Yamaha FS1R

FM Synthesis/Formant-shaping Tone Generator

Published in SOS December 1998
Bookmark and Share

Reviews : Sound Module

FM synthesis was the success story of the mid-'80s, and synths based on its principles, like Yamaha's DX7, sold by the bucketload -- until affordable sample-based synths arrived at the end of the decade. Now, with their new FS1R, Yamaha have updated the technology for the late '90s. Derek Johnson & Debbie Poyser gaze on the new face of FM...

When Yamaha launched their SY85 in 1992, it seemed like the end of an era. For the first time since the advent of the hugely successful DX Frequency Modulation (FM) synths in the early '80s, here was a Yamaha hi-tech instrument without FM in any form. Sample-based synthesis had seemingly taken over the world, and perhaps FM was looking like tired technology at Yamaha HQ. What goes around comes around, however: after all, analogue synthesis has undergone an astonishing renaissance in the '90s, and more recently, retro interest in FM has been bubbling under, with instruments such as the DX100 and TX81Z attaining cultish appeal in techno circles for their FM basses and electric pianos. In current manufacturing terms, though, FM had all but disappeared. Until now, that is...

YAMAHA FS1R £699
pros
A genuinely different form of synthesis in Formant Shaping.
Unique, powerful sounds.
Helpful real-time control knobs.
DX7 compatibility.
Four outputs.
Internal power supply!
cons
Using the filter cuts polyphony by half.
User Formant Sequences can't be created anywhere yet, and even if they could, saving them inside the FS1R would cut the Voice memory in half.
The operating system can be confusing, and the manual doesn't offer enough help.
summary
Despite the odd niggle, the FS1R is an exciting synth you really should hear. Hats off to its designer for developing Formant Shaping and taking a new and very fruitful look at FM.

Apparently out of the blue, Yamaha have released their first new FM instrument for several years, the FS1R. But -- and this is an important but -- it's FM with a difference. Not only is it an eight-Operator variant (like 1982's trailblazing, megabuck GS1), as opposed to the six- and four-Operator FM of the DX/TX range, but it also incorporates a new, potentially very powerful technology called Formant Shaping Synthesis. Formants are, in this case, the spectral patterns making up the sounds of human speech, so one of the FS1R's great strengths is the creation of vocal-like timbres.

If you've seen any of the limited press info for the FS1R it might come as a surprise to find that this is an FM instrument at all, as the marketing approach seems to be to play down the FM angle and play up the FSS angle. There's one thing you can be sure of: there are no samples anywhere on board, nor is there any physical modelling trying to convince you the FS1R is a saxophone or a vintage analogue synth.

From The Outside In

The FS1R doesn't break with the traditional rackmount synth module look. Indeed, anyone who knows Yamaha's MU100R/90R will be in familiar territory as far as appearance is concerned, as the FS1R uses a similar casing and an identical display. One major difference between the FS1R and the MU modules is the presence of four control knobs on the far right of the FS, which have different functions depending on the mode of the synth, and can be used for real-time sound modification. Other front-panel features comprise a headphone socket, volume control, a large backlit LCD (with lettering easily visible even from across the room), and a total of 15 small, round editing buttons, arranged in one group of six and one group of nine. Next up are the four knobs, plus two more small buttons which light up red when activated: these select one of two sets of knob control parameters in Play mode. Finally, there's a large, recessed power switch.

The obligatory look at the back panel reveals a power inlet for the built-in power supply -- whoopee! -- plus MIDI In, Out and Thru, and two pairs of stereo outputs.

Inside the FS1R is a synth engine capable of 32-note polyphony and 4-part multitimbrality. These days, four is a pretty low number of simultaneous voices, but Yamaha justify it, quite reasonably, by saying that the FS1R wasn't designed as an all-round studio in a box for the creation of entire orchestral arrangements, say, but rather a dedicated synthesizer whose forté is interesting, individual sounds. You'd have an FS1R as an addition to a general-purpose workstation, not instead of one.

