The Strokes' comeback single was the product of three years of songwriting, 18 months of recording — and 30 minutes of mixing!
The Strokes burst upon the international music scene 10 years ago with their debut album Is This It. The band's 21st‑century reinvention of guitar rock proved immensely popular with critics and punters alike. As was documented in SOS April 2002 (/sos/apr02/articles/gordonraphael.asp), the album went through a lengthy gestation process that involved aborted sessions with big‑name producer Gil Norton, who was replaced with the then relatively unknown Gordon Raphael, and endless discussions about their sound, which was supposed to be that of "a band from the past that took a time trip into the future to make a record”, according to singer Julian Casablancas. One aspect of this involved him tracking his vocals through a small Peavey practice amp.
Is This It laid the blueprint for the Strokes' approach to recording in many different ways. For example, the band's "get a big name producer and then replace him” approach was repeated on all subsequent albums. In the case of 2003's Room On Fire, Nigel Godrich (Radiohead, Paul McCartney) was replaced by Gordon Raphael, again. On First Impressions Of Earth (2006), Raphael — by now a known producer — was replaced by David Kahne (Linkin Park, Paul McCartney); while on the latest album, Angles, Joe Chiccarelli (White Stripes, Counting Crows) was replaced by Gus Oberg. And while First Impressions Of Earth took 10 months to record, for Angles the band spent more than a year in the studio, dogged by rumours of tension in the ranks. Whether by design or not, the result is that Angles has been one of the main music stories of the Spring, reaching the top five in the UK and the US.
Whatever the travails of its making, Angles is one of the best‑sounding rock albums to have been released in recent years, having avoided the 'death by limiting' suffered by so many CDs these days. The person best placed to shine more light on the recording goings‑on is Gus Oberg, who engineered most of the material on the album, and co‑produced all but one of the album's songs. He also mixed the single, 'Under Cover Of Darkness', as well as the song 'Gratification'. Although Oberg won a Grammy for Best Contemporary World Music Album in 2006 for his work on the the Klezmatics' Wonder Wheel, he isn't as well‑known as many of the mix engineers featured in this series.
Gus Oberg was born in Sweden, but his desire to pursue an engineering career led him across the Atlantic. "When I was 12 and 13 I was already always busy with recording gear, using a Fostex four‑track and so on. I moved to New York in 1997, I guess to learn more about engineering, and I did a course at the School of Audio Engineering in New York. After that, I started work at Loho Studios, where I eventually became chief engineer and studio manager. I ended up being there 24/7! One of the most well‑known projects I recorded there was Willie Nelson's Songbird album. In 2005, Albert [Hammond Jr., Strokes guitarist] booked time at the studio, and after working together for five days we clicked so well that we never really stopped working together. I engineered, mixed and co‑produced Albert's two solo albums. Three years ago, Loho was sold, and Albert and I needed a place to work, so we started to build what's now his One Way Studios, which is located one and a half hours' drive from Manhattan, in the Catskill Mountains. Albert and I designed the studio together. We had a building constructed from scratch that has the shape of a barn, with very high ceilings. There's a large live room that's perhaps 1500 square feet, and we built the studio around a 32‑channel analogue Wunderbar desk, that's based on the Neve 1073 modules of a now legendary desk made for John Paul Jones in the '70s.”
Sessions for what would become Angles apparently began early 2009. Oberg: "I'd say that the band had been writing songs during 2006‑9 — they always write songs — and they rehearsed them in early 2009. I recorded demos in April, just using four microphones, with the band playing live together in their rehearsal studio. I had a Neumann TLM103 on each of the two guitar cabinets and an Audix i5 on the bass cab. I like omni microphones on the drums, and I used an Electrovoice RE50, or something. I didn't use the Audix and EV mics for any other reason than that I found them there. All four mics went through my little Trident B‑range desk, which acted like mic pres, and then via the [Avid] Mbox Pro 2 into Pro Tools. Julian was recorded later, using a Shure SM58 and also an Audix i5, and I ran the latter through the PA, which I recorded with the TLM103s. I blended the 103s and the 58 together for the vocal sound of the demos. He's been singing with a PA all his life, so why not mic it up! The PA sound added some ambience and some nastiness.”
