It took a while for Bob Dylan to hit his stride on his seventh studio album, but once he did there was no stopping him. Producer Bob Johnston recalls the difficult birth of Blonde On Blonde.
If it isn't broken, don't fix it, right? Well, not necessarily, based on the evidence of Bob Johnston's work with Bob Dylan.
In the summer of 1965, after Dylan had recorded the seminal 'Like A Rolling Stone' and then fallen out with his producer Tom Wilson, Johnston stepped into Wilson's shoes for the rest of Highway 61 Revisited, Dylan's sixth studio album and his first to be recorded entirely with a full rock band. However, between the 15th June 'Like A Rolling Stone' session and the July/August Highway 61 dates, Dylan had caused a stink and been heckled for his electric set at the Newport Folk Festival. Accordingly, much of Highway 61 had an aggressive edge and accusatory tone, resulting in one of Dylan's finest works, of which he himself remarked: "I'm not gonna be able to make a record better than that one... Highway 61 is just too good. There's a lot of stuff on there that I would listen to.”
Nevertheless, instead of sticking to any sort of tried and trusted formula while Dylan was still finding his feet in the world of electric folk-rock, Johnston initiated a geographical and musical change of direction for his next album by suggesting that the Minnesota native switch the recording locale from the CBS facility in New York City to that in Nashville. Having already worked in Tennessee's country music capital with legendary 'A‑Team' session musicians such as guitarist Grady Martin and pianist Floyd Cramer, recording demos for the movie songs that he and his wife Joy Byers wrote for Elvis Presley, Johnston had recruited harp player Charlie McCoy from there to play guitar on Highway 61. During those sessions, he'd then broached the idea of placing Dylan in an unfamiliar environment for his next record, among musicians whose entire approach was different to anything he had experienced.
"I was standing there with Dylan, his manager Albert Grossman, Clive Davis and the President of Columbia Records, Bill Gallagher,” Johnston recalls, "and I said, 'Dylan, you've gotta go down to Nashville sometime. They've got the studio straightened out down there — I made sure they got rid of all the little rooms with a saw and a sledgehammer so that it's one big room. The musicians are great there, and you can do anything you want to, all in the room together.' He said, 'Hmm.' He would never answer you, but, just like Jack Benny, he'd put his thumb up to his chin and think about what you'd said, and in this case he then walked out and Grossman, Davis and Gallagher came over to me and basically said, 'If you ever mention Nashville to Bob Dylan again, you're fired.' When I said, 'Why?' I was told, 'Because we don't want him working with a bunch of goddamn stupid people down there. You've got him going good here, and it looks like we're going to have a great record. So keep it that way and just remember what we told you.' I said, 'Yes, sir, you're the boss.'
Seven months later, Bob Johnston took Bob Dylan to Nashville, and it was there, in the Columbia studio facility on Music Row, that they cut most of Blonde On Blonde. Acclaimed by many as Dylan's finest work, this musically eclectic, lyrically surreal double album featured such local greats as guitarists Wayne Moss, Joe South and Jerry Kennedy; drummer Kenny Buttrey; keyboard player Hargus 'Pig' Robbins; bassist Henry Strzelecki; and Charlie McCoy on bass, guitar, harmonica and trumpet. Additionally, there were the likes of New York multi‑instrumentalist Al Kooper, who had played the distinctive Hammond riffs on 'Like A Rolling Stone'; and Canadian guitarist Robbie Robertson, a member of the Hawks (later known as the Band) who had recently been backing Dylan in concert, and who contributed to 'One Of Us Must Know (Sooner Or Later)' when it was recorded in New York, before the switch to Nashville.
Johnston produced half a dozen Dylan albums during a five‑year period that also yielded John Wesley Harding (1967), Nashville Skyline (1969, on which 'To Be Alone with You' commences with the artist asking his producer, 'Is it rolling, Bob?'), Self Portrait (1970) and New Morning (1970). But in addition he has a long and varied list of credits that includes seven albums with Johnny Cash, three with Leonard Cohen, and others with the Byrds, Moby Grape, Marty Robbins, Louis Armstrong, Aretha Franklin, Pete Seeger and Willie Nelson.
Very much the right man in the right place at the right time, Johnston took over the production reins from Tom Wilson not only for Bob Dylan, but also for Simon & Garfunkel, helming three of their most successful abums — Sounds Of Silence (1966), Parsley, Sage, Rosemary & Thyme (1966) and Bookends (1968) — and again overseeing a folk‑rock transition that Wilson had initiated.
