon Jul 06, 2020 9:48 pm
by CS70
awjoe wrote:I'm up to $6 now, mostly through Amazon. I'm almost impressed. I'd like to know how many (units?) have to be sold to generate six bucks for the artist. When I reach the price of a bottle of wine, there WILL be a party.

Much less than it would take were you associated with a label :-D

Re: Distribution Service?

PostPosted: Thu Sep 10, 2020 11:25 am
by hasser964
I've used Distrokid, Ditto, Landr & Soundcloud repost network.

For the money I think I'd say that Ditto is my favourite in terms of ease of use, how fast they were & the analytics they provide. Also they have a team that collects your other royalties that aren't from streaming (radio, shop etc).

Repost network is also pretty good, but they take 15% cut of your streaming royalties. They also offer some cool asf artwork options when you upload to Soundcloud.

Distrokid was expensive when releasing with multiple accounts & they charge extra for stuff like shazam which i personally think should be included in the price. The customer service was great and I never had an issue with them though.

Landr was free and is a great service for distribution. The mastering was also pretty interesting tbh, but it isn't as good as a proper mastering engineer.

You're gonna get most of the same with music distribution companies, I guess it's what works best for you. Personally I use Ditto & love it, but have heard other people not have a good time, same with Distrokid.

Whichever you choose, they're gonna be wildly similar in what they can offer.

There's a list here that goes through the pros & cons of each in a nice table format if you needed more info:

https://www.whippedcreamsounds.com/best ... tion-2020/

Hope this helps!