Angles was the first album on which all members of the Strokes participated in the writing of the songs — on the previous three albums, songs were mostly written by Casablancas, with only occasional input from the band. Much has been made of this aspect of Angles being a cause of friction in the band and also leading to prolonging the recording sessions, but Oberg insists that all songs were already written and demoed before the actual recording sessions began. The next step in the making of Angles was the by now customary search for the big‑name producer to help them take these demos to the finished stage (one must assume the band didn't go in with the intention of ditching him). Joe Chiccarelli, with his background in working with the White Stripes, Frank Zappa and Counting Crows, was an obvious candidate; the Strokes particularly liked his production of My Morning Jacket's 2008 album Evil Urges. And so sessions began at Avatar Studio B in New York in January 2009, with Chiccarelli producing and engineering, Oberg co‑engineering, and Justin Gerrish assisting. Gerrish also mixed Vampire Weekend's most recent album, as featured in SOS May 2010 (/sos/may10/articles/it_0510.htm), while Joe Chiccarelli's work with the White Stripes was featured in the October 2007 issue: /sos/oct07/articles/insidetrack_1007.htm.
"We were there for 10 weeks, seven days a week,” recalls Oberg, "which is a long time, given that it was obvious after four or five days that Joe and the band wanted to go in different directions. The band knew what they wanted, but they also wanted to try out everything, which is why they had approached Joe. Mainly they wanted to experiment with different textures and sounds, because the arrangements and lyrics that they had already recorded on the demos stayed more or less the same. They disagreed with the direction in which Joe took the sounds — basically he wanted to go big with everything, and they wanted to do different things in each song. Joe was very hands‑on with the recordings, he knew what he wanted, and the band played together for most of the time. About 18 songs were recorded during these sessions. After the Avatar sessions I went to Electric Lady, where I recorded Julian's vocals. Joe did come by at one stage, but by then it had become obvious that he and the band were not going to carry on working together.
"After the Electric Lady vocal sessions we went to One Way. Julian was happy with half the album, but the band then agreed that we had to rework almost everything, apart from the song 'Life Is Simple In The Moonlight', which is one great result we got from the sessions with Joe, and we're very happy with it. When working in One Way, we kept the guitars from the Avatar sessions for most songs, but re‑recorded almost everything else. The guitars were the only bits that the band was happy with in terms of the sound. We recorded at One Way for a few weeks, and then people went home, and then they came back. I guess we worked for about two weeks at a time, with me engineering by myself. In between this, I would record Julian's vocals again at Electric Lady. This rhythm kept going until the end of November, when we went into mixing, and after that there was three months of mastering.”
Three months of mastering? We'll come to the ins and outs of that below, but somehow this little bit of info puts the whole hyper‑intense gestation process of Angles into focus. When Oberg says that the band wanted to try "everything”, he's not kidding: every song was tracked several times, and different overdubs were tried, and with the whole project being recorded to Pro Tools at 24/96, he ended up with "thousands and thousands” of Gigabytes of data. Throughout, Oberg was the only one who had an overview of everything that had gone down, and he was expected to be able to give an instant answer to questions such as "that guitar line that I played half a year ago, can you put that on?” In addition, Oberg was by now also promoted to co‑producer alongside the band, making him not only responsible for engineering but also for organising sessions, judging performances, and coming up with sonic ideas; since then he has also become the band's live sound engineer.
According to Oberg, the band enthusiastically participated in the production side of things, and the sessions became very much a collective enterprise. With no‑one else in One Way to assist him on the engineering side of things, Oberg had to be "very organised with my files. But yes, the project became absolutely massive. It's important for me to work in the 24/96 resolution, though. I use a lot of room mics, and rarely use effects, and for that it makes a difference.
"What we had done at Avatar was very straightforward, and the band wanted things more crazy. They wanted to take the sounds somewhere else. They did not want to make a standard rock album. They particularly had a problem with the drums from the Avatar sessions, feeling they were too busy, so they were re‑tracked with hi‑hat taken out, or a tom, or perhaps adding a kick, things like that. As I said, the arrangement stayed pretty much the same, but they did add overdubs and made things a bit more complicated than what we had before. While they had played with the four of them together at Avatar, at One Way it was mostly a process of me recording them one at a time, even though a few songs were played together, like with 'Gratisfaction' and 'Games' I had two or three of them at the same time. For 'Gratisfaction' we started a whole new session from scratch and flew some stuff in from the Avatar sessions. With all the other songs we began with the Avatar session and then overdubbed and replaced things.
