M Audio BX5

Active Nearfield Monitors

Published in SOS December 2003
Bookmark and Share

Reviews : Monitors

M Audio's new desktop active monitors offer magnetic shielding and a smooth mid-range sound.

Paul White

Photos: Mark Ewing
M Audio BX5-1.s

The M Audio BX5 is two-way, compact active monitor built around a one-inch silk-domed tweeter and a 5.25-inch polypropylene-cone bass/mid-range driver. Each driver is fed from a 38W amplifier with a crossover frequency of 3kHz, while a number of rear-panel switches are provided in order to help tailor the response of the monitors to their location. Both drivers are magnetically shielded so that they can be used close to 'antique' CRT computer monitors without causing the colours to run.

Measuring a diminutive 9.85 x 6.54 x 7.88 inches, the cabinets are very solidly built, with rounded corners, and are finished in an attractive black plastic laminate. Both drivers are recessed into the baffle, and the silver mounting ring around the bass/mid-range driver houses a blue LED to show when the monitors are switched on.

The rear panel of the cabinet reveals a bass port and input connectors on both balanced jacks and XLRs, governed by a single volume control. Power connection is through the usual IEC socket and the power switch is also mounted on the rear panel. A three-way Acoustic Space slide switch corrects the bass end for proximity to boundaries by offering 2dB or 4dB of shelving low cut. The bass response may also be adjusted directly by selecting 56Hz, 80Hz or 100Hz roll-off values via another slide switch. A further switch allows the high end to be set flat, boosted by 2dB or cut by 2dB, and there's also a Presence in/out switch to add mid-range boost. This turned out to be quite subtle, helping lift out mid-range detail. A fixed, steep sixth-order filter (36dB/octave) is used to suppress frequencies below the handling range of the speakers, so as to prevent excessive driver excursions. The frequency response is quoted as 56Hz to 20kHz, which is claiming a lot for such a compact system. A matched M Audio active subwoofer will soon be available, which can used to set up stereo or surround monitoring systems, but this was not available in time for the review.

Second Opinion
The BX5s are more than powerful enough for nearfield monitoring applications, and the mid-range and high end seem reasonably detailed and well controlled for a monitor in this price bracket. In fact, the mid-range initially appeared unusually clear and detailed, but I quickly formed the opinion that this perception was attributable to a rather weak and constricted bass response.
Ported speakers inherently have a fairly steep roll-off, often preceded by a significant peak, but the bass end of the BX5 seemed curtailed more than most speakers in this respect. To my ears the LF response has an unusually high-Q roll off — presumably a combination of the port tuning and driver protection circuitry — and the result is a rather misleading spectral balance at the bass end. I gather these speakers have been designed with a matching subwoofer in mind, and it is possible that the LF response of the satellites has been pared back in an effort to increase the overall volume. If this is indeed the case, then I would expect the subwoofer combination to fare rather better than the satellite BX5s manage alone.
I auditioned the speakers with a familiar range of commercial CDs, plus some of my own source material, and while the speakers did an acceptable job in portraying spoken and unaccompanied singing voices in terms of tonality and detail, they fared less well with bass instruments generally, seeming to convey only the harmonics above the first overtone. With more complex mixes the speakers tended to present a rather thin and confused impression of what was going on in the lower octaves. The problem was primarily one of inconsistency. For example, smaller, higher-pitched kick drums could be portrayed with reasonable solidity, while lower-tuned drums often took on the character of cardboard boxes! Similar problems afflicted bass guitars and string basses, as well as keyboards and organs. Unfortunately, relocating the speakers to change the distances from side and rear walls, although changing the overall spectrum in the expected ways, did little to redress the inconsistent nature of the low bass.
When attempting to use the BX5s as mixdown monitors I found it hard to reliably judge the character, EQ and relative level of bass instruments within a mix. Switching to a pair of passive Dynaudio BM5s (only slightly larger than the BX5s reviewed here) revealed just how much LF information and extension was missing from the BX5's output. It is usually possible to learn how to compensate for a speaker's individual characteristics, but I found this impossible to achieve in the week or so that I had to work with the BX5s — the bass end seemed just too unpredictable.
In concert with the matching subwoofer, the system performance might well reach the standard necessary of a monitoring-grade loudspeaker, but on their own I'm not convinced that the BX5s are sufficiently accurate or extended to enable mixes made using these speakers to 'travel well'. Hugh Robjohns