"Johnston had fire in his eyes,” Dylan himself wrote in his 2004 autobiography, Chronicles: Volume One. "He had that thing that some people call 'Momentum'.You could see it in his face and he shared that fire, that spirit. Columbia's leading folk and country producer, he was born one hundred years too late. He should have been wearing a wide cape, a plumed hat, and riding with his sword held high. Johnston disregarded any warning that might get in his way... Johnston lived on low country barbecue, and he was all charm.”
Whether or not the timing of his birth was off, Donald William 'Bob' Johnston entered this world in Hillsboro, Texas, on the 14th May 1932, and was steeped in music right from the start. His great uncle was a concert pianist, and both his grandmother, Mamie Jo Adams, and mother Diane Johnston were songwriters. The latter crafted 'Miles & Miles Of Texas' for Gene Autry during the 1950s, while collaborating with her son — following his return from the Navy — on songs for rockabilly artists such as Mac Davis. Bob himself recorded some rockabilly singles under the name Don Johnston, before relocating to New York in 1964. There he secured a staff production job at Kapp Records and then at Columbia, producing Patti Page's hit rendition of 'Hush Hush, Sweet Charlotte'. As sung by Al Martino, this was the title number to the Bette Davis horror flick of the same name.
Columbia producer/arranger Bob Mersey was the man who handed Johnston the Patti Page assignment. However, when Bob Dylan parted ways with Tom Wilson — why has never been satisfactorily explained — Mersey poured cold water on Johnston's stated intention to work with the celebrated protest singer/songwriter on his album‑in‑progress.
"Why do you want to work with him?” Mersey asked Johnston. "He can't play the guitar, he breaks all the strings...” Since Doris Day's son, Terry Melcher, had recently produced the Byrds' debut album, Mr Tambourine Man, which included four Dylan compositions, Johnston thought Melcher might land the Highway 61 gig. However, he was wrong, and Johnston was handed the production reins by Columbia A&R exec John Hammond, who had signed Dylan to the label and produced his first recordings.
"The first time I worked with Dylan, I discovered that, thanks to some of the musicians overdubbing their parts, he had done more than 30 takes of 'Like A Rolling Stone',” Johnston recalls. "I said, 'I thought you'd do one take. You know what it is. You wrote the son of a bitch. If they want to overdub, they can overdub later or we can avoid overdubbing altogether. I thought you would do it like that.' He said, 'Well, let's try.' So we cut 'Tombstone Blues', the first take was the one we used, and after that I don't think we did more than one or two takes of anything.”
It was at Columbia's Studio A, on 52nd Street in New York City, that Dylan began working on the follow‑up to Highway 61 in October and November of 1965. On hand to provide the backing were the Hawks in the form of guitarist Robbie Robertson, bassist/violinist Rick Danko, keyboardist/saxophonist Garth Hudson and drummer Bobby Gregg. Also present were Al Kooper, guitarist Bruce Langhorne and keyboard player Paul Griffin.
"Those musicians worked in their own way, and they knew what they did and didn't want to do,” says Bob Johnston. "However, I told them that if they quit during a take, they could collect their coats on the way out the door. I didn't want the bass waiting for the guitar to come in before the pianist did his thing — 'Play all the way through. If you've got a band, it's gonna be good; if you don't have a band, it'll sound like shit.' So, that's what they did.”
However, while those sessions saw Dylan record an early version of 'Visions Of Johanna' (titled 'Freeze Out'), they only yielded one track that, back then, was considered worthy of release: the single 'Can You Please Crawl Out Your Window?'
It was largely the same story in January of '66, when three more sessions inside Studio A — featuring the Hawks (with Bobby Gregg and Sandy Konikoff alternating on drums), as well as Al Kooper, Paul Griffin and bass player William E Lee — only yielded one recording that made it onto Blonde On Blonde: the aforementioned 'One Of Us Must Know (Sooner Or Later)'. Two versions of 'Leopard‑skin Pill‑box Hat' didn't meet the composer's expectations, and it was at this point, devoid of inspiration and enough new material, that Dylan decided to cancel three further sessions and follow Bob Johnston's advice to switch scenery and personnel by travelling down to Nashville.
"Oh, I was really down,” Dylan would tell music critic Robert Shelton while touring the US just a couple of months later. "I mean, in 10 recording sessions, man, we didn't get one song... It was the band. But you see, I didn't know that. I didn't want to think that.”
The 14th February, 1966, was the date of Dylan's first session at Columbia's Studio A in Nashville. The large live area that had recently been converted from seven small booths featured the man himself placed centrally inside a glass booth, while the other musicians milled around him.