A total of 1408 preset Voices and 384 preset Performances are on board, plus 128 user Voice and 128 user Performance memories. Three separate effects processors are built in -- reverb/delay, variation effects including chorus, flange, phase and so on, and 'insertion' effects, including some basic multi-effects configurations -- and there's 3-band EQ.

The FS1R & FM

If you're familiar with the workings of any other FM synth, that's a head start when it comes to understanding the FS1R. For those who haven't used an FM synth before, we'll take a brief look at how FM relates to this new instrument.

  MIDI Control  
  The FS1R responds to incoming MIDI note data, velocity, pitch bend, mod wheel and aftertouch, and has a comprehensive system for routing MIDI controllers to FS1R parameters. Per Performance, up to eight parameters can be tweaked over MIDI, using up to eight of the following as control sources: the four knobs (which also respond to and transmit MIDI data), mod wheel, aftertouch, foot controller and breath controller, pitch-bend, and four MIDI controllers of your choice. Assignments can be switched off for each Part in a Performance, which is great if you want the filter cutoff altered for one Part, but not the others, for example. The manual is rather confusing about MIDI control -- you learn much more by just doing it. A section of the display aims to assist in keeping track of which controllers are active and which controllers are assigned to which Parts; in practice, this does help, but the graphic is quite small, so it's necessary to peer closely to get an idea of what's assigned where.  

Put simply, FM synthesis involves the modulation of the frequency of one waveform (the carrier) by another (the modulator). This interaction generates a complex range of subsidiary frequencies, which results in timbral change; the greater the modulation, the greater the change in timbre. As commercially implemented by Yamaha, these waveforms were all sine waves generated by oscillators, and each oscillator (in combination with a series of fairly familiar synth parameters, such as an envelope generator, level, keyboard scaling and so on), was dubbed an 'Operator'. Several Operators -- six in the case of the massively successful DX7 -- were organised into algorithms, which essentially preset the interaction of the carriers and modulators in a voice. The simplest algorithms laid the six Operators side by side, with no modulator/carrier interaction, offering basic additive synthesis facilities. More complicated algorithms organised the Operators in parallel or serial configurations -- a modulator could itself be modulated, for the generation of even more complex timbres. Every algorithm also included a feedback loop, whereby one or more modulators modulated themselves. Algorithms were depicted graphically as linked blocks on the top panel of all Yamaha's FM keyboard synths.

Later FM synths offered variants on these ideas; the Operators on these instruments offered a choice of waveforms, rather than the basic sine wave of (for example) the DX7.

This outline applies pretty well to the FS1R's basic voice architecture, though the new synth is understandably much more complex. Up to eight Operators are configured in an algorithm, and there are 88 algorithms on board (the DX7 offered 32). There's one algorithm per FS1R Voice, and up to four Voices are combined in a Performance.

An FS1R Operator is more comprehensive than a DX Operator, since the basic sine wave is joined by seven other waveform options -- or 'spectral forms' in FS1R-speak -- including broad- and narrow-band all-harmonics, broad- and narrow-band odd-harmonics, resonant broad- and narrow-band, and formant, for a wider range of potential sounds. Original DX synths lacked a filter, whereas the FS1R includes a very good one, and until late in their run, older FM-equipped synths had little, or nothing, in the way of effects. Again, the FS1R is well endowed in that department.

But it's at the Operator level that the FS1R reveals its complexity and power, especially in the creation of voice-like timbres. In order to accurately emulate the workings of a human vocal tract, Yamaha have provided two sets of formant Operators, eight 'voiced' and eight 'unvoiced', that work side by side in pairs -- so you could say that the FS1R is actually a 16-Operator synth. The voiced formant Operators, which are basically oscillators, mimic the larynx, producing the basic sounds, or vowels. Speech needs consonants, however, which brings us to the eight unvoiced Operators. Essentially noise generators (which can be used as such when synthesizing percussion or sound effects), the unvoiced Operators allow the FS1R to imitate consonants.

