You are here

Page 2: Rhodes MK8

Electric Piano By Huw Rees
Published January 2022

Playing The MK8

The testing room in the Rhodes factory was set up with a variety of different Rhodes: a Mark 5, a Mark 1 ‘suitcase’, a Mark 2 and a MIDI‑equipped Mark 7 that had been extensively modified by Dan. Completing the circle of Rhodes were two MK8 prototypes, one very stylish with an olive green lid and the walnut case option, the other the main testing prototype which was finished in standard black Tolex. Sitting down at this piano, the massive step up in quality from all previous Rhodes was obvious. The standard of Tolex finish and the painting of the lid are top‑class, and the keybed really does feel like it comes from a Steinway.

Sitting down at this piano, the massive step up in quality from all previous Rhodes was obvious.

And how did it play? The MK8 is a beast of a Rhodes, with tons of bark and bite across the register. Getting back to the classic, warmer Fender Rhodes sound from the early ’70s certainly seems to have been the priority and the tone reflects that, as does the built‑in EQ: the treble dial in the front rail unit sounds calibrated more to control the high‑mid frequencies in which the Rhodes bark is most prominent, so those looking for a Dyno‑style treble boost will be disappointed (to be fair, no‑one has used that sound since 1987). The mid EQ allows all sorts of sound‑sculpting possibilities even before the envelope follower is introduced. The modulation and mixing options on the tremolo section are really incredibly musical, and I could quite happily have sat experimenting with this synth‑Rhodes until late into the night. But eventually remembering that the purpose of our visit was to review the instrument and not to inflict my Jan Hammer tribute on Dan’s staff, I managed to turn the tremolo dial back down to zero and get my lab coat back on. In order that we could hear right into the soul of the MK8, Dan kindly agreed to bypass the electronics and take a feed straight off the harp into one of the test amps.

In the midrange, the MK8 was still barking away like crazy. But I made sure first to test sustain pedal response, one of the most difficult things to get right on a Rhodes. Press down sustain pedal, play wide‑span random chord, release chord, then release pedal very gently. The occasional hanging note while half‑pedalling is very hard to eliminate, but if this is happening on multiple notes, and if certain octaves are unbalanced, then there is a problem. The MK8 performed admirably here, with clean, even note cutoffs. The stopping power of the dampers was also extremely good across the board, so that even the hardest staccato hit was stopped dead. All Dan’s attention to detail with the damper arms and felts has paid off.

Escapement on a Rhodes is the distance between hammer tip and tine after the tine has been struck, but with the key still fully depressed. Due to the wide swing of Rhodes tines, especially low down, it is not really feasible to set the action to play as sensitively as that of an acoustic piano. It is possible to spend a very long time as a tech walking the line between a sensitive action on one hand and ‘spud’ notes on the other. Escapement is a matter of taste, however, and there are plenty of players who like it set with a bit in reserve. This is how Dan had set the test MK8 up, so it was a fraction high for me, but with the luxurious feel of that keybed under my hands it still felt amazing. Later I was shown a MK8 in the workshop with a lower escapement setting, so there is definitely scope for adjusting touch sensitivity to taste.

In terms of the basics of voicing, there are different schools of thought about how close the pickup head should sit to the tine and how high the tine should rest in relation to the pickup head, as well as how these two adjustments should vary across the keyboard range. Tine height regulates the ratio of fundamental and harmonics in a note. A setting too high will result in a dull, muddy sound, while a setting too low will sound nasal as excessive second harmonic is introduced. Even further and the note will jump an octave! The distance the tine is set from the pickup regulates volume and dynamic, with a closer setting giving more of both, but an overly aggressive adjustment in a search for extra bite can result in the tine striking the pickup head when hit hard. The MK8 was voiced very close, with a really nice harmonic mix, and in my brief experiment with pickup placement and tine voicing, I found the changes in timbre and volume vary pretty much as they do on an original Rhodes. Tine sustain was mostly consistent across the board: just a few tonebar clips, which increase sustain on treble tone generators, had been needed in the top octave.

Selling Points

So if you are in the market for a top‑quality electro‑mechanical piano, does the MK8 represent a good buy? It carries a high price tag, but compared to buying an original Rhodes, it has a number of advantages. First, the last Rhodes came out of the factory in 1985, so by now, most examples are in need of a major overhaul which can cost a considerable sum. With a MK8 all the components are brand new, and many, such as the keybed, electronics and case, are of far superior quality to the original. And you get basically a Mark 5 action — try finding one of those for a reasonable price in anything like playable condition! Second, customer service. Dan is very keen to build a good relationship with MK8 owners, as well as the wider Rhodes community, so there will be the opportunity to talk through the initial setup of your MK8 prior to purchase as well as plenty of tech support afterwards.

Third, the name rail electronics. To match these with another piano, you would need to budget for a few Moogerfoogers, and then still be lacking the firmware updates and the directness of the name‑rail controls. Fourth, price differential. Even though the MK8 is expensive, original Rhodes have risen so much in price over the last couple of years that the difference is nowhere near what it would have been three or four years ago. Fifth, options to customise. You will be able to specify lid/pedal colour, Tolex, case material, and whether the name rail should be black or silver. Then throw in the ability to fill up the right‑hand side of the name rail with effects, and maybe add to your MK8 with future innovations from the factory. Sixth, convenience. The clever integrated stand and the weight reduction, the relocation of the audio outputs and the new sustain pedal all make the MK8 very easy to live with. Seventh, and last but not least, supporting local industry and innovation. The new Rhodes company has the potential to change how music manufacturing works in the UK, as well as offering a template business model for genuine reproduction of any sought‑after vintage musical instrument.

