When Bombay Bicycle Club chose to work with prolific producer John Congleton, both band and producer found themselves having to adapt...
Back in 2016, Bombay Bicycle Club announced that they were taking an "indefinite hiatus", making many wonder if the North London band had split for good. The quartet had gone out on a high: their 2014 album So Long, See You Tomorrow was their first to reach number one, and they'd sold out the 19,000-capacity Earls Court Arena in London. But, after years of near-constant touring and recording since they were in their teens, they felt burned out.
During this interregnum, singer Jack Steadman indulged his passion for funk and soul with an album under the name of Mr Jukes, bassist Ed Nash released his own solo record as Toothless, drummer Suren de Saram sessioned for Jessie Ware and guitarist Jamie MacColl studied political science at university. Then came a call from the group's management to remind them that the 10th anniversary of their debut album I Had The Blues But I Shook Them Loose was coming in 2019. Plans were hatched to get back together to perform a series of shows playing the record in full. But, at the same time, it didn't feel fitting to the band members to be indulging in nostalgia when they weren't yet even into their '30s. So, four years on from So Long..., they've regrouped and returned with their fifth album, Everything Else Has Gone Wrong.
Whereas So Long had been self–produced by Jack Steadman, this time he was keen to work with a third party. His co-producer of choice was Texan–born, LA-based John Congleton, who has a long track record that encompasses acts such as St. Vincent, Angel Olsen, Explosions In The Sky and many more.
"I think it helps to have someone who isn't a member of the band as the authority figure," says Steadman. "'Cause there's going to be so many compromises when you're making a record, or people disagreeing. And if you find someone that you all respect and trust, you can all look to them as kind of the final say. That's a way to just move things along, rather than spending weeks arguing. Sometimes you just have to choose one direction and then move on. And I think you need another producer to do that."
For his part, Congleton was more than happy with the remit the band gave him: to push them out of their comfort zones. "Any band that's made four records is gonna settle into patterns, whether they want to or not," he points out. "The last record they'd made, they recorded it themselves and were super-pixelated inside the process. I think they knew for sure that they didn't want to do that again, just for the sheer fact that it took them a year to make. So, I think they needed somebody who could come in and just get it done.
"In terms of pushing them out of their comfort zones, I think that we totally understand each other. But at the same time, I'm not nearly as cerebral as them. I'm very in the moment, kind of spontaneous: 'Let's capture a feeling and not worry about the details too much.' Whereas they have a tendency to sort of sit there and really scratch their chins over every decision. I think it was painful for them to be with somebody who didn't encourage that. That would cause them anxiety sometimes, but ultimately we found our flow."
John Congleton: "I'm very in the moment, kind of spontaneous: 'Let's capture a feeling and not worry about the details too much.' Whereas they have a tendency to sort of sit there and really scratch their chins over every decision."
Straight away, Congleton recognised certain familiar patterns in Steadman's songwriting that could use a little reshaping. "I'd get to a certain point in the song and have a little drop down and then build back up again," says Steadman. "John noticed it and was like, 'We should try and stop doing that so much.' That instantly made us feel like we'd made the right choice, 'cause someone's pushing us to do things differently."
"Yeah, there were some global comments like that I had," laughs Congleton. "'You always do this thing in your song.' I don't think they'd ever even realised it. You don't see it. But, you know, that's why you bring in somebody from the outside."