The FS1R manual says convincing speech can be emulated using three to five formants, so there are evidently enough to be going on with in the FS1R! The synth can even be made to talk (or sing), using so-called Formant Sequences -- more on this later.

  Favourite Sounds  
  With over 1400 Voices and nearly 500 Performances on offer, you could spend a long time just checking out the FS1R's presets. Here's a necessarily small selection of our favourite Performances.

Performance A 074 Solstice: an amazing wave-sequencing-like effect that sounds as though it couldn't be possible with FM. Upon examination, we found that each of the Operators had been treated as a single oscillator, with its envelope delayed to fit into the resulting pattern. Simple when you know how it's done, but quite remarkable. We asked Yamaha whether a rhythmic Performance like this could be sync'd to MIDI clock, and the answer was no -- but perhaps in a future update?
Performance A 006 Hollywood: probably meant to have a Jan Hammer/Miami Vice feel, this Performance is another eye-opening example of what can be done with the FS1R. It sounds almost like a complete track in itself, with a drum part made using an FSeq and a chugging, menacing 16th-note pad sound.
Performance A 009 Platipus: convincing Minimoog-style lead sound with lots of depth, yet the ability to really cut through.
Performance A 030 Power Key: powerful, distorted FM electric-piano type sound with a real Roxy Music-for-the-'90s edge. Use sparingly for best effect.
Performance A 066 Furry Bell: pretty, delicate bell sound at higher pitches, with a soft halo of echoes.
Performance A 121 Drum Kit 1: surprisingly solid kick, lovely, bouncy snare, and open and closed hi-hat simulations.
Performance B 022 Nu Suitcase: great, phasey electric piano.
Performance B 097 Dark Pad: absurdly warm, Oberheimy pad.
Performance C 035 FM Slap: classic, edgy, unmistakable FM slap bass.

Performance C 054 Vox Move: ethereal vocal pad that's quite beautiful in the upper registers.
Ladies & Gentlemen, may I have your attention please?: this cute, wistful synth voice isn't actually a preset, but is part of the synth's 'Vocodrone' Demo. If this demo is selected and then demo mode exited, the Performance used in it remains in the edit buffer, whereupon it (and its constituent Voices) can be saved in the user memory.

 

A La Modes

The FS1R powers up in Play Mode, from which you can select and audition its Performances. There's no separate Voice mode as such: Voices are accessed and edited from within Performances. In practice this is quite elegant and logical, but it may feel strange at first to those accustomed to how other synths work. It has three edit Modes, Performance, Voice and Effect, plus a Utility Mode, for global housekeeping chores such as display contrast, master tuning, and global MIDI options. To audition, or change, individual Voices, you need to access Part Assign Mode, wherein Voices are assigned to Performance Parts (four per Performance), and basic Part parameters such as MIDI receive channel, volume, pan, effects send and note shift are set.

At The Operator & Voice Level

In Voice Edit mode, parameters are divided into two groups -- Operator and Common. The former are available for each Operator, while the latter apply to a Voice as a whole. The upshot is that there are lots of parameters!

Operator parameters: Each Operator in an algorithm can be modified by a set of synthesis parameters. The exact parameters vary depending on whether you're editing voiced or unvoiced Operators, and on which 'spectral form' is chosen for the voiced Operators. All Operators, whether voiced or unvoiced, have frequency (pitch) parameters, an amplitude envelope generator (with 'hold' parameter for delaying onset of the envelope), frequency EG (which produces a filter EG effect), and various sensitivity parameters that determine how Operator amplitude and formant frequency respond to velocity, amongst other parameters.

All voiced Operators have detuning, key sync and a range of level-scaling parameters. One use for the latter would be to split groups of Operators into virtual 'keygroups' in a Voice, enabling a single algorithm to apparently produce different sounds at different points on the keyboard. Unvoiced Operators are cut back to one level-scaling parameter, which alters their volume response either side of middle C. This is a shame, because there would have been scope for creating percussion sets with up to eight voices had level scaling been as comprehensively implemented as for voiced Operators.