"When recording in Avatar, the guitars were always split to two amplifiers for each guitarist, using the Radial Tonebone JX2 Switchbone pedal. A lot of the time, Nick [Valensi] used the Fender Supersonic and different Orange cabs, and a Fender Deluxe. Albert switched a lot, between Hiwatt and usually a Marshall or Fender‑type amp. The cabs for each guitarist were recorded with an SM57 on one and a Royer R121 on the other, and then going into the Neve 8088 board for the mic pres, and then put through an 1176 and an API 550 three‑band EQ. The first batches of vocal recordings were done at Electric Lady Studio B, and 'Under Cover' was the second song we did. I used a Neumann U47 and a Sennheiser MD421. The signal chain was the 47 going into a Neve 1081 mic pre, then an [Universal Audio] 1176 and [Teletronix] LA2A, a Pultec EQ, and then into Pro Tools. The 421 was for a more dirty sound, and went into the 1081 with the gain set very very high, to drive it, and then to the SSL 9000J so I could have a fader on it, as it was too hot to print. From the board I went back to a Dbx 160 for a lot of compression and then another Pultec EQ and finally to Pro Tools. Julian sang through headphones in the live room, but he likes to sing next to me, so later we moved to an editing room at Electric Lady where we could both be in the same space, and he sang with the headphone sometimes over just one ear, sometimes we monitored via the speakers. Yes, I did mind the spill, but he needed to be comfortable while singing, and I'd do whatever is needed to get him to sing well.”
When the sessions moved to One Way, Oberg installed himself under a skylight at the Wunderbar board, and guided the band through a long Spring, Summer and Autumn of overdubbing. Looking at the Edit window screenshot for the modestly sized Pro Tools Session of 'Under Cover', he elaborates on the signal chains for each of the tracks, beginning at the top with the drums. "I like the Chandler TG2 mic pre/EQ a lot. It's made by a guy who remakes all the Beatles EMI stuff. I just fell in love with it a few years ago, and I use it a lot on drums. The kick was recorded inside with an AKG D12 and outside with the Yamaha Subkick, the big guy, and each went through a Chandler, with Dbx 160 compression on the inside mic and LA2A on the outside mic. The snare was recorded with a Telefunken M80 at the top and an MD421 on the bottom, and both mics went through the Telefunken V72 [preamp], [Empirical Labs] Distressors and Neumann BFE EQs, which are great. They are very heavy in weight, which is usually a good sign.
"I used SM57s for the toms and AKG 451s on the hi‑hats. The toms went through the Wunderbar — I think we have PEQ2s in that board — and the hats went through the API 512 mic pre. The kit mic was the new Telefunken ELAM 260. You can switch the capsules on them and I used the omni one. I put the 260 on the beater side of the rim of the kick drum, it's like two inches from the top of the kick drum and two inches from the side of the snare. It was also going through the Chandler and then a Distressor. The room mic was a U87 going through an Avalon 737 compresor/EQ. The overheads were Royer 121 to capture some of the room, going through Trident Bs and compressed with an Alan Smart compressor. That was it for drums. There are some other tracks, but those are simply brief overdubs. The bass was played through a SVT cab on which I put a [AKG] D112 close, a [Neumann] FET47 about six or seven feet away from the amp, and I DI'ed it with a Radial J48. All three signals were going through the Wunderbar. The DI and the D112 were compressed with a 1176, but the FET was not compressed.
"Underneath is the fast little boogie‑woogie line that was overdubbed by guitar and a bass. I put them on separate tracks because they needed different settings on the compressor. There's a shaker and a new guitar solo by Nick, done at One Way, using a Fender Supersonic 4x12, on which I put a Beyer M88 mic close and also a Royer 121. I bussed these two together, going through a Distressor or an 1176 and finally an API EQ. There was also a room microphone on the guitar solo, which was a Blue Dragonfly going through the Avalon 737. At the bottom of the session, you can see the vocal tracks: 'LV‑Jules Blend' is my main lead vocal, and close to the bottom there are two instances of 'LV31', the top being the clean vocal from the 47, underneath the dirty vocal sound from the 121. Right at the bottom is an early lead vocal track that wasn't used. The backing vocals were sung by Julian, Nick and Fabrizio [Moretti, the band's drummer].