Performance

I set up the speakers on top of a double-width, wooden-topped equipment rack, close to the front edge and around 18 inches from the nearest wall, as I guessed this would approximate (or even improve upon) the way many people would use desktop-sized monitors. As usual, I conscripted my Mackie HR824s as references — I have these set with their bass roll-off switches at 47Hz, as that happens to suit my room. Evaluating the performance of the BX5s on their reproduction of familiar CDs in various styles proved very interesting. The mid-range and high end are detailed, but the use of a silk-domed tweeter manages to keep the high end reasonably smooth so that you can use them for extended periods without experiencing undue fatigue. Switching in Presence brings out the mid-range detail even more, but the effect isn't over-dramatic. No maximum SPL is quoted, but in a nearfield environment they can play very loud without losing clarity.

M Audio BX5-2.s

I settled on using the flat settings for my tests, in order to get the maximum bass end from the speakers, and discovered that the perception of bass changed depending on the type, and even the period of music being played. For example, I dug out some old Alex Harvey band material which was recorded in the early '70s, and the bass guitar and kick drum came over as quite punchy even though they didn't have the depth you'd expect from bigger monitors. By contrast, I played the latest Afro Celts album, which presents a much wider spectrum of bass energy through the use of synths and electronic percussion, and I found the perceived bass end noticeably lacking, making the sound seem somewhat 'small' and constricted. Switching to my Mackies at a similar monitoring level revealed a bass end that could move furniture, so it's my guess that the BX5's use of a sixth-order filter to protect the driver has an audible effect on the lower reaches of the bass end. It's almost as though you get to hear only the upper half of the bass spectrum, and that everything below a certain point has just been sliced off, which is pretty much what you'd expect from a high-order filter.

The reproduction of voices is quite adequate, with no conspicuous vices, and as with any speaker that has a limited bass response, the mid-range appears clearer, which makes it easier to focus in on detail. Nevertheless, the somewhat unpredictable bass response would make it quite difficult to do a full-range mix with any certainty as to the outcome — and it's not just a question of physical size, as I have a pair of AVI Neutrons (which are two-way passive monitors of a very similar size) that deliver a far more even and extended bass end.

The M Audio BX5s are, in my view, perfectly useful speakers for monitoring while recording, and their small size makes them ideal for use in desktop systems where there is little space available. Magnetic shielding is becoming less of an issue as flat-screen monitors become cheaper, but it's still a welcome inclusion. I'd be far less happy using the BX5s for mixing, other than in a secondary reference role, as their bass end is simply not extended enough to allow accurate value judgements to be made in this area. If you treat them as the modern equivalent of the Auratone to check that the playback will sound good on a small hi-fi system (but with a far more accurate high-end and mid-range balance than I remember my old Auratones having!) you won't go far wrong.

In this article:
M Audio BX5 £249
pros
Compact.
Smooth mid-range and high-frequency reproduction.
Magnetically shielded.
Adequately loud.
cons
Bass end inadequate for serious mixing, although adding a subwoofer may help here.
summary
In most respects, these monitors are accurate enough for serious recording work, but their limited bass response makes them unsuitable for mixing unless used with a subwoofer.
information
£249 per pair including VAT.
M Audio +44 (0)1442 416590.
+44 (0)1442 246832.


SOS Readers Ads
GRAB A BARGAIN

£502,443

of Second-User Gear for sale now — don't miss out!

AVI Neutron Five

2.1 Monitor System

Thumbnail for article: AVI Neutron Five

This interesting monitor system uses the natural roll-off of the satellite speakers to provide the crossover with the subwoofer.

Tannoy Reveal 601A

Studio Nearfield Reference Monitors

Thumbnail for article: Tannoy Reveal 601A

Building to a price inevitably entails compromises. The art is in choosing the right ones...

Quested V3110

Three-way Active Monitors

Thumbnail for article: Quested V3110

Sometimes, a dose of old-fashioned good engineering delivers something well worth listening to...

Adam A7X

Active Two-way Studio Monitors

Thumbnail for article: Adam A7X

Their A7 nearfield monitors received many plaudits, not least in the pages of SOS, but manufacturer Adam thought there was room for improvement.

PMC TB2S AII

Active Nearfield Monitors

Thumbnail for article: PMC TB2S AII

PMC broke new ground a decade ago with their TB2 monitors, but the competition have been catching up. Does PMCs new activated design nudge them back to the front of the pack?