  Effects  
  The FS1R's complement of four effects processors is comprehensive enough, with a straightforward signal path. There's a 'send' for each of the global effects (reverb/delay and variation) from each Performance Part. In addition, an insert effect can be switched into any (or all) Parts, allowing a single Part to be treated with a different effect than the remaining three Parts. This is a good, modern, touch, but how much nicer if there had been four insertion effects! Insert effects include some simple multi-effects, as well as various modulation, delay, and distortion options. In addition, there are some cross-patching parameters that pass the variation effect through the reverb/delay, and the insert effect through the variation and/or the reverb/delay. As mentioned elsewhere, a fully parametric three-band EQ is also counted amongst the effects; this is global for all four Parts.  
Formant Operators are a special case, though they do have access to standard voiced-Operator parameters. It's possible to think of a formant Operator as a mini synth, combining an oscillator and filter in one unit, and its sound is shaped by parameters which include centre frequency, level, bandwidth and the amusing 'skirt'. This last parameter determines the shape of the flare at the bottom of a formant's bell-shaped response curve -- higher values produce a wider skirt!

Unvoiced Operators don't have quite as many parameters as voiced, but they do have the same bandwidth, resonance and 'skirt' parameters, and can even be made to resonate to self-oscillation. During the review, this latter feature was used to provide a couple of excellent sub-oscillators that, whilst almost inaudible when solo'd, added weight and body to the main sound.

Common parameters: Additional modifications can be made to an algorithm as a whole, using the so-called Voice Common parameters. Included in this set of parameters are two LFOs, a pitch EG, and a filter. The latter is in addition to the filter-like parameters available to each formant Operator, and is more like a VCF on an analogue or S&S synth. It's rather well-specified, with low-pass (12dB, 18dB or 24dB per octave), high-pass, band-pass and band-reject options, plus cutoff frequency and resonance controls, and even comes equipped with its own EG. Using the filter does have one unfortunate side-effect, however: bafflingly, it cuts a Voice's polyphony in half.

At The Performance Level

Performance editing parameters are organised, as are Voice parameters, in two groups -- Common and Part.

Performance Common parameters treat all four Parts in a Performance, and include individual output assignment, controller assignment (whereby various control sources, including the front-panel knobs and various incoming MIDI controllers, can be used to alter parameters in real time), and the choice of Formant Sequences (FSeqs).

FSeqs are what allow the FS1R to 'talk' or 'sing' recognisable words or phrases. This is achieved by sequencing the frequency, fundamental pitch and level for each voiced/unvoiced formant pair. Only one FSeq per Performance is possible, so Voices will never say or sing anything too complicated, although the presets manage phrases such as "I Love You", "Yamaha FS1R" and "Are you ready?". A nice touch is that playback speed of phrases can be increased or decreased, and even sync'd to MIDI clock. And since the sound of formants isn't pitch dependent, speed and pitch can be varied over a wide range without altering the basic timbre of the sounds -- try that with your sampler! FSeqs can also loop, with Performance B 013 Shooby Do a prime example: it sings 'shooby do wop', with the 'wop' bit looping if a key is held down. This Performance also illustrates a nifty triggering option, where the FSeq is triggered by the first key press; as long as one of the first keys pressed is held down, the loop will kick in, and you can play tunes within the FSeq without retriggering the phrase.

Unfortunately, FSeqs are a silver cloud with a grey lining: there are 90 preset FSeqs, which provide a wide range of actual phrases, fun gibberish, laughing and, surprisingly, arpeggio and drum patterns, but there are only six memory positions for your own FSeqs. And it gets worse: there's no way of creating your own FSeqs on the FS1R. A software editor -- whether from Yamaha or a third party -- will offer the only solution, and none is available yet. And if you could save your own FSeqs, doing so would halve the user Voice memory -- you'd have space for only 64 of your own Voices instead of 128. This takes some of the shine off what may be one of the most exciting aspects of any new synth of recent years. If there's a way to fix this with a software or hardware update, Yamaha should be urged to try to find it. We hear that there's a development tool which turns WAV or AIFF files into FSeqs, and it would be fabulous if the public could have access to that -- imagine, you could sing or say something and have it transformed into an FS1R synth voice!