Once sessions at One Way were completed, the mixing of the album was handed to Noah Georgeson, a guitarist, composer and electronic musician from California, who also busies himself with producing, engineering and mixing — his credits on the studio front include Devendra Banhart and Joanna Newsom. However, in the case of 'Under Cover Of Darkness' and 'Gratisfaction', the Strokes and Oberg ended up with the mix equivalent of demoitis: "The band decided in the end that they preferred the rough mixes that I'd done of those two tracks. I did rough mixes of all the tracks, although my mix of 'Under Cover' was slightly more than a rough mix. I had some ideas for how to cut up the drums, taking things out here and there, which you can see on the Edit window. We'd been working a lot on that, trying to make the chorus kick‑drum pattern work in the verse and so on, and taking out the room in places where it sounded too messy. We'd taken a year to come to conclusions about how the track should sound and where to cut the drums, et cetera, and my actual mix was very quick. It took me 30 minutes! Later, when the decision had been taken to use my mix, I said: 'If that's what you like, I can do one that's a little better and cleaner.' I'd slammed the tracks very hard through the board, and it's so compressed that it has pops in places that sound like percussive hits. I had not taken the time to do any crossfades. So I spent a whole day recreating and improving my mix. They sound virtually identical to me, but someone could hear the difference, and preferred the original. So we went with the one I did in half an hour!
"By the time we got to the mix, the band already was very clear about how they wanted the songs to sound. I think we were pretty set on everything, we had tracked things the way we wanted them to sound. Noah tried to do a lot on his early mixes, and they always asked him to tone it down. My mix of 'Under Cover' also doesn't change much about the sounds. Most of the compression and EQ was already added during rough mixing while tracking, plus, as I said earlier, I don't like using effects like delays and reverb. There are just a few plug‑ins, like the API 550 EQ on the kick and one of the boogie‑woogie lines, Bomb Factory 1176 on the snare top and again one of the boogie‑woogie lines. There's a Digidesign EQ4 on the bass and some of the backing vocals, 'MV2' on the bass DI is the Waves compressor, and there's a Waves S1 Stereo Imager on the overheads. Outboard included the Alan Smart C2 compressor, three or four 1176s, and I think I used an Empirical Labs Fatso on the drum submix and some API compression on the guitars. There's some Neve 1068 EQ on the drums, to boost the high end, and that was it. I prefer to keep it tight, which makes it more intense. I will try anything, but for this album, simplicity in the mix was the best approach.
"The Wunderbar does not have automation, so all my mixes were done manually, although I always use volume automation in Pro Tools. I've mixed in the box and I love the recall. The fact that you can bring up your session later on and it'll sound exactly the same is very convenient. But it also gets a little mechanical. It's more fun moving faders. Plus mixes done via a desk sound a little better, more powerful. I mixed on the small KRK ST6 speakers at One Way — we also have big KRK E8T monitors — and on [Yamaha] NS10s, always. The NS10s have been around for so long, I know exactly what they sound like. Plus every studio has them. How come 18 songs were tracked at Avatar and only 10 ended up on the album? We spoke about including 12 songs, but I felt nine or 10 was better. The album is already so intense, with a lot of information and intense lyrics, 34 minutes and 10 songs is enough. We wanted to keep it short. It would have been too much to have had to listen to another 10 minutes. We finished a few more tracks, but not all eight remaining tracks. At some point they'll be reworked for the next album, which will come out soon, hopefully.
"I mixed back into Pro Tools, at 24/96. Mastering was done by George Marino at Sterling Sound in New York City. Yeah, that took three months! It was just George and I, and then we sent what we did to the band for approval. George only had Tuesdays and Thursdays available, and we made a lot of changes. Mostly EQ and compression, but we also remixed the songs, using stems, like tucking in the vocal a bit lower, bringing stuff up, taking stuff down, half a dB, a quarter of a dB, swap choruses or verses, and so on. Noah and I had both sent stereo mixes and stems. We didn't hit the limiter very hard, because we don't like the loudness wars and over‑limited music. You can always turn your stereo up, which is what you should be doing.”
Amen to that! .
The Strokes experimented with unusual sounds on many of the tracks on Angles, particularly the atmospheric, experimental 'Call Me Back' — which, unlike 'Under Cover Of Darkness', features a lot of keyboards. Oberg ties up some loose ends: "Ninety-five percent of the keyboards were the Roland Juno 106! The other keyboards that were used were the MicroKorg XL, a Wurlitzer [electric piano], and a Farfisa organ. We tried to use MIDI, we wanted to use MIDI, but using it never actually beat the manually recorded parts, which were played by everyone in the band. Regarding 'Call Me Back', I didn't add any effects. There's a Juno 106 pad, and the megaphone effect on Julian's voice is just EQ. He sang very softly and I then slammed the vocal very hard through an 1176. Maybe feedback from the speakers also changed the sound. We did a lot of work on the guitar sounds. They used a bunch of pedals — like, for example the pink Maxon AD999 delay, the Electro‑Harmonix Memory Man, the Green Rhino distortion pedals, and so on. There's a distorted low guitar line which has a plug‑in on it. Somebody thought that it sounded too pretty, so I used a plug‑in, I can't recall which one, the Sansamp or Amp Farm or something like that. Also, I'd like to add that I occasionally used a TEAC quarter‑inch tape machine during tracking, that I bought one night/early morning coming back from the sessions. I'd transfer guitars to tape and back after comping, before mixing. Just on a few songs, to get a bit of the sound of analogue compression. I also used the TEAC for slap‑back echo on the drums for 'Gratisfaction', while mixing.”