Avantone Active MixCube

Secondary Reference Monitors

Avantone have added on-board amplification to their contemporary take on the classic Horrortone secondary monitor, and the result is something quite special...

Sonodyne SM 50AK

Two-way Nearfield Active Monitors

Thumbnail for article: Sonodyne SM 50AK

India may be a growing force in most industries these days, but few Indian pro-audio companies have made it into Western markets. Can Sonodynes speakers change all that?

Unity Audio The Rock

Monitor Speakers

Thumbnail for article: Unity Audio The Rock

The time-domain response of monitors is often sacrificed for level, but this sealed-cabinet design tackles that issue head-on...

Infrasonic Blow 4D

Nearfield Monitor Speakers

Thumbnail for article: Infrasonic Blow 4D

With digital and analogue inputs, these small speakers from newcomers Infrasonic promise a lot for the money. Can they outperform their budget price tag?

Blue Sky Sat 8 & Sub 212

2.1 Monitoring System

Thumbnail for article: Blue Sky Sat 8 & Sub 212

If you demand brutal and revealing precision from your monitors, read on...

Barefoot Sound MicroMain 27

Active Three-way Monitors

Thumbnail for article: Barefoot Sound MicroMain 27

As well as a distinctive design, these huge nearfield monitors offer a frequency and time-domain performance that compares with the best.

Adam S3XV

Studio Reference Monitors

Thumbnail for article: Adam S3XV

Adam make the leap to a three-way speaker design that seems to pay dividends in clarity and separation.

JBL LSR 2300

Monitor Speakers

Thumbnail for article: JBL LSR 2300

JBL have a reputation for clinically precise monitors, but this time theyve come up with something a little smoother...

Equator Audio Q8

Active Monitors

Thumbnail for article: Equator Audio Q8

Coaxially-mounted speakers may seem a bit old-school, but theres nothing wrong with the theory — and a touch of DSP can make them very modern indeed!

M-Audio Studiophile DSM1

DSP Reference Monitors

Thumbnail for article: M-Audio Studiophile DSM1

Built-in DSP extends the flexibility and usefulness of these capable speakers.

Event Opal

Studio Monitors

Thumbnail for article: Event Opal

Events new owners make some extravagant claims for these new high-end monitors, whose design is said to put quality first. Do they live up to the hype?

Samson Resolv A6 & 120A

Studio Monitors & Subwoofer

Thumbnail for article: Samson Resolv A6 & 120A

Samsons new low-cost nearfields can produce a big sound, but do they measure up for serious mixing? We find out.

Prodipe Pro Ribbon 8

Active Monitors

Thumbnail for article: Prodipe Pro Ribbon 8

Ribbon tweeters can yield a smooth sound, while still capably reproducing transient detail — and the Pro Ribbon range promises to do so for an attractive price.

Focal CMS65

Active Nearfield Monitors

Thumbnail for article: Focal CMS65

Focal control everything from design to manufacture in their factory in France — and this approach appears to be paying off.

Klein+Hummel O410

Active Midfield Monitors

Thumbnail for article: Klein+Hummel O410

Getting the balance right between the benefits and disadvantages of ported and non-ported speaker designs is a tricky job, and K+H do it better than most with this ported model.

WIN Great Prizes in SOS Competitions!

 

Home | Search | News | Current Issue | Tablet Mag | Articles | Forum | Subscribe | Shop | Readers Ads

Advertise | Information | Privacy Policy | Support | Login Help

 

Email: Contact SOS

Telephone: +44 (0)1954 789888

Fax: +44 (0)1954 789895

Registered Office: Media House, Trafalgar Way, Bar Hill, Cambridge, CB23 8SQ, United Kingdom.

Sound On Sound Ltd is registered in England and Wales.

Company number: 3015516 VAT number: GB 638 5307 26

         

All contents copyright © SOS Publications Group and/or its licensors, 1985-2014. All rights reserved.
The contents of this article are subject to worldwide copyright protection and reproduction in whole or part, whether mechanical or electronic, is expressly forbidden without the prior written consent of the Publishers. Great care has been taken to ensure accuracy in the preparation of this article but neither Sound On Sound Limited nor the publishers can be held responsible for its contents. The views expressed are those of the contributors and not necessarily those of the publishers.

Web site designed & maintained by PB Associates | SOS | Relative Media