"They could all play and watch each other,” Johnston explains. "The room was so large, it looked like a football field, and the drums were in the middle, up against the back wall. Then, in the centre of the room, I had this glass booth built for Dylan, and he was in there with a table and chair — it was like his study. He'd sit in there, stand up, turn around and do whatever he wanted to do, and I usually had three mics in there so that if he turned his head to the left or right, I wouldn't miss anything.”
The initial Music Row session proved to be fruitful, with successful recordings of '4th Time Around' and 'Visions Of Johanna'. (Only 'Leopard‑skin Pill‑box Hat' still failed to make the grade.) Then again, while Dylan and his fellow northerners weren't yet familiar with the record‑making modus operandi in 'Music City USA', their Nashville contemporaries also weren't used to Dylan's improvisational approach in the studio or the physical appearance of some of his rock & roll colleagues.
"Al Kooper was great, man, as were all of those people, but he was worried about the country guys not liking him,” Johnston remarks. "When he got there, he had on high‑heeled boots, a big hat and a black cape that made him look like an undertaker. Well, he went to Ernest Tubb's Record Shop on Broadway, some guys chased after him and they cornered him in a phone booth outside. They were trying to get the door open, and he called Elvis Presley's buddy, Lamar Fike, who came and picked him up in his Cadillac convertible. It was hilarious. However, nobody knew Dylan. He could walk down the street and no one would bother him.”
Back in the studio, many of the musicians could also walk around unhindered within the vast recording space, courtesy of Bob Johnston ensuring they had long cables attached to their instruments... once he had pointed this out.
"Their speakers were all in different rooms,” he says, "and the guitarists had 50‑ or 60‑foot cords so they could walk anywhere they wanted to. They were scattered all over the room, and I had them move around on purpose. At first, I had the guitarists way up to the left and the bass player way in the back, and they looked as if they were thinking, 'Goddamn, why do we have to stand this far apart?' I told Dylan what I was doing, and when they started playing they didn't feel as if they could be heard, so they kept turning up their earphones and I was just laughing. Finally, I told them that's what the long cords were for — to move around the damn room and stand anywhere they wanted! So that's what they did.
"Spillage wasn't a problem with me, because I wanted everything that I heard. I just told everyone not to play anything that they didn't want to be heard, because I wouldn't be allowing them to come back in for overdubs and screw up the record. We were only gonna use what they did during the actual take.”
Meanwhile, whereas the live area was absolutely huge, the Studio A control room was less than ideal.
"There was a custom console with EQ that could be switched between 'pop' and 'country', and when I first worked there you looked out a little bitty glass window at the band and had to turn around to hear the speakers,” Johnston recalls. "Eventually, I had them put four speakers up on the wall and change quite a lot else, but they fought me all the way. I had two tape machines, and the first time I worked in there with Dylan, he said, 'Okay, I'm ready to go,' and I said, 'Roll the tape.' Well, the guy at the desk said, 'Roll the tape,' and another engineer at the door said, 'Roll the tape!' Then, down the hall, I could hear this guy say, 'OK, roll it,' and another guy in the distance shout out, 'Now?' The first guy said, 'Now.' The other one asked, 'Which button do I hit?' and he was told 'The big red light.' So he hit the button, and by that time Dylan was already through the first verse.
"I said, 'Hold it!' and Dylan said, 'What's the matter? What's going on?' I said, 'You've got to come in here.' When he came in, I said, 'This is what I have to do.' He said, 'What?' I said, 'Watch this... OK, you ready? Roll tape!' Again, the order went all the way down the hall, with the guy in the back asking, 'Which button do I hit?' We were in convulsions. Dylan said, 'What in the name of God are we going to do?' Well, I went in and moved the machine, only to be told, 'You can't touch that machine!' I said, 'Forget I touched it. Otherwise, we'll spend a whole lot of time going to court and CBS will fire your ass.' So, I moved the machine into the control room, and I also put everything on 7.5 [ips] tape.”
Following his first Nashville session that successfully captured '4th Time Around' and 'Visions Of Johanna', Dylan returned to the studio on the 15th February 1966, and asked to be left alone while he spent about six hours finishing a new composition. Then, after the musicians were woken up just before four in the morning of the 16th, they recorded three takes of 'Sad Eyed Lady Of The Lowlands', the first of which ended up on the album. Indeed, if ever there was an opportunity for them to familiarise themselves and get to grips with the main man's improvisational approach, this was it.
A soulful, 11‑minute, 23‑second ode to Dylan's then‑new wife, former Playboy Bunny Sarah Lowndes, 'Sad Eyed Lady Of The Lowlands' was set apart from the rest of the often‑witty yet acerbic Blonde On Blonde by occupying the double album's entire fourth side. Diving headlong into surreal imagery, the track features its author at his poetic peak as, playing harmonica and acoustic guitar to the band's traditional, loping 6/8 waltz arrangement, he nonchalantly sings about "your childhood flames on your midnight rug, and your Spanish manners and your mother's drugs, and your cowboy mouth and your curfew plugs...”