Inside Track | Secrets Of The Mix Engineers
Thirty years after Led Zeppelin ended, Robert Plant has reached a second career high. His latest hit album was tracked and mixed by Mike Poole, using a mouth-watering selection of vintage equipment.
Interview | Engineers
With country guitars, what you hear on the record is what was played in the studio. We asked Nashville's leading engineers how they capture those tones.
Interview | Producer
Mike Vernon produced some of the greatest blues records of all time. A full decade after retiring, he's back in the studio with some of the British blues scene's brightest lights.
Some of the friends we've made over the years share their congratulations on our 25th birthday!
Interview | Music Production
The man behind the biggest UK single of the year — 'Pass Out' by Tinie Tempah — is 21-year-old musical prodigy and maverick Labrinth.
One of electronicas most adventurous spirits, Markus Popp has returned with an album that sounds surprisingly... musical. But is everything as it seems?
Interview | Engineer
As the Prodigy's chief live sound engineer, Jon Burton gets to unleash untold kilowatts of bass power on an unsuspecting world. He has also made multitrack recordings of every show on their 26-month world tour.
Interview | Band
Silver Apples jammed with Jimi Hendrix, counted John Lennon as a fan, and produced extraordinary electronic music — with nothing but a drum kit and a pile of electrical junk.
Interview | Producer
Nashville heavy-hitter Paul Worley was so impressed by Lady Antebellum that he gave up his high-profile job at Warner Bros to produce them. With Clarke Schleicher at the desk, the gamble paid off in style.
Four Decades Of De-evolution
Pioneers of everything from circuit-bending to multimedia art, Devo have always belonged to the future.
Andrew VanWyngarden & Ben Goldwasser: Recording Congratulations
MGMT could have followed up their smash hit debut album with more of the same. Instead, they headed straight into left field, with help from a legend of British psychedelia.
40 Years Of Krautrock
In 1969, Faust used their massive record company advance to build a unique studio and a collection of weird, custom-made effects units. The same experimental spirit lives on in their new album, Faust Is Last.
Producing The Defamation Of Strickland Banks
Plan B entered the public eye as a rapper, but its as a soul singer that he has conquered the charts. He and his production team revisit the tortuous story behind The Defamation Of Strickland Banks.
Inside Track: Johnny Cash | American VI: Ain’t No Grave
Sometimes the simplest-sounding music takes the most work to get right, and so it was with Johnny Cashs posthumous hit album American VI: Aint No Grave. Engineer and mixer David R Ferguson was on hand at every stage of Rick Rubins production.
Steven Wilson: Recording & Marketing Porcupine Tree
Every new Porcupine Tree album sells over a quarter of a million copies. And with founder Steven Wilson in control of everything from songwriting to shrink-wrapping, theres no middle man to take a cut. Read his valuable advice for SOS readers wishing to do likewise...
From Rock Producer To Pop Songwriter
Phil Thornalley learned his trade as a rock engineer and producer in the 80s. Then he co-wrote a little-known song called Torn...
Five Decades In The Studio
Legendary songwriter and Kinks frontman Ray Davies got his first taste of recording in 1964, and hes never looked back.
From humble beginnings in provincial Norway, the Stargate team have gone on to become one of Americas leading hit factories. Songwriter and producer Mikkel Eriksen explains how their hard work and talent brought success.
Time Trial: Bringing Multitracks and MIDI into the 21st Century
Dave Stewarts career has spanned several generations of music technology (from National Health band in the 1970s to hits with partner Barbara Gaskin. For his latest project, he faced the challenge of bringing his old multitracks and MIDI sequences into the computer age.
Inside Track: Michael Bublé ‘You’re Nobody Till Somebody Loves You’
In a rare interview, legendary engineer and producer Humberto Gatica explains how he and singer Michael Bublé breathed new life into big-band swing music — with stunning results.