You are here

Hot new Sample CDs on test

Sample Library By Dave Stewart & Oli Bell
Published September 2004

PCP80 Electric Grand *****


Hot new Sample CDs on testFirst manufactured in 1976, Yamaha's CP70 and CP80 electric grand pianos were a practical solution to the problem of using acoustic piano in a live rock group. By putting individual pickups on each note, Yamaha created a hybrid instrument that sounded pretty good when played acoustically, but could also be cranked up through a PA with no fear of feedback. While the CP-series pianos' somewhat cantankerous amplified sound wasn't to everyone's taste, their sturdy, biting, instantly recognisable tone went down well with discerning musicians — Peter Gabriel, Eddie Jobson, and George Duke learned to love the piano, and many keyboardists (myself included) continue to use a CP70 as a writing tool.

Composer/sound designer Akihito Okawa obviously shares in the nostalgia for this vintage keyboard, as he has lovingly sampled a CP80 in all its 88-note glory. The specs make impressive reading: Prominy's multi-format release comprises 24-bit/96kHz EXS24, Kontakt, and Halion versions with up to 20(!) velocity layers, plus a 16-bit/44.1kHz, 16-layer Gigastudio version comprising 2GB of samples. The two-DVD package also offers some lower-sampling-rate and 'lite' options. Loading the 16-velocity Gigastudio instrument takes a while, but that's understandable given the number of samples involved — most of the 88 notes use 16 dynamic layers plus a further 16 release triggers, resulting in a 256MB program containing nearly 2600 samples!

The musical effect is superb — having so many velocity splits makes transitions between dynamic layers totally undetectable. The CP80's range is perfectly replicated, from tiny, delicate tinklings to aggressively poky loud notes, the latter just the ticket for a high-decibel belt through 'Hit Me With Your Rhythm Stick'! The Gigastudio version offers only three programs: the 16-layer full Monty, a RAM-conserving eight-velocity version, and a small 'pedal-on' layer, designed to simulate the ringing effect introduced by the sustain pedal. (I found this had a negligible effect on the sound.) Due to programming limitations, the piano's built-in mono tremolo effect can only be enjoyed by Halion users.

From a pianist's point of view, performing with these samples feels just like playing the real thing, with none of the depressing artefacts one associates with sampled pianos. The multi-dynamic samples respond admirably to expressive and improvisational playing, and the provision of extremely quiet notes encourages a subtle touch. It takes a brave piano tuner to deal with the CP80's wayward, occasionally unmatched upper partials, but this piano has been brought bang into tune by an immaculate, expert tuning job. Certain endearing idiosyncrasies (the clanky, slightly reedy attack and thunky bass notes) are still in evidence, but they're part of the charm! Once again, a fine, endangered keyboard has been rescued from extinction by a fanatically detailed and diligent sampling job. Dave Stewart

EXS24, Gigastudio, Halion, and Kontakt 2-DVD-ROM set, $199 (around £108).

Prominy +1 949 451 1753.

Solo Strings *****


Hot new Sample CDs on testVSL's Pro Edition covers most angles of the orchestra, but failed to include solo viola and double bass. The Viennese completists will no doubt rectify this in a future update — meanwhile, anyone who wants to put together a sampled string quartet without first remortgaging their house should be aware of Solo Strings, which, in true Christmas spirit, brings the four members of the strings family together under one roof.

The solo violin and solo cello samples on Solo Strings are identical to those in Strings and Performance Set Pro Editions, reviewed in SOS March 2004. Back then, I singled out those two instruments for special praise, and can only repeat that their samples are absolutely stunning. Solo Strings ' viola closely matches the solo violin's array of musical styles, the exceptions being that the viola plays no spiccatos, grace notes, runs, or glissandi.

Having suffered my fair share of tired, uninspiring solo strings samples, I'm pleased to report that this solo viola is the best I've heard. The detailed, noise-free recording captures the instrument's rich, vibrant, autumnal tone in all its glory, and release triggers add a luxurious extra dimension. The player's subtle vibrato imparts emotion without going over the top, but for all you slaves of passion there's an expressive 'strong vibrato' option.

Also played with vibrato, the double bass pizzicatos might not be everyone's first choice for a jazz walking bass part, but their big, plump sound should be weighty enough for most applications. The arco samples pack power — there are some fierce bow attacks hiding amongst the diminuendos, and the sustains can comfortably handle all the subtleties of melodies, chords, and bass lines. This stately, versatile double bass perfectly complements the other three solo strings in a quartet setting.

Like the violin and cello, the viola and double bass work through a large number of stylistic variations (details of which appear in the March 2004 review), the only notable omission being harmonics. Things get even better when we move on to the performance samples — the viola's 'performance legatos' offer loud, portamento, accented, and quiet options, all of which sound convincingly organic when played under the control of the VSL Performance Tool 's Horizon Legato mode. The double bass performance legatos work well too, though for some reason the loud version utilises portamento on some intervals. Altogether, the four solo instruments supply more varieties of note repetition than you can shake a stick at.

Solo Strings ' huge size (over 30GB) should give a good indication of its musical scope. In effect, it costs around £10 per gigabyte in the UK — when you consider that 512MB Akai ROMs used to retail for £200, £296 seems a very fair deal for a library containing arguably the best collection of solo string samples in the world. Dave Stewart

EXS24 MkII and Gigastudio 5-DVD-ROM set, £296 including VAT.