Performance Part parameters: Even from within Performance Edit, it's possible to tweak many of an individual Voice's parameters (for example, LFO speed, filter cutoff, resonance and EG depth, EG attack, decay and release times). However, when you change, say, LFO speed for a Voice within Performance Edit mode, all you're actually doing is adding an offset to that Voice's stored LFO speed value. The Voice itself will sound as though it's been edited, but remains unchanged -- only the offset value is stored as a Performance edit. This is excellent and means that you can tweak away to your heart's content at Voices in a Performance, secure in the knowledge that you won't have screwed up that Voice or its appearance in any other Performance.

  Documentation  
  The main user manual is surprisingly thin at 88 pagess. There's also a separate data list giving the FS1R's MIDI implementation and listing preset Performances, Voices and FSeqs, plus effect parameters and a handy list of controllers, for use when assigning MIDI and knob controllers. The FS1R's documentation is completed with an algorithm card.

The manual isn't one of Yamaha's best, suffering from a less than comprehensive index and a few organisational problems. A few more explanations of the parameters wouldn't go amiss: those with FM experience may know how to use Level Scaling of Operators to create timbral splits, but you wouldn't necessarily be able to work it out from the manual, for example.

 

An easy way of tweaking a Performance without venturing too deeply into the OS is to use the four front-panel knobs to alter a total of eight parameters (four preset and four you can assign yourself) for all four Parts at once. As above, when a Performance edit made with the knobs is saved as a new Performance, the constituent voices remain unscathed.

There are a few parameters which are unique to Performance edit mode, covering pitch settings (detune, note shift), portamento, pitch bend, note assign, polyphony reserve, mono/poly mode, plus high/low note and high/low velocity values, for splits and velocity layers.

FS1R In Use

Programming and editing the FS1R is very different from programming and editing an S&S synth. For a start, there are no banks of raw samples as a basis for programming -- instead there are 88 eight-Operator algorithms. You don't know what any of the algorithms are going to sound like until you play through them, and a few suggestions in the manual for what each might lend itself to would have been nice. The display does attempt to help, but the graphic it uses to display algorithms is so small it's practically invisible unless you're all but on top of the synth.

Of course, when programming a bass-type sound, say, you'd start by tweaking a bass preset, and realistically many people will start their own sounds from one of the 1400+ factory presets. DX7 aficionados will like the fact that the FS1R has almost complete compatibility with 6-Operator FM synths: you can send, via MIDI, a patch from a DX7, for example, and the FS1R will convert it to an identical-sounding patch in the new synth. A lot of the preset Voices actually come from the DX7's library. It's also possible to program sounds from DX7 sound charts, finding an algorithm that has an equivalent layout to the DX algorithm and turning off the unwanted Operators.

The FS1R isn't the friendliest synth to program. Changing parameters from the front panel can be a bit tricky -- the buttons are small, the display isn't ideally suited to the synth, and the many parameters are organised in a hierarchy that's often three levels deep. However, there is an alternative to pecking at the tiny buttons, since the four knobs can scroll though Performance Parts or Voice algorithm Operators, navigate menus, select from lists of parameters, and change their values. And there are nice touches: individual Parts in Performances and individual Operators within Voices can be muted or solo'd in order to fine-tune an edit, a Search button quickly finds themed Voices or Performances within named categories, and the Play button provides a quick audition of whatever you're editing. The display, though obviously borrowed from the MU family, provides some help: the bottom strip shows MIDI channel, category setting and volume level, amongst other useful information.