The New Rhodes Company

The main developer behind the Rhodes MK8 is Dan Goldman. Dan’s passionate about Rhodes pianos, having worked with them for almost 30 years. The first part of this was spent as a performer, most notably with Morcheeba, before Dan built up his own Rhodes repair business, becoming one of the most renowned techs in Europe.

The MK8 is assembled by hand in Rhodes Music’s Leeds workshop.The MK8 is assembled by hand in Rhodes Music’s Leeds workshop.It turns out that the MK8 has partly come to fruition from a longstanding business arrangement between Joe Brandstetter, the owner of the Rhodes trademark, and Matt Pelling, now the chairman of Rhodes Music Group Ltd. In 2007, the Rhodes Mark 7 was unveiled by Joe’s Rhodes Music Corporation, and it was around this time that Matt was granted rights to use the Rhodes trademark for his companies Loopmasters and Plugin Boutique. When production of the Mark 7 finished and the RMC ceased to operate, Joe’s direct involvement in the manufacture of electric pianos came to an end. But as the owner of the Rhodes trademark, he was keen that any future use of the Rhodes name would only be in the development of the next generation of true electromechanical pianos. As Joe already had a productive business relationship with Matt, it seemed logical to explore the possibility that Matt could take on the manufacturing rights. After long negotiations, an agreement was reached which resulted in Joe retaining legal ownership of the Rhodes trademark, but the new UK‑based manufacturing business Rhodes Music Group Ltd having exclusive 50‑year rights to the Rhodes name.

Then began the process of recruiting a team to develop a new electric piano, including the vital role of a tech who could oversee the whole process, as well as making decisions about design and parts procurement. Dan was an obvious choice: as well as wide experience performing on and servicing Rhodes pianos, as the UK contact for Mark 7 service he was already highly regarded by Joe.

The actual development process began relatively recently, in 2019. Instead of resorting to purchasing parts from already established vintage keyboard parts suppliers, the intention was to re‑engineer every aspect of the Rhodes concept, modifying and improving some elements of the original Rhodes, and starting from the ground up in other areas. All components of the MK8 would be directly procured by the company and developed under close supervision.

Dan has worked hard to establish close working relationships with local manufacturers, as replicating the classic Rhodes sound with modern technology has needed intensive and ongoing collaboration. Except for the keybed, all MK8 components come from UK suppliers, most based in or near Leeds. For some aspects of the MK8, numerous iterations of parts have been required, so it has been invaluable for Dan to be able to visit a supplier at short notice for a quick test of a prototype component. As much of the prototyping was initially done at small scale, it was often difficult for Dan to find a manufacturer prepared to get involved, but the suppliers who did get on board eventually became enthusiastic about the idea of reviving an iconic musical instrument! Having such tight control over the manufacturing process also allows planning for the future: Dan discussed with us the potential to develop more versions of the MK8, as well as branching out into parts supply and manufacture of other types of electromechanical keyboards.

The Vintage Vibe Piano

The main competition for the MK8 comes from the Vintage Vibe Piano. This is a refined Rhodes in all but name, with the internals based on the classic Fender Rhodes models produced from around 1970 to 1975 with the half‑wood, half‑plastic hammers (Vintage Vibe now mold these in a single piece for extra durability). After a day servicing original Rhodes pianos at ep-service.nl I would quite often head to the upstairs studio and sit down at a Vintage Vibe Piano to reference how a well set‑up Rhodes should sound and play.

Having been on the market for a number of years the Vintage Vibe Piano is now a mature product with every component tried and tested. Since it was first released in 2008, many innovations have been made to the design, particularly around weight reduction, action regulation and preamp electronics. Vintage Vibe managed to obtain the rotary swaging machine from the Torrington company on which original Rhodes tines were manufactured, so the sound of the Vintage Vibe Piano is completely authentic. And in my experience of installing Vintage Vibe tines as replacements in original Rhodes, the quality is faultless.

There are many different options available; 64 or 73‑note keyboard ranges, beautifully finished glass fibre sparkle‑top lids in a variety of colours and a suitcase‑style amplifier, as well as many different custom finishes. The exterior owes a lot to the design of the Wurlitzer 200‑series pianos, though the footprint has been enlarged to accommodate a Rhodes action. While lacking the contemporary style of the MK8, the approach to weight reduction in the Vintage Vibe Piano has been ruthless, so even though it has a wooden keybed, the equivalent 73‑note piano weighs in at just 60lbs. Vintage Vibe Pianos can be a little hard to come by in the UK as there is currently no established sales outlet, but it is possible to import them from the USA, and the team in the factory in New Jersey are very cool to speak with over the phone.

Pros

  • Fantastic sounding.
  • Ultra‑stylish modern industrial design.
  • Groundbreaking name‑rail electronics.
  • Mark 5‑style action featuring Steinway keybed quality.
  • Innovative modern tine production process.
  • Assembled in the UK from mostly British‑made parts.

Cons

  • Still new so untested under heavy gigging/long‑term use.
  • Larger and heavier than the equivalent Vintage Vibe Piano.
  • Currently available only as a 73‑note version.

Summary

In terms of the development of Harold Rhodes’ concept in the modern era, the MK8 is a breakthrough. The revolution in tine manufacturing technology, the pioneering application of modern synth electronics to an electro‑mechanical piano and the cutting‑edge industrial design put it way ahead, and offer enormous potential for further development in the near future. The new Rhodes company is an impressive entity in itself, with a focus on keeping parts supply local and boundless enthusiasm for making the MK8 the best Rhodes yet.

Information

From £8244 including VAT.

www.rhodesmusic.com

From $9450.

www.rhodesmusic.com