Time & Space +44 (0)1837 55200.

Tool Shed Percussion *****


Hot new Sample CDs on testAs I'm sure I've said before, you can never have enough drum sounds, but sometimes getting new or original samples to play with can be tough. The nice people at Big Fish Audio have decided to help by putting together this library, which mixes some standard (and not so standard!) drum kits, standard percussion, and 'found' percussion into loops and hits. In total there are 49 construction kits, as well as an additional group of over 500 single hits. Each construction kit follows the standard format of a blast of the full drum loop, followed by the individual parts. The kits are a great mixture of drums, odd/exotic percussion, and bits of junk or tools. For example, the Roller kit contains a Gretsch bass drum, a metal pipe, a parade snare, sandpaper blocks, maracas, a selection of toms, a wooden block, and a slap on someone's 'large round belly'! Other sounds that sit on the stranger end of the scale include saw blades, buckets (both full and empty), tape measures, and a metal leaf rake.

With such a mismatch of sounds, there is a danger that the end results could be a complete din, but the full mixes are actually really good — with a little editing these would work well as percussion beds for most musical genres, especially for soundtrack work. Tempos cover 50-170bpm, and there's also a nice mixture of time signatures, but for me it's the component hits, shakes, and crashes that make Tool Shed Percussion really interesting. These individual hits and loops can be chopped up and slotted into just about any type of rhythm track. Containing both vintage 'normal' kit, some interesting percussion, and other 'found' instruments like crisp packets, suitcases, and paint rollers, these samples can be taken as is or processed to give some some really original-sounding percussive sounds.

I must also mention the excellent included booklet, which is clear, uncluttered, and full of information. Along with the track and bpm listings, it includes detailed information on all the drums and strange percussion used. Size, construction, type of beater, and age of kit are all listed. This is a real plus point that helps to underline the thought and care that the producers, Kent Carter and Pat Campbell, have put into this collection. Other sample CD companies please take note!

On the downside, a few of the samples are quite noisy, with some unpleasant audio side effects thrown in, although that's hardly unexpected when thumping merry hell out of a huge oil tank outdoors! Also, perhaps there are slightly too many standard drum kit sounds for a sample CD with this title, but these really are only very minor niggles that fail to put a dampener on what is a high-quality and well-thought-out collection of truly original percussion sounds that can't fail to inspire and add some much-needed interest to the dullest of rhythm tracks. Oli Bell

Audio CD + Acid ised WAV/REX CD-ROM 4-CD set, £56.95 including VAT.

Time + Space +44 (0)1837 55200.

+44 (0)1837 55400.

Woodwind Collection Expanded Edition ****


US composer Tim Smith set up Westgate Studios to distribute his custom sound libraries. Tim's Woodwind Collection started life as a single CD, but with the addition of new instruments and articulations, it grew into a 1.52GB Gigastudio two-CD set. The expanded edition includes all the first version's samples, and the two editions are separately available — for a comparison of their contents, check out his web site.

A quick listen to the oboe and English horn gives a good insight into the library's character — both have a bright, clear tone, but, being dryly recorded in mono with no release triggers, they lack the sumptuous depth of more expensively-produced libraries. However, slap on a little reverb and you're in business; the instruments' vibrato sustains have a lovely lyrical quality, their positive attack and incisive timbre being ideal for poignant, expressive lead lines. Moving on, I also enjoyed the sweet, pastoral tone of the flute, and its marcato short notes sounded excellent in chordal passages. The flute and piccolo both play a selection of fast upward runs spanning an interval of a fourth — a useful extra, as such musical flourishes usually sound bogus when programmed with single notes. Sadly, there's no alto flute — Tim explains that this was omitted because no-one asked for it. D'oh! I've put in my request, but its probably too late now...

The whole clarinet family — 'E' flat, 'B' flat, and bass — is here, each instrument sounding bright and effective, with nice snappy staccatos and rock-steady sustains. Combining jocularity with a sad lyricism, the bassoon also sounds in the best of health, and a rich-toned, powerful contrabassoon provides some profoundly deep support. Great stuff, but there's more: the instrumentation here extends beyond the orchestral, supplying a recorder family (sopranino, two types of soprano, and alto), an ineffably sweet sound nowadays not much heard outside of historical documentaries. The library also has a tin whistle and a penny whistle (or flageolet), the latter contributing bends, mordents, and grace notes, very handy for programming Irish folk tunes. Overall, I was impressed by all the instruments' accurate tuning and controlled delivery, especially evident in their beautifully precise trills.

This well-organised, comprehensive package offers fifteen instruments, a well-chosen selection of performance styles and up to four dynamic layers. None of the long notes are looped, but with sustains lasting around nine seconds that's not the end of the world. this library proves you don't need a million-dollar budget to create a good sample library, just good players, a decent recording setup, and the musical experience to know which articulations will work when sampled! If you're looking for reasonably-priced woodwind samples to supplement your favourite orchestral brass and strings, this musically solid set comes highly recommended. Dave Stewart

Gigastudio 2-CD-ROM set, $199 (around £108).

Westgate Studios +1 817 281 6212.