In Clinton Heylin's 2000 biography, Dylan: Behind The Shades, Take Two, drummer Kenny Buttrey recalled: "He ran down a verse and a chorus and he just quit and said, 'We'll do a verse and a chorus, then I'll play my harmonica thing. Then we'll do another verse and chorus and I'll play some more harmonica, and we'll see how it goes from there.' That was his explanation of what was getting ready to happen. Not knowing how long this thing was going to be, we were preparing ourselves dynamically for a basic two‑ to three‑minute record. Because records just didn't go over three minutes.
"If you notice that record, that thing after, like, the second chorus starts building and building like crazy, and everybody's just peaking it up 'cause we thought, 'Man, this is it. This is gonna be the last chorus and we've gotta put everything into it we can.' And he played another harmonica solo and went back down to another verse, and the dynamics had to drop back down to a verse kind of feel. After about five, six minutes of this stuff, we start looking at the clock, everyone starts looking at each other, we'd built to the peak of our limit and, bang, [there] goes another harmonica solo. After about 10 minutes of this thing we're cracking up at each other, at what we were doing. I mean, we peaked five minutes ago. Where do we go from here?”
Bob Johnston has a similar recollection: "When we were two minutes into the song, Dylan started to gain momentum and the musicians started to gain momentum. However, at the end of the first verse, they thought they had cut the three‑minute record, but then he started the second verse and they quickly latched on and started in again. This happened on every verse; they kept thinking it was the end of the song. Afterwards, he came into the control room and said, 'Let's hear it back,' and that was the cut we used. It was one of the prettiest things I ever heard in my life.
"Nobody ever counted off for Bob Dylan. 'One‑two‑three' — nobody did that. He had a metronome in his head, his foot started going, everyone else latched on and that was it. No matter what he cut, when he cut it, how he cut it or who he cut it with, it was always the same. He was a genius, and I never told him how to sing, when to sing, what to sing or where to sing. And I also never said, 'I don't like this,' or 'I don't like that.' I liked everything he did. I was awed by him and what he could do.”
Meanwhile, if the musicians were still reflecting on the 16th February studio session that captured 'Sad Eyed Lady Of The Lowlands' in the first of three takes, they found themselves gelling on similar territory the very next day when recording the equally rambling and surreal seven‑minute opus, 'Stuck Inside Of Mobile With The Memphis Blues Again'. Once again, Bob Johnston was happy to accommodate and realise Dylan's musical vision.
"He said, 'Man, I've got a blues thing I wanna do,' and we went straight into it,” Johnston recalls. "It was a 'Sad Eyed Lady Of The Lowlands' blues and it was an instant recording, as were most of his songs. We didn't work on them or anything, we just did them.”
This was clearly the case when, after returning to Nashville from some concert dates with the Hawks, Dylan nailed the remaining nine Blonde On Blonde tracks — 'Pledging My Time', 'Just Like A Woman', 'Absolutely Sweet Marie', 'Most Likely You Go Your Way (And I'll Go Mine)', 'Temporary Like Achilles', 'Rainy Day Women #12 & 35', 'I Want You', 'Leopard‑skin Pill‑box Hat' and 'Obviously Five Believers' — in just three sessions, on the 8th, 9th and 10th March. Beforehand, working on these songs in his hotel room, the composer was able to focus on his lyrics while Al Kooper played the piano and learned the tunes, so that the keyboardist could teach them to the band members in the studio before Dylan arrived.
"With 'Rainy Day Women', Dylan was sitting outside the studio, it was about two o'clock in the morning, and he said, 'Listen to this,'” Johnston recalls. "He played me the song and I said, 'That sounds like it's for a damn Salvation Army band.' He said, 'Can you get one?' and I told him, 'Probably not, but I can try.' So I called Charlie McCoy, and he called a trombone player [Wayne Butler], woke him up and he came down. Charlie also played the trumpet, and I put a drum around Kenny Buttrey's neck and had him bang it while marching around the studio. That was the first time I ever heard Dylan truly laugh. The record company didn't want that track out at all, but we rushed it out and it was a big hit.”
An unlikely single, 'Rainy Day Women #12 & 35' actually peaked at number two on the Billboard Hot 100 and at number seven in the UK, while 'I Want You' made the Top 20 on both sides of the Atlantic, 'Just Like a Woman' reached 33 in the US and 'Leopard‑skin Pill‑box Hat' topped out at number 10. As for Blonde On Blonde, its number nine placing in the US — where it would eventually attain double‑platinum status — was bettered by number three in the UK, and the record garnered universal critical acclaim.