  Swotting Up On FM  
  When the DX7 was first released, it was known as much for being hard to program as it was for offering a completely new synthesis system. In retrospect, it's not quite as difficult as it once seemed. After all, FM happened at the dawn of parameter access, before we'd all got used to doing without dedicated knobs and buttons, which probably helped to give it a reputation for inscrutability it didn't fully deserve.

Part three of Paul Wiffen's Synth School series (SOS September 1997) goes into great detail regarding FM synthesis. If you want more, check out the digital synthesis chapter of SOS contributor Martin Russ's Sound Synthesis and Sampling, available from SOS mail order.

 
But any OS shortcomings the FS1R has are mitigated to a huge extent by the sounds it can produce. It really does sound like no other synth -- both lush and digital at the same time, without being thin or cold. If you were to compare its character to anything, in some ways it's rather like the super-expensive digital synths of the '80s, such as the Synclavier and PPG Wave. Loads of presence, loads of depth, a big sound that's bright without being strident. Some of the factory presets knock you backwards on first hearing (the 'Favourite Presets' box gives a personal 'best of' selection), without being gimmicky. The presence of unvoiced formant Operators introducing a noise element even allows drum-like timbres to be produced from a synth that has no drum samples.

Some might say the Formant Sequence presets are gimmicky, and no doubt they'll be appearing all over chart records within a very short space of time. But they're great fun, reminding of Kraftwerk and Electric Music, in the way that something that's not quite human, but not quite electronic, seems to be speaking and singing. The FSeqs almost give the FS1R a personality, and will become much more than a gimmick when some way for users to create their own is introduced.

Remember, too, that the FS1R's formant Operators are not just confined to voice-like timbres -- they can make almost any type of sound feel more 'real', partly because the formant component of an FS1R sound is completely independent of pitch. Thus sounds using formants will play much more naturally at the extremes of the keyboard than sample-based sounds.

Conclusion

Genuinely novel synthesis systems are increasingly hard to come by. The last big new thing was physical modelling, and its main task these days seems to be recreating decades-old analogue technology. The FS1R isn't completely revolutionary -- it features a development of 15-year-old technology, after all -- but it does manage to offer a sound and method quite unlike any other synth on the market. Even for those who don't want to do in-depth programming the FS1R has lots to offer; there are tons of quality presets, which can be easily layered into new Performances and then tweaked with the front-panel knobs, all with no real knowledge of FM needed. And though programming enthusiasts will probably find that the FS1R requires a bit of effort to come to grips with, the results should more than repay their time and trouble. Formant Shaping, in particular, is a serious, exciting achievement on the part of this synth's designers and a breakthrough at any price, let alone at £699. Looks like FM's back to stay!

 information
£699 including VAT.
Yamaha-Kemble Brochure Line +44 (0)1908 369269.
+44 (0)1908 368872.
www.yamaha.co.uk

SOS Readers Ads
GRAB A BARGAIN

£454,302

of Second-User Gear for sale now — don't miss out!
WIN Great Prizes in SOS Competitions!

 

Home | Search | News | Current Issue | Tablet Mag | Articles | Forum | Subscribe | Shop | Readers Ads

Advertise | Information | Privacy Policy | Support | Login Help

 

Email: Contact SOS

Telephone: +44 (0)1954 789888

Fax: +44 (0)1954 789895

Registered Office: Media House, Trafalgar Way, Bar Hill, Cambridge, CB23 8SQ, United Kingdom.

Sound On Sound Ltd is registered in England and Wales.

Company number: 3015516 VAT number: GB 638 5307 26

         

All contents copyright © SOS Publications Group and/or its licensors, 1985-2014. All rights reserved.
The contents of this article are subject to worldwide copyright protection and reproduction in whole or part, whether mechanical or electronic, is expressly forbidden without the prior written consent of the Publishers. Great care has been taken to ensure accuracy in the preparation of this article but neither Sound On Sound Limited nor the publishers can be held responsible for its contents. The views expressed are those of the contributors and not necessarily those of the publishers.

Web site designed & maintained by PB Associates | SOS | Relative Media