Melding a compelling mixture of blues, folk, rock and country with endlessly intriguing wordplay and imagery, the album was hailed by Rolling Stone critic Dave Marsh as one of "the greatest in the history of rock & roll”.
"Blonde On Blonde was 20 years ahead of its time and it was the culmination of all we did,” asserts Bob Johnston, who is currently finishing work on an all‑star album project that he commenced more than a decade ago, pairing Carl Perkins with Johnny Cash, George Harrison, Tom Petty, Paul Simon, Willie Nelson and Bono. "I think Dylan is the only prophet we've had since Jesus, and in a couple of hundred years people will recognise this...” .
Track: 'Sad Eyed Lady Of The Lowlands'
Producer: Bob Johnston
Engineers: Neil Wilburn, Mike Figlio
Studio: Columbia Studio A (Nashville)
In a 1978 Playboy interview with Ron Rosenbaum, Dylan asserted, "The closest I ever got to the sound I hear in my mind was on individual bands in the Blonde On Blonde album. It's that thin, that wild mercury sound. It's metallic and bright gold, with whatever that conjures up. That's my particular sound.”
Bob Johnston, on the other hand, states: "What I wanted was that mercury sound on Highway 61 and the mountain sound on Blonde On Blonde, and that's what I got. I wanted people to centre on him. I didn't want them to centre on Kooper's organ playing or Robbie Robertson's lead guitar part. I wanted to centre on Dylan first, and I wanted people to hear what he had to say. From Highway 61 up until we stopped working together, I don't think I ever missed.”
Dylan's voice, described by David Bowie as being like "sand and glue”, changed with each album, ranging from the husky intonations of his earliest records and the affected slur of Blonde On Blonde to the country croon of Nashville Skyline. Yet, Bob Johnston asserts that, on the albums he produced, this was due purely to the singer, not the techniques employed to record him.
"What I used on his vocals — and what I used on Johnny Cash, Patti Paige, Marty Robbins and many others — was a [Neumann] U47 microphone with a power pack,” Johnston explains. "It was the old one and nothing was better. I put a baffle over the top of Dylan's guitar so he could play while he sang, and I also used some EQ on his voice, but I never tried to change his sound. All I did was change sounds in terms of the mechanics. Whatever Dylan did — from Highway 61 through Blonde On Blonde, John Wesley Harding, Nashville Skyline, Self Portrait and New Morning — happened because he himself had changed. I never knew what he was going to sound like and I never cared. He was growing.”
Producers: Chip Young, Billy Swan; Engineer: Chip Young
In 1974 Billy Swan walked into Chip Young's Young'un Sound studio and, in two takes, recorded a million-selling single that had taken him 20 minutes to write. This is how it was done...
Track: 'Hit Me With Your Rhythm Stick'
Producers: Nile Rodgers, Madonna, Stephen Bray • Engineer: Jason Corsaro
Producers: Richard Dashut, Ken Caillat, Fleetwood Mac
Producer: Alan Mair • Engineers: John Burns, Robert Ash
Producers: Tricky • Mark Saunders
Producer: Billy Sherrill • Engineer: Lou Bradley
Producer: Phil Spector • Engineer: Larry Levine
Producers: The Jam, Vic Coppersmith-Heaven • Engineers: Alan Douglas, Vic Coppersmith-Heaven
Producers: Depeche Mode, Daniel Miller, Gareth Jones • Engineer: Gareth Jones
Producer & Engineer: Les Paul
Producers: Robert Smith, Mike Hedges
Producers: Robin Millar, Sade Adu, Mike Pela, Ben Rogan
Artist: David Bowie; Producers: David Bowie, Tony Visconti; Studio: Hansa Ton, Berlin
Artist: The Sex Pistols; Producer: Chris Thomas; Engineer: Bill Price
Producers: Michael Jackson, Bill Bottrell • Engineer: Bill Bottrell
Producers: Duran Duran, Alex Sadkin, Ian Little; Engineers: Phil Thornalley, Pete Schwier
Artist: Kate Bush; Producer: Andrew Powell; Engineer: Jon Kelly
Artist: Tina Turner; Producer: Terry Britten; Engineer: John Hudson
Artist: The Rolling Stones; Engineer: Chris Kimsey
Producers: The Police, Hugh Padgham • Engineer: Hugh Padgham.
Artists: Natalie Cole & Nat 'King' Cole; Producer: David Foster; Engineer: Al Schmitt